Viewpoint: Legislation threatens Europe antimony trade
An EU initiative to overhaul chemical safety regulations could crush the supply chain for critical material antimony metal inside Europe, leaving consumers with few options and no spot market.
Europe is wholly dependent on imports for its antimony trade, in the absence of regional production. The metal is used to produce flame-retardant chemicals for textiles, rubber and plastics, in lead-acid batteries for cars and back-up power systems, alloys, and defence applications to harden weaponry and ammunition. The EU ranks the criticality of antimony in Europe as secondary only to rare earths based on economic importance and supply risk (see chart). Most of the world's antimony metal is produced in China, and the US is similarly dependent on imports.
The EU's Reach regulation is intended to "improve the protection of human health and the environment from the risk posed by chemicals while enhancing the competitiveness of the EU chemicals industry". But many market participants are voicing concerns that the cost of proving to the European Chemicals Agency that the chemicals are safe for workers to handle in factories — which are already among the safest anywhere — is making it economically impossible to supply raw materials such as antimony.
If nothing changes, trading in antimony metal may end, several traders said on condition of anonymity, leaving consumers entirely dependent on Chinese prices with no competing sources of supply. The safety of the end products — a large share of which are consumed by the European automotive industry in batteries and flame-resistant textiles and plastics — are not under investigation and have already been tested.
The EU Raw Materials Initiative, which was founded in 2008, two years after Reach came into effect, was developed to ensure "a fair and sustainable supply of raw materials from global markets". An EU review of critical materials in 2017 concluded that "unwrought [antimony] metal is the most significant in terms of trade volume and therefore represents the most likely bottleneck in the EU supply chain".
But the way in which Reach is being implemented in Europe is putting the financial burden on small suppliers more than large foreign producers, traders told Argus. Another concern raised by the industry is that the regulation could price out participants by virtue of the size of the market not the safety of the higher-margin downstream chemical intermediaries. The only real beneficiaries could be foreign producers, if there are only one or two companies left that are allowed to customs clear antimony metal into the EU.
Reach makes the entire industry responsible for the cost of proving that all the chemicals are safe to handle and transport in the EU. But it does not appear to consider the possibility of producers being exempt by virtue of not existing in that jurisdiction. This leaves a handful of traders and manufacturers responsible for shouldering the burden of as many tests are deemed necessary with no cap or transparency about potential future costs.
It also makes it impossible for traders to calculate whether they can break even if they continue to contribute. In a larger market such as nickel, with many participants, the costs can be absorbed within the market. But in a tiny market such as antimony, with global production of under 200,000 t/yr compared with 2mn t/yr of nickel, there are simply not enough participants to cover the costs, market participants said.
The US did not impose import tariffs on Chinese antimony, along with rare earths, indium and other critical metals, signalling its strategic importance. The US Defense Logistics Agency awarded a grant of $510,500 in October 2019 to US Antimony to develop a North American source of antimony trisulphide.
Related news posts
US Fed cuts rate by half point, signals more to come
US Fed cuts rate by half point, signals more to come
Houston, 18 September (Argus) — The US Federal Reserve cut its target interest rate by 50 basis points today, the first rate cut since 2020, with officials signaling they expect to make another half point worth of cuts by the end of 2024. The Fed's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) lowered the federal funds rate to 4.75-5pc from the prior range of 5.25-5.5pc, which was a two-decade high. The Fed had kept the target rate unchanged since July 2023 after hiking it for more than a year in the most aggressive increase campaign in four decades to quash inflation, which peaked at 9.1pc in mid-2022. "The committee has gained greater confidence that inflation is moving sustainably toward 2pc and judges that the risks to achieving its employment and inflation goals are roughly in balance," the FOMC said in its statement after the two-day meeting. "Job gains have slowed, and the unemployment rate has moved up but remains low." The Fed board and policymakers, in their latest economic projections, expect the target rate range will end 2024 near a midpoint of 4.4pc compared with an end of year midpoint of 5.1pc projected in June, which implies further cuts amounting to 50 basis points by the end of 2024. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Japan's Tokyo Steel cuts sales prices on weak demand
Japan's Tokyo Steel cuts sales prices on weak demand
Shanghai, 18 September (Argus) — Japan's steel manufacturing firm Tokyo Steel said it will cut domestic steel product prices for October, marking the first full-scale price cut in over four years. The decision was driven by sluggish domestic demand and increased competition from cheaper imported steel products. Tokyo Steel will reduce prices across all product lines starting October, with steel coils and plates dropping by ¥15,000/t, shaped beams by ¥12,000/t, and tubes and deformed bars by ¥10,000/t. The company had maintained stable domestic steel prices for an extended period on the back of the steadier domestic demand and market conditions compared to the more volatile overseas market. The last price cut for deformed bars was in July 2023. Steel sales in Japan were weak during the third quarter, impacted by rising procurement costs for materials, a shortage of construction capacity, and an influx of cheaper steel products from China in the seaborne market, market participants said. A decline in profitability pushed Japanese mills to cut production costs. From 11 July to 14 September, domestic scrap prices at Tokyo Steel's Utsunomiya plant dropped by ¥12,500/t, or 23.8pc. Market sentiment in Japan remains bearish due to economic uncertainty and the strengthening of the Japanese yen. The upcoming adjustments in US monetary policy could add further volatility to exchange rates. "We may see more corrections in the Japanese domestic market," a trade source said. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
July EU HRC imports show 175,000t pullback
July EU HRC imports show 175,000t pullback
London, 17 September (Argus) — EU hot-rolled coil (HRC) imports surpassed 1.5mn t in July — a record high — as importers for the first time faced a cap to the ‘other countries' safeguard quota, which led some to purchase back-up material from other sources. More importantly, official figures show that around 175,000t were pulled back from customs clearing, likely all in Italy, after the initial quota numbers were made available in early July from Egypt, Vietnam, Japan and Taiwan. This leftover amount will likely all be custom-cleared in October, in addition to material that has arrived since July, as market participants expect importers to clear all of their HRC to avoid the risk of retroactive duties, potentially applicable from December. Imports from Taiwan, India, Turkey and Japan in July all surpassed the 200,000t mark each, with total imports from those four origins close to 900,000t, a sharp year-on-year increase. Vietnam saw volumes drop ( see table ), while South Korean imports fell by 75pc on the year to 40,379t and Serbian imports were down by 10pc to 37,437t. Hot-dipped galvanised (HDG) imports were at a record high, topping 750,000t in July, with nearly 30pc of the total from Vietnam. There has been concern in the market that the EU might start an investigation on Vietnamese HDG, as volumes have been on the increase, while suppliers are regularly the lowest-priced in the market. Plate imports were also at a record high, as EU producers are preparing to file for an investigation on some origins. Meanwhile, the increase in imports and the drop in EU demand has led producers to seek export outlets, with EU HRC exports rising on the year and on the month in July to nearly 230,000t, with the bulk going to the UK, US and Turkey. Downstream product exports also increased. By Lora Stoyanova and Colin Richardson July EU HRC imports t July y-o-y ±% Taiwan 227,892.8 8.2 India 225,558.6 134.8 Turkey 223,185.9 255.2 Japan 210,842.9 6.5 Egypt 158,625.7 31.9 Vietnam 144,202.0 -59.5 Ukraine 101,721.2 118.5 Australia 51,784.0 104.4 Saudi Arabia 40,594.8 -36.4 Total 1,565,744.2 9.1 — GTT Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
US to impose 25pc tariffs on Chinese critical minerals
US to impose 25pc tariffs on Chinese critical minerals
Houston, 13 September (Argus) — The US plans to impose 25pc tariffs on Chinese minerals including indium, tantalum, chromium, cobalt and tungsten, citing China's efforts to dominate global supply chains, according to the office of the US Trade Representative (USTR). The USTR determined not to exclude any critical minerals from the proposed Section 301 tariffs. The USTR said the concentration of mining and refining capacity of these minerals in China, as well as China's effort to dominate the global supply chains for these minerals, endangers US national security and clean energy goals. The Section 301 tariffs on indium, tantalum, chromium, cobalt, and tungsten will go into effect on 27 September. Tariffs on natural graphite and permanent magnets will go into effect on 1 January 2026. China is the leading producer and exporter of indium, producing an estimated 650t in 2023, about 66pc of the global total, according to the US Geological Survey (USGS). The US imported 219 metric tonnes (t) of unwrought indium in 2023, including 10t from China. So far in 2024 the country has imported 148t, of which 45t originated in China, according to data from the US Commerce Department. Indium is primarily used globally for its electric conductivity in a variety of screens including liquid crystal displays (LCDs) as well as fiber-optic cables and other technical components. US consumption is more focused around solders and specialty alloys. The US imports more tantalum powders, alloys, and metals from China than any other country. The US imported 321t of unwrought tantalum in 2023, including 132t from China and has imported 269t between January and July 2024, including 178t from China. Tantalum is primarily used in high-temperature alloys and capacitors. Although China accounted for only 3.3pc — 79t — of global 2023 mine production, the USGS estimated the country had a world-leading 240,000t of tantalum reserves. Chromium is primarily used in stainless and heat-resistant steels. China is the world's largest producer of ferrochromium and stainless steel. The US imported 103,034t of chromium ores and concentrates in 2023, including just 10t from China. Still, the US did import 9,302t of unwrought chrome metal from China so far in 2024, which accounted for 74pc of total volumes, and US reliance on China for the metal has increased since sanctions forced Russian supplies off the table. Although China does not mine a significant amount of cobalt, it is the world's leading cobalt refiner and consumer. The US imported 18t of cobalt ores and concentrates in 2023, including 11t from China, and imported 11t between January and July 2024, including 6t from China. The US imported 1.6mn contained kilograms (ckg) of tungsten carbides in 2023, including 906,000ckg from China and imported 1mn ckg between January and July 2024, including 491,000ckg from China. Tungsten is primarily used in carbide parts for construction, metalworking, mining, and drilling applications. Tungsten is also used in specialty steel fabrication as well as in electrodes, filaments, and wires for various electrical and electronic products. By Cole Sullivan Critical Mineral Tariffs metric tonnes, t HTS Code Resource Name Imports from China, 2023 Imports from China, 2024 through July 2605.00.00 Cobalt ores and concentrates 11 6 2610.00.00 Chromium ores and concentrates 10 52 2611.00.60 Tungsten concentrates 139 46 2825.90.30 Tungsten oxides 212 19 2841.80.00 Tungstates (wolframates) 0 0 2849.90.30 Tungsten Carbide* 906,375 491,371 8101.10.00 Tungsten, powders 0 0 8103.20.00 Tantalum, unwrought 132 178 8112.92.30 Indium, unwrought; powders 10 45 Source: US Commerce Department *unit of measure is kilograms contained Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more