Viewpoint: NWE LPG market to be driven by US exports

  • Market: LPG
  • 12/12/18

Steady US LPG export volumes this winter will weigh on northwest Europe propane prices, as demand is likely to be stagnant compared with the previous year. Propane will stay at a discount to naphtha, and petrochemical demand will as usual act as the balance for the former.

US seasonal stockdraws began late this year. Consecutive weeks of draws started in November from a peak of 84.5mn bl, compared with a mid-September start from 82.2mn bl last year. US propane stocks totalled 79.8mn bl in the week ending 30 November, 7pc higher than at the same time last year. More importantly, restocking has been accompanied by steady LPG exports — an average 911,000 b/d between August and November, compared with 808,000 b/d in the same period last year.

Three to four very large gas carriers (VLGCs) will arrive monthly from the US in the first quarter of next year — a number in line with the first half of this year. This flow could fall to between two and three in the second quarter, when regional demand for domestic heating will drop.

The US export levels have kept propane large cargo cif ARA (Amsterdam-Rotterdam-Antwerp) values low compared with crude and naphtha. The propane-naphtha spread averaged -$58.5/t in November, compared with -$13/t in the same month last year. This kept petrochemicals producers in the propane buyers' pool as winter got underway, a situation likely to continue throughout the winter as geopolitical developments support the steady arrival of US tonnes.

China, a major importer of US LPG for its growing network of propane dehydrogenation (PDH) plants, applied a 25pc import tariff on US LPG in August, as trade tensions escalated. The move was by-and-large anticipated and US exports were diverted to other destinations. Six VLGCs shipped US LPG to northwest Europe in October, up from three in the same month last year, and four moved on that route in November compared with one a year earlier.

This frequency will continue next year, as US export capacity ramps up. The Mariner East 2 pipeline has started taking commitments for transport of natural gas liquids (NGLs), which include LPG, from the Marcellus shale in Pennsylvania to the Marcus Hook export terminal. It will come on line by year-end, and on reaching full capacity by the third quarter of 2019 will boost the terminal's export capacity to 6-8 cargoes/month, from 2-3/month currently. The journey to Europe from the Atlantic coast terminal takes around 12 days. Midstream firm Enterprise will expand its export capacity on the US Gulf coast by 175,000 b/d to 720,000 b/d by the second half of next year.

The increased US LPG export volumes will only find their way to Europe if local buyers offer competitive netbacks compared with their Asia-Pacific counterparts. The number of VLGCs directed to Europe can dry up if European premiums fall below those of competing Asia-Pacific buyers.

The European LPG market has felt only a limited effect from US sanctions against Iran, which is the source of marginal tonnes. Imports from Russia are more substantial, especially from the Sibur-operated Ust-Luga terminal in the Baltic Sea that has exported around 200,000 t/month so far this year. These could fall should the EU impose sanctions in reaction to Russia's annexation of Crimea, a possibility recently revived by tensions on the Azov Sea. In the absence of any punitive moves, Russian LPG exports to Europe will remain steady next year.

With US exports steady, propane prices will hover at a $50-75/t discount to naphtha, in line with the previous two winters, and only briefly move below or above this range. Propane was at a premium to naphtha for several weeks last winter because of a shortage of US exports, which will not repeat this winter.

Demand for heating, which lifts prices in winter, will be stagnant in northwest Europe this year. The forecast is for mild temperatures except for a colder period on both sides of the English Channel and over Portugal in February.

Petrochemical firms will as ever act as the balance for the propane-naphtha spread. With propane at a significant discount, it is likely some crackers will use it as feedstock this winter. Petrochemical firms will curb their buying of propane when the propane-naphtha spread gets closer to -$50/t, and may resell some product to local buyers. This would ease upward pressure on propane prices.

Naphtha prices are likely to remain weak and the crack negative in the first half of next year, because US gasoline stocks are high and demand is faltering in Asia-Pacific. This will keep the propane-naphtha spread narrow even when the ratio of propane to Atlantic basin crude benchmark North Sea Dated reaches unseasonably low levels, such as sub-parity.

Propane's ratio to Dated has been volatile in recent years, bottoming at around 75pc in 2014 and peaking just above 120pc last year. Strong demand for domestic heating keeps the regional market reactive to supply gaps, which can send propane prices to a premium to crude. The flexibility offered by US supply, in terms of availability and short sailing time, reduced this volatility this year and put pressure on propane values. The ratio of propane prices to Dated will remain between 90pc and 110pc during the winter, then decline slowly in the second quarter when heating demand fades out.

Propane prices will quickly fall in the spring when warmer weather removes one main source of demand, and the petrochemical turnaround season — which begins in May — removes the other. The derivatives market indicates propane large cargo cif ARA prices will fall by around $30/t between February and May, at constant crude prices.

Rhine river water levels will continue to raise concerns for distribution. The average level at bottleneck Kaub averaged just 48cm throughout October. Levels have risen recently, but forecasts are for a further fall. If freezing temperatures arrive and stay in northwest Europe before the river has been able to refill sustainably, this could generate significant supply problems for German retailers and end-users.

Butane large-cargo cif ARA spot activity was lacklustre this year, with only two deals recorded in the open trading discussion. With little buying interest, the ratio of butane to naphtha has fallen to 80pc in early December, a few percentage points below the 15-year average range. Butane prices will remain at a steep discount to naphtha during the winter, but could find its place as the preferential petrochemical feedstock in periods of propane tightness. This would put a floor to the value of butane at around 75pc of naphtha.

Demand for butane in northwest Europe competes with the Mediterranean market. A pattern emerged in the later part of this year of US VLGCs unloading half their shipment in a Mediterranean port before heading to northwest Europe with the other half. This could benefit US producers, as exporters benefit from the scale economies of a VLGC without saturating one market. Butane imports from the US will especially become important as new petrochemical plants come online in the coming years.

UK petrochemical firm Ineos said it requires imports of more than 1.5mn t/yr to Europe to help supply its planned 750,000 t/yr PDH cracker and 1mn t/yr ethane cracker, either at Antwerp or at Rotterdam. These have a schedule to start by 2023 or 2024. Ineos will commission a significant new butane storage facility in 2020. Austria's Borealis plans to begin production at its new Kallo PDH plant, with 740,000 t/yr targeted output, in early 2022.

The US will be the source of additional LPG supply, as production will continue to rise. Enterprise expects US NGLs output to increase by 67pc from this year's level to 8.2mn b/d by 2025. Most of this increase will go to export.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
25/03/24

Vietnam’s Long Son extends cracker shutdown to June

Vietnam’s Long Son extends cracker shutdown to June

Singapore, 25 March (Argus) — Vietnam's sole cracker operator Long Son Petrochemical (LSP) has extended the shutdown of its cracker and associated downstream units in Ba Ria-Vung Tau to June, to address technical issues. LSP shut its cracker and downstream units on 21 February because of equipment issues. Siam Cement (SCG), the parent company of LSP, subsequently issued a force majeure on products the following day. SCG was initially expecting the cracker to restart in about 2-4 weeks after the shutdown in February. But the firm filed a statement to the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) on 22 March, stating that the technical difficulty is still under investigation and the LSP complex is expected to restart in June. LSP's cracker is a mixed feed cracker with a nameplate capacity of 950,000 t/yr for ethylene, 400,000 t/yr for propylene and a 100,000 t/yr butadiene extraction unit. Downstream units are polymer-focused, with a 500,000 t/yr high-density polyethylene (HDPE) plant, a 500,000 t/yr linear low-density polyethylene (LLDPE) unit and a 400,000 t/yr polypropylene (PP) unit. SCG offered spot HDPE, LLDPE and PP supplies from its new LSP complex to the market earlier this year but has ceased offers since late February, after the force majeure announcement. SCG also stated in its statement filed to the SET that its Rayong Olefins (ROC) cracker in Map Ta Phut, Thailand has resumed operations. The producer is expected to ramp up production at its 920,000 t/yr HDPE unit and 720,000 t/yr PP unit in Thailand following the restart of the ROC cracker, and will resume supply of these grades to the market. The ROC cracker was restarted late last week and has achieved on-specification olefins products since then, according to sources close to the company. The cracker was shut for maintenance since mid-November 2023. The ROC cracker has a nameplate capacity of 800,000 t/yr of ethylene and 400,000 t/yr propylene. SCG also owns another cracker at the same site — the Map Ta Phut Olefins cracker with capacity of 1mn t/yr of ethylene and 500,000 t/yr of propylene. Both the crackers are currently operating at near-full run rates. By Yee Ying Ang, Brian Leonal and Toong Shien Lee Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

US Fed signals 3 rate cuts this year, holds rate steady


20/03/24
News
20/03/24

US Fed signals 3 rate cuts this year, holds rate steady

Houston, 20 March (Argus) — Federal Reserve policymakers kept the target interest rate unchanged at a 23-year high today while officials signaled they still expect to make three quarter-point rate cuts later this year. Fed officials, in their latest economic projections, expect the the target rate range will end the year near a midpoint of 4.6pc, unchanged from December's projections. That implies three quarter-point cuts, even as inflation has ticked up and job growth has surprised to the upside in recent months. "We believe our policy rate is likely at its peak in this tightening cycle," chair Jerome Powell said in prepared remarks after the meeting. "If the economy evolves broadly as expected, it will likely be appropriate to begin dialing back policy restraint at some point this year." The Fed's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) held the federal funds target rate unchanged at 5.25-5.5pc. It was the fifth consecutive meeting in which the Fed held rates steady following 11 increases from March 2022 through July last year that amounted to the most aggressive hiking campaign in four decades. "If we ease too much or too soon, we could see inflation come back," Powell said during a press conference after the decision. "If we ease too late, we can do unnecessary harm to employment," he said, adding that the Fed remained "data dependent" in determining its rate moves. "The economy is strong, the labor market is strong, inflation has come way down and that gives us the ability to evaluate this question carefully," he said. The decision to keep rates steady was widely expected. CME's FedWatch tool, which tracks fed funds futures trading, had assigned a 99pc probability to the Fed holding rates steady today while giving 64pc odds of a quarter point rate decline in June. Futures markets had earlier expected cuts to begin in March. Today's decision comes as the chief of the European Central Bank said today that the ECB may begin to lower its target rate in June if inflation continues to ease and that further cuts would be "data dependent." The Fed's economic projections see core Personal Consumption Expenditures inflation, the Fed's favorite measure of inflation, falling to 2.6pc to end this year from a prior forecast for 2.4pc. Policymakers see inflation falling to 2.2pc next year. They see the lower end of the Fed target range falling to 3.9pc in 2025, compared with the December projection of 3.6pc for late 2025. The latest policy meeting comes as the Consumer Price Index (CPI) has proven sticky, averaging 3.2pc in the five months through February, down from a peak of 9.1pc in June 2022. US job growth has consistently surprised to the upside and continues to top pre-Covid levels, while GDP growth topped an average 4pc in the second half of 2023. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US’ industry-led carbon capture model is best: Panel


19/03/24
News
19/03/24

US’ industry-led carbon capture model is best: Panel

Calgary, 19 March (Argus) — Government policy is critical in spurring investment in carbon capture and storage (CCS) and the US model appears to be a welcome standard compared with other jurisdictions. "Long term, [CCS] must be led by the industries and commercially viable for it to be sustainable, robust and scale," 1PointFive president Jeff Alvarez told the CERAWeek by S&P Global conference in Houston, Texas, on Tuesday. "In the short term, the role of government policy is extremely important," Alvarez continued, whose company is a subsidiary of Occidental Petroleum and the largest handler of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the world for enhanced oil recovery. The US tax credits through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) appear to be spurring more investment compared with policies in the UK, and that is largely due to it having a broad goal of lowering CO2 and giving industry greater latitude in how it achieves that, panelists said. "We need what you've got in America now," said University of Oxford professor Myles Allen. "Incentivizing people to actually get [CO2] back into the ground. That's the crucial incentive we're lacking" in the UK and Europe. "The industry is pretty good at designing these things. And this is why we need a think, big picture, about the incentives," said Allen, and then to let the industry work out the value chain to make sure it happens. "We love to make things complicated in Europe." There are 17 projects in the EU that have not gone past the final investment decision (FID) stage, according to International Association of Oil and Gas Producers (IOGP) chief executive Graham Henley. "That highlights that there is a lot more to be done in the policy space to de-risk these investments for the operators in the near-term," Henley said, while also noting the technological upside the projects still represent. "What we're seeing now around the world is many, many first-of-its-kind projects, and whenever you implement first-of-its-kind projects you uncover problems," said Henley. "So don't judge the CCS technology by some of the examples that are around today, which are really pioneers and there's a lot more that we can do." "A lot of these [projects] are bespoke," said Alvarez, noting one of his observations are challenges on the commercial side of proposed projects. "Can the whole value chain be successful? Because if it can't . . . the whole project fails." "Policy is much more important early on and hopefully that will be supported by other mechanisms that can survive on their own," said Alvarez. By Brett Holmes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Private sector loses ground in Mexican LPG market


19/03/24
News
19/03/24

Private sector loses ground in Mexican LPG market

Falling imports were offset by Pemex's increased domestic output, with Mexico's nationalist policies continuing to favour the company, writes Antonio Gozain Mexico City, 19 March (Argus) — Private-sector operators lost ground to state-owned oil firm Pemex in Mexico's LPG market last year as a result of higher domestic output from Pemex, falling rates of theft and energy policies favouring the company. Pemex's share of domestic LPG sales grew to 62.1pc last year — including wholesale distribution to retailers — up from 61.2pc in 2022 and 49.7pc in 2020, which was the lowest in its history. The company had a monopoly on the market before Mexico's 2014 energy reforms. Pemex sold 166,400 b/d (5.24mn t/yr) of LPG in 2023, up by 4pc from 159,400 b/d in 2022, according to the company. This increase was also supported by firm demand for LPG in Mexico. No data on consumption are available, but Mexico's total LPG imports plus domestic output stood at 292,400 b/d last year, 4pc higher than in 2022. Pemex's LPG imports fell by 1pc to 76,100 b/d in 2023, while private-sector companies' imports also fell by 1pc to 114,000 b/d, according to the energy ministry Sener. But these declines were more than absorbed by Pemex because it hiked domestic production. The company's LPG output increased by 11pc to 102,300 b/d in 2023, partly as a result of increased investment in its refining capacity since 2019, although about 84pc of this was from gas processing. President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador's administration has pursued a nationalistic policy to support Pemex through restrictive regulations. Although the 2014 energy reform remains in force by law, in practice Sener and autonomous energy regulator CRE have aligned with Lopez Obrador, cancelling or not granting permits for private-sector firms at all levels of the fuel value chain. Still, private-sector firms have over 4,700 permits for LPG distribution in the country, according to CRE. Another challenge for private-sector companies and Pemex has been LPG theft, which is predominantly done by tapping the state-owned company's pipelines. The problem has escalated as criminal gangs have shifted from gasoline and diesel to LPG owing to a government crackdown on targeting pipelines of the former two products. Yet Pemex reported it lost 179,000t of LPG to theft in 2023, down by 8pc from 194,500t in 2022, following a transparency request for data from Argus. Illegal taps on its LPG pipelines fell by 2pc to 2,470, the data show. But this would seemingly contradict previous Pemex data that showed the company had lost 175,000t in January-August 2023 alone, unless theft had stopped in the final quarter, as well as data from LPG distributors' association Amexgas, which suggested illegal taps were on course to rise by 54pc to over 3,800 in 2023.Pemex did not respond to an Argus request for comment on the data. Mexico's LPG retail prices have increased this year on rising US propane, althoughthe government continues to shield customers through price controls. The average capped price across 2,490 cities was 10.57 pesos/litre ($1.99/l) over 10-16 March, above the 2023 average of Ps9.66/l. This follows US propane price rises at the turn of the year, although they have fallen since. US Gulf coast propane prices delivered to Mexico fell by 4pc on the week to 88.01¢/USG ($459.50/t) on 8 March. Control enthusiasts Mexico introduced LPG price controls in 2021. A court ruled in August 2023 that the price caps are constitutional for truck deliveries to residential consumers but not sales from other retail sites. Around 60pc of Mexico's LPG demand of more than 9mn t/yr comes from the residential sector, Argus data show. Mexico's presidential election in June could be an opening for a return to liberalisation. Ruling party Morena's candidate Claudia Sheinbaum — ahead by double digits in recent polls — is expected to continue with Lopez Obrador's nationalistic approach, but opposition candidate Xochitl Galvez has expressed her intention to open the sector to more private-sector investment. Mexico LPG imports Pemex LPG production Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Iran LPG exports to keep growing despite US sanctions


19/03/24
News
19/03/24

Iran LPG exports to keep growing despite US sanctions

Output from the South Pars field continues to rise and Iran has expanded its export capabilities to further feed China's PDH sector, writes Ieva Paldaviciute Dubai, 19 March (Argus) — Iranian LPG exports are expected to continue increasing until at least the end of this decade, despite US sanctions on the country's energy and banking sectors that could face renewed vigour if Donald Trump is re-elected in November. Iran's LPG exports rose by 2.6mn t on the year to almost 11.4mn t in 2023, according to consultancy FGE, which expects them to grow by 600,000t this year. This is higher than data from Kpler, which puts exports at 10.4mn t, up by 1.9mn t, and would make Iran the largest LPG exporter in the Mideast Gulf for the first time. Iran's exports hovered at around 5mn t/yr over 2018-20, demonstrating the rapid growth in the three years since, driven primarily by rising LPG output, around 80pc of which is from gas processing. Iran is an Opec member but is not bound by Opec+ crude production restraints. US sanctions that have been in place since 2018 when Washington withdrew from the 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) nuclear deal initially restricted Iran's crude and oil products production and exports. But natural gas output from the giant South Pars field has continued to rise, and with it production of natural gas liquids (NGLs). Iran's LPG production rose by around 77pc to 429,000 b/d (13.5mn t/yr) between 2020 and 2023, FGE data show, driven largely by rising South Pars gas output. All of the field's 24 phases are now producing, the last of which, 11, started up last year. Increasing crude output and exports since the start of last year further lifted gas and associated gas output, and so too LPG yields. Iran has also expanded its VLGC fleet and upgraded its export terminals, enabling it to ship more LPG. China is the dominant buyer, taking 8.9mn t, or 78pc, of Iran's LPG exports in 2023, Kpler data show — India took 945,000t, with the rest mostly heading to Yemen, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Turkey. China's growing LPG-fed petrochemical capacity and fleet of VLGCs has encouraged it to buy more cheap Iranian supply, with discounts to fob Saudi Aramco contract prices (CP) peaking at $100/t for large refrigerated cargoes and $420/t for smaller pressurised shipments in 2022. "These high discounts helped Iran expand its market in China," FGE says. Discounts narrowed last year as demand for Iranian LPG grew, but they have widened again this year. "Refrigerated cargoes now land in south China at a cif price of $40-60/t above CP, which is still competitive compared with cargoes from neighbouring countries in the Mideast Gulf," FGE managing director for the Middle East Iman Nasseri, says. China's LPG demand is likely to expand significantly again this year, which will further support trade with Iran, whose LPG exports are expected to grow to 17mn t/yr by 2030 and production to 636,000 b/d, FGE says. Trump resurrection Iran's energy exports recovery has been on the US' agenda since the Israel-Gaza conflict began. President Joe Biden took office in 2021 intending to de-escalate tensions with Tehran and pave the way for a return to the JCPOA. But talks broke down in 2022. Iran's exports rise has been explained by less-stringent sanctions enforcement by the US. Iran and the US held indirect talks recently about "sanctions relief negotiations", according to state news agency Irna, with the US said to be using it as leverage to get Tehran to prevent Yemen's Houthi militants from attacking ships in the Red Sea. Washington has not confirmed these talks. But the US presidential election is due in November, with Donald Trump — the architect of the US withdrawal from the JCPOA and the renewal of sanctions in 2018 — slightly ahead in most polls. Even if Trump wins and takes steps to toughen sanctions, the impact on Iran will be limited, Nasseri says. "We are unlikely to return to [lower] 2018-20 export levels. Iran has really expanded its ‘middlemen' network in the past few years, as well as its fleet, making it really hard to track the origin of Iranian cargoes." Iran LPG infrastructure Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more