US court clears sale of Citgo shares

Spanish Market: Crude oil, Oil products
25/05/20

A US federal court has given a go-ahead to the potential sale of shares in US refiner Citgo to satisfy Venezuela's debts, stressing that upholding debtholders' rights outweigh any political considerations.

The decision is another setback for Venezuela's US-supported political opposition, which has nominal control over Citgo since last year, even though the refiner's parent, state-owned PdV, remains in the control of the Venezuelan government of President Nicolas Maduro in Caracas that faces US sanctions.

The legal process for selling Venezuela's most valuable foreign asset can proceed, judge Leonard Stark of the US District Court for the District of Delaware ruled on 22 May, after the US Supreme Court declined to consider an appeal of the lower court ruling. The US district court will hear arguments on procedure for the sale on 17 July.

The primary claimant for shares in Citgo's US holding company PdVH is former Canadian mining firm Crystallex, which is now controlled by New York hedge fund Tenor Capital. The Delaware district court is considering separate claims from Crystallex and US independent producer ConocoPhillips, both of which have won international arbitration awards related to the Venezuelan government's takeover of their assets.

Crystallex, which is seeking to collect a $1.2bn arbitration award for expropriated gold mining interests, convinced the Delaware court in 2018 that Citgo operated as an alter ego of the Venezuelan government and could be sold to satisfy the country's more than $150bn in debts. Among other creditors laying claim to Citgo shares are holders of a PdV 2020 bond, which fell into default in October 2019.

The spotlight now shifts to the US government, which issued an executive order in August 2019 that bars sales of any Venezuelan assets without Treasury Department clearance.

Crystallex already petitioned Treasury's sanctions enforcement arm, the Office of Foreign Assets Control (Ofac), for a license to proceed with the sale.

Treasury clarified in late November that US sanctions on Venezuela and the Maduro government prohibited any enforcement of judicial or arbitration decisions without a lifting of sanctions or an executive order. A separate, specific license also prevents bondholders from taking over the refiner. The US last month extended that license into July.

Stark in his closely watched ruling noted that "no executive branch order or regulation prohibits this court from moving forward in determining how the attached shares will be sold." Stark invited US government representatives to make counter-arguments at the 17 July hearing.

Debtholders' rights hold primacy over other considerations, Stark said, citing a US Third Circuit Court of Appeals decision. "Any outcome where Crystallex is not paid means that Venezuela has avoided its obligations."

Venezuela's Western-recognized interim government described the Crystallex case as a "monstrosity" of Maduro's making but asserted that Citgo remains "protected" from seizure thanks to the US executive order.

Figurehead

Venezuela's mainstream opposition has made the defense of Citgo a policy cornerstone since National Assembly speaker Juan Guaido declared an interim presidency in January 2019. Guaido and his exiled advisers argue that Citgo is vital to Venezuela's reconstruction after Maduro is forced out.

The keep-Citgo strategy has become more difficult to sustain the longer that Maduro remains in power. The Guaido authority has no access to Citgo's revenue and cannot tap the refiner to supply gasoline to Venezuela because of the US sanctions.

Over the weekend the first Iranian cargo of gasoline arrived in Venezuela, where fuel scarcity has impeded distribution of food and medical supplies.

Guaido legal adviser Yon Goicoechea told reporters on 22 May that the interim authority "can't take one dollar from Citgo" because "even the earnings of Citgo are frozen and protected by Ofac."

"On the one hand this is bad because the interim government can't use it for social programs or relief, but it is good because… thanks to Ofac's protection the creditors can't get that money."

By Haik Gugarats and Patricia Garip

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

22/05/25

Brazil senate passes environmental licensing bill

Sao Paulo, 22 May (Argus) — Brazil's senate approved a bill that aims to standardize and, in some cases, speed up environmental licensing that the oil industry has blamed for slowing exploration projects . The bill, which the senate approved Wednesday in a 54 to-13 vote, aims to create national standards for environmental licensing, with the goal of simplifying the process for projects that have a limited environmental impact. The bill also aims to create a new type of environmental license for projects that are considered government priorities. These projects would be subject to a more simplified licensing process that would take one year at most. The creation of a new type of licensing for these projects would potentially facilitate oil exploration in the Amazon, the senate said. The change comes as state-controlled Petrobras pushes to begin offshore drilling in the environmentally sensitive Foz do Amazonas offshore basin . The bill would also exempt agricultural projects from obtaining environmental licensing but would continue to require farmers to obtain authorization to remove native vegetation. It also allows small- and medium-sized projects to self-declare their environmental commitments, without the need to have a proper license. Senator Eliziane Gama criticized that proposal, using the disaster in the Brumadinho dam — which burst in 2019 and was considered a medium-sized project — as an example. Brazilian energy think tank Instituto Acende called the bill an important milestone for Brazil, adding that if approved, it would "reduce legal uncertainty, administrative inefficiencies, and obstacles to sustainable development". Environmentalists slammed the proposal, with Observatorio do Clima calling it the "greatest attack on environmental legislation in four decades". The legislation would approve nearly all new projects without environmental impact studies, the group said. The bill will now return to the lower house because senators altered the original text. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

US officials squabble on Chevron's Venezuela future

22/05/25

US officials squabble on Chevron's Venezuela future

Caracas, 22 May (Argus) — Chevron will be allowed to continue producing and exporting Venezuelan crude, or maybe it will not, depending on which senior US official is speaking. Secretary of state Marco Rubio took to social media late Wednesday night to insist that Chevron's waiver from US sanctions will end as planned on 27 May, contradicting US presidential envoy Ric Grenell's statement a day earlier. "The pro-Maduro Biden oil license in Venezuela will expire as scheduled next Tuesday May 27th," Rubio posted from his personal account on X. Rubio referred to an authorization, originally issued under former president Joe Biden in 2022, that allowed Chevron to import crude into the US produced in its joint venture with state-owned PdV. Grenell had said on Wednesday that he expected an extension of the license after he helped secure the release of US Air Force veteran Joseph St Clair from a Venezuelan prison. Chevron has until 27 May to wind down all business in Venezuela, and neither the company nor the US Treasury Department's sanctions enforcement arm, the Office of Foreign Assets Control, have disclosed if the license would be extended or modified. Venezuela's national assembly president Jorge Rodriguez earlier this week had suggested that the US under President Donald Trump would seek to extend the original license to prevent China from taking over Chevron's space in its joint ventures with PdV. Sources close to the issue in Venezuela had heard until late Wednesday that the extension was in the works. "It's going to happen, Friday is what we are hearing", the source said, indicating multiple currents in the Trump administration. But Venezuelan opposition leader Maria Corina Machado lobbied against extending the waiver, saying Chevron's presence helps support the Maduro regime, an opposition source in Caracas said. "The [US] wants their hostages, but they are not super eager to hand Maduro a win in return", the source, who has liaised with DC for the opposition said. "La señora complained." By Carlos Camacho Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Iraq signs integrated energy deal with China’s Geo-Jade

22/05/25

Iraq signs integrated energy deal with China’s Geo-Jade

Dubai, 22 May (Argus) — Iraq's oil ministry has signed an agreement with China's Geo-Jade Petroleum and local firm Basra Crescent to expand the capacity of the 20,000 b/d Tuba oil field and develop a suite of downstream and power assets, in a move that mirrors recent integrated energy deals with international partners. A key component of the South Basrah Integrated Energy Project will be to raise Tuba's production capacity to 100,000 b/d, oil minister Hayan Abdulghani said at the signing ceremony in Baghdad on 21 May. The project will also include processing of up to 50mn ft³/d of associated gas. Downstream components include a 200,000 b/d refinery, a 620,000 t/yr petrochemical plant and a 520,000 t/yr fertilizer facility. A 650MW thermal power plant and a 400MW solar plant will also be part of the project, Abdulghani said. No financial details or project timelines were disclosed. The agreement marks a further step in Geo-Jade's expansion in Iraq, following its successful participation in the country's fifth and sixth licensing rounds. While the company now holds multiple upstream assets in Iraq, it has yet to bring any into production. The deal follows a similar multi-billion dollar agreement signed with TotalEnergies in 2023 , which bundled gas processing, water treatment and solar power with development of the Ratawi field. In February this year, BP signed a major upstream deal with Iraq that also includes power, water and potentially exploration. By Bachar Halabi Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Mexican GDP outlook dims on tariffs: IMEF

21/05/25

Mexican GDP outlook dims on tariffs: IMEF

Mexico City, 21 May (Argus) — Mexico's association of finance executives IMEF lowered its 2025 growth forecast for a fourth consecutive month, citing the growing impact of US tariffs on the economy. GDP is now expected to grow just 0.1pc in 2025, according to IMEF's May survey, down from 0.2pc estimates in April, 0.6pc in March and 1pc in February. The number of respondents forecasting a contraction in GDP rose to 16, or 37pc of the sample, from nine in April. While the US has granted some exemptions and discounts for Mexican goods meeting regional content rules, IMEF said the effective tariff rate on Mexican exports remains higher than that for Canada, Brazil, India, Vietnam and others. "We're already seeing the [tariffs'] impacts," said IMEF economic studies director Victor Herrera, adding that May trade data will likely show a sharp drop in Mexican exports to the US. Trade is also being hit by a screwworm outbreak in cattle that led to port closures last week and curtailed beef exports, which account for $1.3bn in annual exports. More automakers could relocate or scale back production in Mexico, Herrera said, after Stellantis confirmed plans to shift some operations to the US and recent reports Nissan may close one or both of its Mexican plants. In response, Mexico this week sent deputy economy minister Luis Rosendo Gutierrez to Tokyo to meet with Mazda, Nissan, Toyota and Honda executives. IMEF cut its 2025 job creation forecast to 200,000 in May from 220,000 in April. Mexico's social security administration IMSS reported only 43,500 new jobs over the past 12 months as of 5 May. Beyond trade, IMEF flagged uncertainty from recent constitutional reforms and the potential for a US tax on remittances as additional risks to growth. The group held its 2025 inflation forecast steady at 3.8pc, despite Mexico's consumer price index rising to 3.93pc in April from 3.80pc in March . IMEF noted concerns about a potential rebound in inflation later this year after the central bank cut its benchmark interest rate by 50 basis points to 9pc on 8 May — the third such cut in 2025. The group now sees the end-2025 rate at 7.75pc, down from 8pc previously. IMEF expects the peso to end the year at Ps20.80/$1, slightly lower than the Ps20.90/$1 forecast in April. The peso recently strengthened to Ps19.34/$1, though Herrera said this reflected dollar weakness more than peso strength. By James Young Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

EPA to set biofuel mandate 'very soon': Zeldin

21/05/25

EPA to set biofuel mandate 'very soon': Zeldin

New York, 21 May (Argus) — Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) administrator Lee Zeldin stressed Wednesday that the US is working quickly to propose and finalize new biofuel blend mandates. EPA last week sent proposed Renewable Fuel Standard volumes for 2026 — and likely at least one future year — to the White House Office of Management and Budget for review, the final step before a draft rule can be released. Zeldin referenced that process at a Senate hearing Wednesday and said "we expect the proposed rule to be finalized and released very soon." Asked by US senator Pete Ricketts (R-Nebraska) whether the agency was planning on releasing something by summer or fall, Zeldin said he was eyeing a "much, much faster" timeline. "We'll finalize this as quickly as we possibly can," he said. Zeldin has stressed at recent House and Senate hearings that the agency is expediting the months-delayed rulemaking. Under the Renewable Fuel Standard, EPA requires oil refiners and importers to blend annual amounts of different types of biofuels into the conventional fuel supply. EPA decisions on volume mandates — and on requests for exemptions from small refiners — are highly influential for crop feedstock demand, biofuel production margins and retail fuel prices. Zeldin said last week at a House subcommittee hearing that EPA was also weighing what to do with a backlog of requests from small refiners for exemptions from program requirements. "None of these were getting approved at all in the last administration," Zeldin said. "We want to get caught up as quickly as we can." EPA has not commented more recently on its specific timeline and plans, but the agency said earlier this year that it wanted to get the frequently delayed biofuel program back on its statutory timeline. The Clean Air Act requires new volumes to be finalized 14 months in advance of a compliance year, which in this case would require proposed volumes for 2027 to be released soon for public comment and then finalized before November this year. A coalition of industry groups, including the American Petroleum Institute and Clean Fuels Alliance America, have pushed the agency to hike the biomass-based diesel mandate from 3.35bn USG this year to a record-high 5.25bn USG next year. Other groups, including fuel marketers, have urged more caution given a sharp drop in biofuel production to start 2025 and uncertainty about the future of a federal clean fuel tax credit being renegotiated in Congress. As part of the White House process, outside groups can seek meetings with the Trump administration to present their views on a pending regulation. Meetings are scheduled through 4 June on the proposed volumes — and through 9 June on a related rule to cut last year's cellulosic biofuel quota — though the US has expedited the process before. Last year, President Joe Biden's administration cancelled previously scheduled meetings on the initial proposal to cut cellulosic targets as a way to more speedily exit the review process. By Cole Martin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more