Vietnam mulls tariffs to protect its coil producers

  • Market: Metals
  • 26/12/19

Vietnam is mulling tariffs on flat steel imports to protect its domestic steelmakers in the face of lower-cost overseas shipments and new capacity in 2020, adding to oversupply in the market.

The protectionist measures could stunt the growth of Asean spot trading of hot-rolled coil (HRC) into Vietnam, one of the few Asian countries without trade barriers on HRC imports.

Major coil producers Formosa Ha Tinh Steel and Hoa Phat Steel have lobbied the government to add such measures, similar to its safeguard duties on billet and long steels, market participants said.

HRC import prices plunged by more than $100/t from July-October, pressured by aggressive discounting by Indian exporters during the country's rainy season. The price plunge occurred after benchmark iron ore indexes peaked above $125/t cfr China, increasing steel production costs before HRC prices headed lower.

Potential losses by domestic mills this year and the addition of new capacity in 2020 have prompted the government to consider adding safeguard tariffs on HRC, Vietnam-based participants said.

Hoa Phat will start operations of a 2mn t/yr second phase at its integrated Dong Quat mill in second-quarter 2020, which will be used to make HRC. Formosa has a capacity of 7mn t/yr, 5.2mn t/yr of which is for HRC, which it sells domestically and exports. The two mills will be able to cover about 70pc of domestic HRC demand, leaving only 30pc demand for imports, a Vietnam-based trader said.

The increased supply comes as Vietnam's downstream demand slowed sharply in 2019, Vietnam-based traders and consumers said. Real estate construction has stalled in tier-one cities amid a review of approval processes, and the delays could continue into late 2020. Projects in tier-two cities could partly offset the slower demand in tier-one cities.

Vietnam's steel exports have not made up for the slower domestic demand. Pipe makers in south Vietnam have had poor sales this year and been unable export to neighbouring countries, with October-November sales down by 30-40pc on the year, a mill official said.

Revenue and price realisation details of the unlisted Formosa are not publicly available, but the mill and Hoa Phat have anecdotally incurred losses this year. In response, Hoa Phat has sharply reduced its staff count, participants said. The Hoa Sen and Nam Kim steel groups saw their profits fall to the lowest level in around five years in the third quarter, analysts said.

Consumers are opposing the safeguard duties because they will lead to a rise in production costs, adding that imports are needed to meet at least half of domestic HRC demand. The global economy will turn better in 2020 with the US-China trade war easing, which may further stimulate Vietnamese steel demand. A proposal to impose a 5pc duty on China's HRC sales to Vietnam was abandoned by the finance ministry in September as it did not find enough evidence of injury to domestic producers, consumers said.

Official data showed solid growth for Vietnam's overall steel sector before the second-half slowdown.

Vietnam's January-June steel output rose by 17pc to 7.8mn t, according to the Southeast Asia Iron and Steel Institute (SEAISI). Vietnam's first-half steel imports climbed by 21pc to 7.4mn t, while exports increased by 8.1pc. First-half consumption rose by 23pc to 11.8mn t, SEAISI said.

India-origin HRC exports were the main weight on Asean spot markets in late 2019, pricing at a discount to other origins. Chinese offers for SAE grade coils were broadly $5-20/t higher compared with Indian offers in Vietnam during the past year, according to the Argus HRC Asean cfr Vietnam country origin differentials.

The Asean HRC index fell from a 2019 high of $518/t cfr Vietnam in July to as low as $412/t cfr in October, before steadily rebounding in December, with the index at $492/t cfr on 24 December.

Trade on the London Metal Exchange fob China HRC (Argus) contract is on pace to set a new record in December since its launch in March. Asean markets are widely distorted by trade barriers. Vietnam changing from a free port to one with safeguard duties will put it in the same category as most of the others in the region, potentially pinching growth in its spot physical trade.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
28/03/24

Europe plate: Imports weigh on EU prices

Europe plate: Imports weigh on EU prices

London, 28 March (Argus) — Plate prices in Europe tumbled this week on increased import activity, which has pushed European producers to adjust their offers down to remain competitive. The Argus fortnightly Italian plate assessment dropped by €22.50/t to €730/t ex-works today for S235 grades, while the northwest European plate assessment for the same specifications also dropped by €15/t to €765/t. In the south, for S275 material, re-rollers were heard quoting €740-750/t to small customers, with €720-730/t possible for larger volumes. The market remained split between suppliers willing to drop to the low €700s/t to collect orders, and others that preferred to remain firm at €740-750/t and wait for after the Easter holidays to see how the market develops. Two re-rollers confirmed this week that they are mulling extending their Easter break by a few days owing to weak purchasing activity in the market. The level of €710/t ex-works for S275 was also reported available for orders of 1,000t and above, but this could not be verified. Buying activity over the past two weeks remained poor, as market participants are purchasing what they need with no restocking activity occurring. A slight drop in slab prices has contributed to lower plate prices. Deliveries for the Italian domestic market remain for late April for commodity grades. To the rest of Europe, Italian producers were heard offering around €750/t on a ex-works basis for S235 material, without collecting any tonnage. One source said there were offers as high as €760-770/t ex-works Italy. In northern Europe, one mill was reported concluding sales to end-users working in the shipbuilding industry at €750-770 ex-works for S355 grades. The same producer tabled offers at around €780/t, but was quick to offer discounts. Orders from the supplier are expected to be delivered in six to seven weeks. One source estimated that for S235, integrated mills would be offering close to €780-800/t ex-works, while from re-rollers located in the Benelux area €750/t ex-works for the same grade could be easily achieved. One central European mill was also heard available to sell at €790-810/t ex-works for S235. Producers in the northwest are operating on April to May delivery depending on the mill and the product requested. Market participants agree that a rebound in market activity is only expected towards the latter part of April. On imports, over the past couple of weeks, Indonesian material was purchased by buyers across the continent, especially in southern Europe at €640/t cif levels for S275. One source estimated that sales from Indonesia totalled close to 60,000t over the past month. After this activity, Indonesian material was not reported available over the past seven days. One deal was also concluded this week at €710/t cfr north EU, for South Korean S355 material. From South Korea, offers for S275 were estimated over the €660/t cif Italy level this week, with no deals concluded. Indian material was offered at $710-720/t cfr Italy for S275, while one trader offered the same origin from port, free on truck at €730/t for S355. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

Turkey rebar: Market muted ahead of elections


28/03/24
News
28/03/24

Turkey rebar: Market muted ahead of elections

London, 28 March (Argus) — Turkish rebar prices were stable today, without a great deal of urgency shown by export buyers following a sustained uptick in scrap prices over the past few days. The domestic market remained subdued, as construction demand is still constrained by high borrowing costs and the ongoing depreciation of the domestic currency. Argus ' daily Turkish export assessment for rebar was unchanged at $590/t fob, with larger cargoes still available at this level. European, mostly Balkan, buyers have been making enquiries this week, with scrap prices inching steadily upwards over the past three weeks. But buyers have mostly been checking prices, and trade has remained thin. Rebar indications from suppliers were in a $590-605/t fob range, with most suppliers expecting at least $595/t fob. In the wire rod segment, material was available in a range of $605-625/t fob. The weekly wire rod assessment increased by $5/t to $600/t fob Turkey. In the domestic market, offers from most mills in the Marmara and Iskenderun regions were firm in a range of $610-620/t ex-works excluding value-added tax (VAT). But material remains available from Izmir mills and one Marmara mill at $595-600/t ex-works. While some buyers have made purchases in the run-up to the municipal elections on 30 March, restocking has been lacklustre, with a lack of firm signals from the construction sector. Argus ' daily Turkish domestic rebar assessment was unchanged at $600/t ex-works excluding VAT, with the lira equivalent also unchanged at TL23,4000/t ex-works including VAT. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Taiwan scrap imports fall 13pc on year in February


28/03/24
News
28/03/24

Taiwan scrap imports fall 13pc on year in February

Singapore, 28 March (Argus) — Taiwan's ferrous scrap imports fell on the year in February, reflecting rising prices, subdued activity during the holiday period and high stocks. Ferrous scrap imports totalled 218,887t, down by 21.3pc on the month and 13.2pc on the year, customs data showed. Trade sources attributed the decline to rising seaborne scrap prices in November and December. Trade sources said lower bookings were expected given the lunar new year holiday in Taiwan on 8-14 February, with mills likely to have been prudent in their procurement since November as delivery of containerised scrap usually takes 8-10 weeks from the signing of an agreement. The US remained Taiwan's top ferrous scrap supplier in February, providing 81,249t, although this was down by 32.6pc on January and 25.1pc on the year. Ferrous scrap imports from Japan fell by 10.3pc on the month and 15pc on the year to 55,510t in February. Imports from Dominican Republic rose by 7.1pc on the month and 16.9pc year on year to 17,563t. Scrap supply from Australia fell by 47.8pc year on year to 9,921t. Trade sources said underwhelming fundamentals in Asia meant Australian sellers focused on south Asia, where they could achieve stronger margins. Looking ahead, a slowing construction sector could mean lower scrap imports. "The shortage of manpower and rising building material costs have impacted the initiation pace of new construction projects," the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research said on 25 March. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Japan’s SMM eyes Li-ion battery recycling plant by 2026


28/03/24
News
28/03/24

Japan’s SMM eyes Li-ion battery recycling plant by 2026

Tokyo, 28 March (Argus) — Japanese battery cathode producer Sumitomo Metal Mining (SMM) plans to set up a lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery recycling plant in western Japan's Ehime prefecture by June 2026. The recycling plant is expected to have a processing capacity of around 6,000-7,000 t/yr of black mass, equivalent to batteries for around 60,000 electric vehicles, a company representative told Argus on 28 March. Black mass is the shredded remains of cathode materials such as nickel, cobalt and lithium. The company will start construction sometime during March-April 2025, but the timing for commercial operations was undisclosed. SMM has also entered into a partnership with nine domestic recycling partners to build a supply chain for collecting used Li-ion batteries, the company representative added. SMM produced cathodes using nickel and cobalt from recycled Li-ion batteries in June 2023. Domestic battery producer Prime Earth EV Energy proved the quality of SMM's used cathodes in performance testing. The recycled ratio of nickel and cobalt used in the test was more than 6pc and 16pc respectively. This exceeds the standard rates that EU battery regulations tentatively set as minimum recycling requirements for each material, a SMM representative previously told Argus . The EU regulation is expected to take effect from 2031 after approvals by member countries. By Yusuke Maekawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Centaurus' Jaguar Ni mine in Brazil eyes 2027 output


28/03/24
News
28/03/24

Centaurus' Jaguar Ni mine in Brazil eyes 2027 output

Singapore, 28 March (Argus) — Australian mining company Centaurus Metals said that its Jaguar nickel sulphide project in Brazil is undergoing a feasibility study and aims to start production in mid-2027. Jaguar, bought from Brazilian mining firm Vale in 2020 , is estimated to hold 109mn t of 0.87pc grade nickel for an estimated 948,900t of contained nickel. The nickel product will be largely targeted at the Atlantic market, with expectations that demand will strengthen in the region. "Demand for nickel we believe is not going away. And if you look at what's going to happen in the US and European markets in particular, nickel will probably be a bigger part of the battery composition than anywhere else," Centaurus' managing director Darren Gordon said at the Tribeca Futures Commodities conference held in Singapore on 26 March. "There's a huge amount of nickel that still needs to come into the market." Many Australian mining firms have struggled with a slump in global nickel prices earlier in the year because of a supply glut caused by increased volumes from Indonesia, coupled with a slowdown in demand. Several Australian mines have halted operations , while other processing facilities were placed on care and maintenance programmes . But Centaurus is hopeful that Jaguar will be able to compete on a cost and environmental basis with Indonesian supplies. "Nickel is going to continue be supplied out of Indonesia in very large ways so we are going to compete on costs. And we think that when we deliver the feasibility study, we will be able to demonstrate that we can compete on costs. But overlay on that, we have this very low carbon footprint associated with our project," Gordon added. Centaurus said Jaguar is one of the lowest carbon footprint nickel project globally, following a review done by a metals and mining ESG research company. Once operational, greenhouse gas emissions from the project are forecast to be 7.27t of carbon dioxide/t of nickel equivalent, which is assessed to be lower than 94pc of other global nickel production. By Sheih Li Wong Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more