21/05/26
UN backs ICJ climate ruling, key oil nations opposed
UN backs ICJ climate ruling, key oil nations opposed
Edinburgh, 21 May (Argus) — The UN general assembly has adopted a resolution
welcoming an International Court of Justice (ICJ) advisory opinion on the
obligations of countries to protect the environment from greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions, with only eight countries opposing — including the three largest oil
producers the US, Saudi Arabia and Russia. Pacific island nation Vanuatu put
forward the resolution to the UN general assembly, saying "the ICJ advisory
opinion confirms that the protection of the climate system is a matter of legal
obligation not political discretion". It was adopted on Wednesday, 20 May, with
141 votes in favour, including the world's largest GHG emitter China, eight
against and 28 abstentions. Belarus, Iran, Israel, Liberia, Russia, Saudi
Arabia, the US and Yemen voted against. The ICJ last year determined in an
advisory opinion that all countries have an obligation to contribute to cutting
emissions. This is not legally binding but could open door for more climate
litigation . ICJ advisory opinions "carry significant legal and moral authority
— helping to clarify and develop international law by defining states' legal
obligations", the UN said. The UN resolution adopted calls on UN member states
"to take all possible steps to avoid causing significant damage to the climate
and environment, including emissions produced within their borders, and to
follow through on their existing climate pledges under the Paris Agreement".
Adoption "sends a strong message that tackling the climate crisis is a legal
duty under international law, and not just a political choice," the UN said. The
US opposed the resolution, with its representative saying the country has many
concerns about the court's opinion. The US noted the resolution includes
"inappropriate political demands relating to fossil fuels". Countries such as
India, Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Algeria said the resolution failed to address the
obligations on the provision of finance to developing countries, saying the
focus was "disproportionally" on mitigation. India, Iraq and Algeria abstained.
Russia said the resolution is an attempt to make ICJ opinion "mandatory in
nature". It added the resolution "selectively cites the conclusion of the
advisory opinion" and the outcomes of the UN climate conferences Cops, ignoring
finance and adaptation — adjusting to the effects of climate change where
possible. Algeria said the resolution is excessively "highlighting and
rewriting" decisions from previous Cop outcomes. The text urges members to
implement measures to keep the global temperature increase to 1.5°C, including
tripling renewable energy capacity and doubling the global average annual rate
of energy efficiency by 2030, transitioning away from fossil fuels and phasing
out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies which were agreed at Cop 28 in Dubai. The
UAE voted in favour of the resolution. Brazil, the Cop 30 president, also
adopted the resolution, while Turkey, which will host Cop 31 in Antalya later
this year, abstained. Australia, which will preside on negotiations of Cop 31,
supported the resolution but said it should not be "interpreted as our agreement
with every element of the advisory opinion". By Caroline Varin Send comments and
request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2026. Argus
Media group . All rights reserved.