Germany supports gas in EU green label row

  • Market: Electricity
  • 24/01/22

The German government this weekend reiterated its opposition to include nuclear energy in the EU's green finance taxonomy, while it called on the European Commission to amend rules for the inclusion of natural gas as a transitional fuel.

In a letter sent to Brussels after the expiry of the deadline to provide feedback on the inclusion of gas and nuclear in the green taxonomy, the German government rejected the use of the latter while detailing new requirements for gas to meet climate targets.

"We have once again clearly expressed our rejection of the inclusion of nuclear energy" in the EU taxonomy as "it is risky and expensive", economy and climate protection minister Robert Habeck and environment minister Steffi Lemke said.

The government pointed out the lack of safety requirements in the field of nuclear power, while reiterating that the lengthy construction of new reactors "does not offer a short-term opportunity" to phase out carbon-intensive energy sources such as coal.

To achieve carbon neutrality by 2045, transitional fuels "must be geared towards these goals" by allowing for greater energy efficiency and increase generation from renewable energies, the letter says. A higher share of renewables in the energy mix also requires flexible generation capacity to be ramped up and down at times of lower renewables supply, "which nuclear power cannot provide", the letter continues.

While the government rejects the inclusion of nuclear energy in the green taxonomy, it highlights the importance of gas as a transitional fuel.

Gas used in "ultra-modern and efficient gas-fired power plants forms a bridge for a limited transitional period" to allow for a 2030 phase-out of coal-fired generation, the government says in the letter.

The proposed intermediate fuel switch targets to low-carbon and renewables gases — 30pc by 2026 and 55pc by 2030 — laid out by the taxonomy proposal are however not realistic, the government highlights.

Fuel-switching goals should only be seen as guidelines and be "enabled in a flexible manner after 2036", the letter says.

"Should the delegated act remain unchanged and the commission ignore the critical opinions of a number of member states... we believe that Germany should reject it", Habeck and Lemke say.

The European Commission will revise the proposal based on the feedback of the member states, after which each member has four to six months to object to the new delegated act.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
27/03/24

Electrification key to cut UK offshore emissions: NSTA

Electrification key to cut UK offshore emissions: NSTA

London, 27 March (Argus) — The UK offshore oil and gas industry must make "decisive emissions reduction actions now and on an ongoing basis", with asset electrification and low carbon power central to making cuts, regulator the North Sea Transition Authority (NSTA) said today. "Where the NSTA considers electrification reasonable, but it has not been done, there should be no expectation that the NSTA will approve field development plans", the regulator said in a new emissions reduction plan. The NSTA set out "four clear contributing factors to decarbonising the industry" — including asset electrification, investment and efficiency and action on flaring and venting. It will also look at "inventory as a whole", ramping up scrutiny on assets with high emissions intensity. Relevant companies must produce emissions reduction action plans for offshore assets, the NSTA said. New developments with first oil or gas after the beginning of 2030 must be either fully electrified or run on "alternative low carbon power with near equivalent emission reductions", the NSTA said. New developments with first oil or gas before 2030 should be electrification-ready at minimum. If electrification is not reasonable, other power emissions reductions must be sought, the regulator said. The offshore industry must from 1 June provide "a documented method of the split of projected flaring and venting figures into categories", and must from 1 June 2025 have a plan and budget to "deliver continuous improvements in flaring and venting", it said. New developments — including tie-backs — must be planned on the basis of zero routine flaring and venting, which every asset must reach by 2030. Industry flaring almost halved between 2018-22, the NSTA said. The regulator has flagged a particular focus on methane emissions. The NSTA may require developers to agree to cease production of assets with high emissions intensity "with reference to societal carbon values", it said. Societal carbon values are calculated by the UK government to reflect the marginal cost to society of additional CO2 emissions. It will discuss end dates for production for assets with greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions intensity 50pc over the average for the UK offshore, and which intend to produce oil or gas beyond 2030. This represents a slight watering down of the initial plan the NSTA consulted on last year. The North Sea Transition Deal, agreed in 2021, commits the UK offshore industry to reducing its production emissions of GHGs by 10pc by 2025, by 24pc by 2027 and by 50pc by 2030, from a 2018 baseline. Industry has itself committed to a 90pc reduction by 2040 and a net zero basin by 2050, the NSTA said. It "would welcome industry owning and delivering these reductions", it said, adding that its plan is focused on emissions cuts and "emissions offsetting will not be considered towards meeting the obligations." By Georgia Gratton Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

Jera delays Hekinan NH3-coal co-firing test: Correction


26/03/24
News
26/03/24

Jera delays Hekinan NH3-coal co-firing test: Correction

Corrects trial period in first paragraph Osaka, 26 March (Argus) — Japan's largest power producer by capacity Jera has pushed back a trial to co-fire 20pc of fuel ammonia with coal at its Hekinan power plant to after the end of March. Jera previously said the co-firing demonstration at the 1GW Hekinan No.4 unit will start on 26 March at the earliest . But the company has decided to push this back. The trial will begin sometime after the end of this month, Jera said on 25 March. It took more time to test run equipment ahead of the demonstration, with safety the main priority, it added. It is unclear when exactly the company will start the trial to co-fire 20pc of ammonia with coal. Jera aims to demonstrate 20pc co-firing of ammonia with coal ahead of planned commercial operations in the April 2027-March 2028 fiscal year. It also hopes to achieve a 50pc mixture on a commercial basis in the first half of the 2030s. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Oil sands producers plan CCS network, hub


25/03/24
News
25/03/24

Oil sands producers plan CCS network, hub

Calgary, 25 March (Argus) — A group of Canadian oil sands companies are planning to build a massive C$16.5bn ($12.2bn) carbon capture and storage (CCS) project to decarbonize operations. Canadian Natural Resources (CNRL), on behalf of the Pathways Alliance consortium, filed plans for the project with the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER) last week to store 10mn-12mn t/yr of carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent in the oil sands region of northeast Alberta. The Pathways Alliance also includes Cenovus, Suncor, Imperial Oil, ConocoPhillips Canada and MEG Energy, which account for about 95pc of the province's roughly 3.3mn b/d of oil sands production. Construction of the project is expected to begin as early as the fourth quarter 2025 with operations starting in 2029 or 2030. The main CO2 transportation pipeline will be 24-36-inches in diameter and stretch about 400km (249 miles). It will initially tap into 13 oil sands facilities from north of Fort McMurray to the Cold Lake region, where the CO2 will be stored underground. "When you have that concentration of emission sources, technologies like carbon capture and storage become very, very technically viable," Pathways Alliance president Kendall Dilling told the CERAWeek by S&P Global conference in Houston, Texas, earlier this month. Oil sands crude producers have been criticized for being particularly carbon intensive. The Pathways Alliance is their answer to driving operations to net zero by 2050. The CCS project and "a host of other technologies" represent Phase 1 of the Pathways Alliance's efforts and will reduce oil sands emissions by about 25pc by 2030, according to Dilling. The CCS project itself accounts for about half of this reduction. Phase 2 is planned for between 2031 to 2040 and would tie in at least another eight oil sands projects, while also ramping up alternative energy initiatives related to hydrogen, electrification and small modular nuclear reactors. By Brett Holmes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

LatAm clean energy sector calls for global taxonomy


25/03/24
News
25/03/24

LatAm clean energy sector calls for global taxonomy

New York, 25 March (Argus) — The Latin America energy sector is calling for the creation of a global taxonomy that sets standards for clean energy technologies and financial instruments to attract investment in clean energy technologies. Around $1.8 trillion was invested in clean energy technologies globally in 2023, according to Paris-based the International Energy Agency (IEA). Over 80pc of that investment went to developed economies and China, while less than 15pc of investments in clean energy projects were made in developing economies. Clean energy investment in emerging and developing economies needs to rise more than sixfold in the next 10 years to $1.6 trillion, according to the IEA. "We are advancing in clean energy, but we are still far away from reaching 2030 targets," said Clarissa Lins, founder and chief executive officer at consultancy Catavento. Latin America has the resources needed to transition to cleaner energies in its entire supply chain. The share of renewables in its power mix is 60pc, double the global average. Countries like Brazil have an immense potential to decarbonize their transport sector using biofuels while the region has vast resources of critical minerals for the transition. But the region needs to improve its risk-return profile if it wants to attract more private investment in clean energy technologies and this is a task that it cannot achieve alone. The creation of a global taxonomy that sets standards and definitions of technologies and financial tools is a first step. "We need to define what bonds mean, what low-carbon hydrogen and sustainable fuels mean so we can attract investment," secretary of hydrocarbons at the ministry of mines and energy of Brazil, Pietro Mendes, said. Latin America could benefit from this global taxonomy as it could also add economic value to many products manufactured in the region that already have low-carbon intensity given the region's less-polluting energy matrix. "Everything produced in LatAm has already twice less carbon than in the rest of the world," said Viviana Coelho, executive manager of climate change at Petrobras. "Everything produced in Brazil has four times less carbon than the rest of the world, but that is not valued globally. A global taxonomy would add value to those products that we managed to produce with less emissions." At a regional level, governments need to guarantee legal stability and create the right economic incentives and fiscal benefits for renewables. Policymakers need to work in collaboration with the private sector and local communities to guarantee developers can materialize their projects on time. In this line, tender processes need to be more transparent, offering a clear pathway for investors that ensures they will be able to sign contracts for their projects. "We need more feasible tenders to avoid an absence of offers," said Andrea Arrobo, energy minister of Ecuador. The country last year launched a tender for 500MW of combined wind, solar and biomass capacity. No bids were received for biomass projects, according to the government. And some new wind and solar projects that were awarded in previous auctions have suffered delays because of the lengthy process to sign concession contracts. Think forward Latin America should not limit its ambitions in the energy transition to generating cleaner energy and should think ahead to take advantage of its resources to produce low-carbon by-products. "LatAm doesn't need to think only on green hydrogen exports, but also exports of green fertilizers and green petrochemical products," Mendes said. "We need to develop the whole supply chain to produce other products and to industrialize our countries." Integration between governments and industries is also required to succeed with this goal as corporations that are willing to decarbonize can assume the costs of producing green products, but that also equires a competitive legal framework. By Jacqueline Echevarria Latin America and the Caribbean GHG emissions mn t Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Jera considers joining ExxonMobil’s H2 project in US


25/03/24
News
25/03/24

Jera considers joining ExxonMobil’s H2 project in US

Osaka, 25 March (Argus) — Japan's largest power producer by capacity Jera is considering joining an ExxonMobil-led hydrogen and ammonia production project in the US, aiming to boost its ammonia import portfolio in its efforts to reduce coal use. Jera has signed a framework agreement with ExxonMobil to jointly explore the development of blue hydrogen and its derivative of ammonia at ExxonMobil's Baytown complex east of Houston, Texas, the Japanese firm said on 25 March. Jera will explore the possibility of importing around 500,000 t/yr of ammonia and securing a stake in the project through the deal. ExxonMobil is developing a hydrogen production plant and a carbon capture and storage (CCS) facility at its Baytown complex, aiming to begin operations in 2028. The plant would produce around 900,000 t/yr of hydrogen, part of which will be used to produce around 1mn t/yr of ammonia, Jera said. Jera is separately working with Norway-based fertilizer producer Yara and US ammonia producer CF Industries to develop blue ammonia production on the US Gulf coast, targeting production of more than 1mn t/yr under each partnership. Jera has not decided yet whether it wants to invest in the upstream projects. Jera said it can proceed with projects to invest in low-carbon ammonia production and marketing only with financial and other support from the government . The private sector cannot make upstream or downstream decisions on fuel ammonia "based on just pure business judgment," Jera chief executive Yukio Kani said at CERAWeek by S&P Global in Houston on 20 March. Beyond funding, the government will have to help set safety and other standards for the new type of fuel, Kani said. Jera aims to import around 2mn t/yr of fuel ammonia in 2030 , which is nearly 70pc of Japan's current 2030 ammonia demand target of 3mn t/yr. The company is planning to start testing the use of ammonia at its 1GW Hekinan No.4 coal-fired unit by the end of this month. Tokyo and Washington have also geared up efforts to strengthen their ties in clean energy technology development, alongside private-sector partnerships. Japan's trade and industry ministry and the US Department of Energy held a second US-Japan clean energy and energy security initiative plenary meeting on 19 March, ahead of a US-Japan leaders' summit in April. This is aimed at accelerating cooperation in developing and deploying clean energy technology such as nuclear energy, floating offshore wind, perovskite solar cell, geothermal, hydrogen and its derivatives, including ammonia and synthetic fuels, as well as carbon management. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more