LNG cannot offset halt of Russian gas flows to Europe
Europe does not have enough LNG import capacity to entirely replace Russian pipeline gas supplies, should these halt or be hit by international sanctions in the event of a conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
A complete halt of Russian flows to Europe remains an extremely unlikely scenario. But the US government is assuming that transit through Ukraine would be cut in the event of an invasion and has also been preparing for the event of Russian supplies to Europe stopping altogether, even though it considers it less likely. In recent months, members of the European parliament have also called for the EU to phase out Russian gas imports.
With limited flexibility left with which to increase production or pipeline imports, ensuring sufficient gas supply to Europe in the event of a complete halt in Russian deliveries would fall almost entirely to the region's LNG terminals, which have already been bearing the brunt of offsetting dwindling Russian flows in recent months. Russian flows to Europe reached a low of about 10.3bn m³ (8mn t of LNG equivalent) in December, compared with 14bn m³ (10.9mn t of LNG) in December 2020. By contrast, LNG deliveries to Europe — excluding Turkey — rose to 6.90mn t last month, from 5.25mn t a year earlier, data from oil analytics firm Vortexa show.
As Russian pipeline flows have slowed further this month, Europe ramped up its LNG receipts, which have already totalled 8.6mn t since the start of January, on track to reach a new monthly record. Gazprom sales to Europe, excluding the Baltic states and Turkey, may have been about 3.25bn m³ (2.5mn t of LNG) in the first half of this month, based on the company's statements. Europe would have been short of about 1mn t of LNG this month if Russian flows had completely stopped, even with import terminals running at full capacity.
But terminal capacity caps how much Europe can rely on LNG, particularly during periods of peak demand, even before supply availability is considered.
Russian flows to Europe — excluding Baltic states, Moldova and Turkey — averaged 162.7bn m³/yr across 2017-20, before falling sharply to about 135bn m³ in 2021. Monthly imports over 2016-20 ranged between 9.5bn m³ in November 2021 and 16bn m³ in May 2019, the quickest in any given month since at least March 2016. These would be equivalent to 7.4mn-12.3mn t/month of LNG. But combined European import capacity — excluding Lithuania and Turkey — stands at about 151.5mn t/yr, or 12.6mn t/month — which would be barely able to accommodate LNG volumes equivalent to Russian pipeline flows, even if capacity were entirely available (see table).
This is not the case. Europe already receives LNG under long-term deals that takes up capacity at import terminals. Even when market prices in 2016-17 favoured sending gas to Asia-Pacific over Europe, European receipts ranged from 2mn-3.7mn t/month. About 2.2mn t/month of this is delivered under long-term contracts with no destination flexibility, Argus estimates, reducing the remaining available capacity at LNG terminals to 10.1mn-10.6mn t/month.
Furthermore, almost a third of Europe's regasification capacity — 44.1mn t/yr — is in the Iberian Peninsula, which has limited interconnection with the rest of Europe. Flows from France to Spain through the Pirineos pipeline could be net off if Spain receives more LNG, increasing supply availability in northwest Europe, but scope for physical reverse flows are capped by the pipeline capacity of about 19mn m³/d. Another 34.4mn t/yr is in the UK, which does not receive physical Russian flows, although it is connected to markets in which there is instead substantial scope for competition between supply sources. Russia's largest customer in Europe, Germany — which received 52.5bn m³ from Russia in 2020, according to EU statistics unit Eurostat — has no direct access to LNG.
Constraints in supply availability
Replacing Russian gas flows to Europe with LNG may also be hampered by supply availability, with historical flows broadly equating to total LNG production in the Atlantic basin at present.
Quicker global LNG production, as encouraged diplomatically by the US in recent days, would not only test European import capacity but would also face constraints in feedgas supply availability and issues with existing contractual obligations.
Technical production capacity in the Atlantic basin is only marginally higher than Europe's import capacity of about 14.5mn t/month, excluding Russian independent firm Novatek's 17.44mn t/yr Yamal plant, which could also be subject to hypothetical sanctions.
Overall LNG production within the Atlantic basin has ranged from 8.88mn-11.6mn t/month throughout 2021, excluding 1.6mn t/month from Russia's Yamal LNG export project. With global LNG prices having climbed to multi-year highs in recent months, producers already had an incentive to push output to its limits, suggesting there is limited flexibility left with which to further ramp up production. LNG production from Trinidad and most of west Africa has remained well below capacity in recent months, mainly as a result of issues with upstream gas supply.
And while the majority of Atlantic basin cargoes are sold free of destination clauses, there are still some volumes that are tied to long-term contracts with Asian buyers. The US has long-term agreements with Asian buyers on a des basis totalling about 2mn t, which would limit the scope for all US supply to be shipped to Europe, although this would still leave about 7.2mn t of more flexible supply on a monthly basis.
US administration officials have been in discussion with suppliers outside the Atlantic basin, such as Qatar and even Australia. But Qatar may have limited uncommitted volumes to supply to Europe following the start of a number of new deals with Asian buyers at the start of this year. The country's 77mn t/yr Ras Laffan export complex ran at well above its nameplate capacity for nine months to meet the unexpected jump in Japanese gas demand in the aftermath of the Fukushima-Daiichi nuclear disaster in 2011. But while it may be able to use its peak production for a short period, it is unlikely to be able to sustain peak output for an extended period by postponing regular maintenance, as it could in 2011 when many of its liquefaction trains were still quite new.
European LNG import terminals | mn t/yr | |
Name | Location | Import capacity |
Zeebrugge | Belgium | 7.2 |
Krk | Croatia | 2.0 |
Fos Tonkin | France | 1.2 |
Montoir-de-Bretagne | France | 8.0 |
Fos Cavaou | France | 6.5 |
Dunkerque | France | 12.4 |
Revithoussa | Greece | 4.9 |
Panigaglia | Italy | 2.5 |
Adriatic LNG | Italy | 5.7 |
OLT Toscana | Italy | 3.0 |
Gate | Netherlands | 8.7 |
Swinoujscie | Poland | 3.9 |
Sines | Portugal | 6.8 |
Barcelona | Spain | 12.6 |
Huelva | Spain | 8.7 |
Cartagena | Spain | 8.7 |
Bilbao | Spain | 5.1 |
Sagunto | Spain | 6.4 |
Mugardos | Spain | 2.6 |
South Hook LNG | UK | 15.6 |
Dragon | UK | 4.0 |
Isle of Grain | UK | 14.8 |
Related news posts
US M&A deals dip after record 1Q: Enverus
US M&A deals dip after record 1Q: Enverus
New York, 26 April (Argus) — US oil and gas sector mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are likely to slow for the rest of the year following a record $51bn in deals in the first quarter, consultancy Enverus says. Following an unprecedented $192bn of upstream deals last year, the Permian shale basin continued to dominate first-quarter M&A as firms competed for the remaining high-quality inventory on offer. Acquisitions were led by Diamondback Energy's $26bn takeover of Endeavor Energy Resources. Other private operators, such as Mewbourne Oil and Fasken Oil & Ranch, would be highly sought after if they decided to put themselves up for sale, Enverus says. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Start-ups to help Total keep output stable in 2Q
Start-ups to help Total keep output stable in 2Q
London, 26 April (Argus) — TotalEnergies said it expects its oil and gas production to hold broadly steady in the second quarter as planned maintenance is partially offset by rising output from new projects in Brazil and Denmark. The company expects to average 2.4mn-2.45mn b/d of oil equivalent (boe/d) in April-June, compared with 2.46mn boe/d in the previous three months and 2.47mn boe/d in the second quarter of 2023. Production is being supported by the restart of gas output from the redeveloped Tyra hub in Denmark late last month and the start of the 180,000 b/d second development phase of the Mero oil field on the Libra block in Brazil's Santos Basin at the beginning of the year. TotalEnergies first-quarter output was flat compared with the previous three months but 2pc lower than a year earlier as a result of Canadian oil sands divestments. The company reported a robust set of first-quarter results today, broadly in line with analysts' expectations. Profit for the first three months of 2024 was $5.7bn, compared to $5.6bn in the same period last year. Adjusted profit — which takes into account inventory valuation effects and special items — came in at $5.1bn, down by 22pc on the year but slightly ahead of the consensus of analysts' estimates of $5bn. Adjusted operating profit from the firm's Exploration & Production business was down by 4pc year-on-year at $2.55bn, driven in part by lower natural gas prices. The Canadian oil sands asset sales weighed on the segment's production but this was partly compensated by start-ups. As well as Mero 2, the Akpo West oil project in Nigeria started production during the first quarter. TotalEnergies' Integrated LNG segment saw a 41pc year-on-year decline in its adjusted operating profit to $1.22bn in January-March. The company said this reflects lower LNG prices and sales. But while its LNG sales for the quarter fell by 3pc in year-on-year terms, its LNG production was greater by 6pc. TotalEnergies achieved an average $78.9/bl for its liquids sales in the first quarter, an improvement on $73.4/bl a year earlier. But the average price achieved for its gas sales was 43pc lower on the year at $5.11/mn Btu. In the downstream, the company's Refining & Chemicals segment's first-quarter adjusted operating profit was $962mn in January-March, down by 41pc on the year but 52pc higher than the preceding quarter. TotalEnergies attributes the quarter-on-quarter rise to higher refining margins and a rise in refinery throughput . For the second quarter, it expects refinery utilisation rates to be above 85pc, compared with 79pc in the first quarter, boosted by the restart of 219,000 b/d Donges refinery in France. Total's Integrated Power segment continued to improve, registering a quarter-on-quarter and year-on-year increased of 16pc and 65pc respectively in its adjusted operating profit to €611mn. Net power production increased 14pc year-on-year to 9.6 TWh, while the company's portfolio of installed power generation capacity grew 54pc to 19.5GW. Total's cash flow from operations, excluding working capital, was down by 15pc on a year earlier at $8.2bn in the first quarter. The company has decided to raise its dividend for 2024 by 7pc to €0.79/share and plans a $2bn programme of share buybacks for the second quarter. By Jon Mainwaring Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Japanese gas utilities to sell more city gas in 2024-25
Japanese gas utilities to sell more city gas in 2024-25
Osaka, 26 April (Argus) — Japanese gas utilities are expecting city gas demand from their customers to rebound in the April 2024-March 2025 fiscal year, after warmer than normal weather reduced the use of the heating fuel in 2023-24. Japan's largest gas retailer by sales Tokyo Gas forecast on 25 April that its city gas sales will increase to 11.422bn m³ for 2024-25, up by 1.1pc from a year earlier. Sales to the household sector are predicted to grow by 3.4pc to 2.8bn m³, after unusually warm weather during the summer and winter of 2023-24. Supplies to the industry and commercial users are also anticipated to edge up by 0.3pc to 8.6bn m³ during the period. The optimistic outlook came after a 10.1pc year-on-year fall in city gas sales for 2023-24. Tokyo Gas sold around 2.7bn m³ of city gas, down by 2.8pc from a year earlier, to the household sector to meet weaker weather-driven demand. Sales to the industry sector plunged by 20.1pc to 4.7bn m³ because of slower operations at their customers, while wholesale sales dropped by 3.2pc to 1.56bn m³. The falls more than offset a 2.3pc rise to 2.3bn m³ in the commercial sector where hotter than normal summer weather boosted city gas demand for cooling purposes. Tokyo Gas forecast temperatures in its service area to average 16.4°C in 2024-25, down from the previous year's 17.5°C. Fellow gas retailer Toho Gas forecast its city gas sales to increase by 1.2pc from the previous year to 3.4bn m³ in 2024-25, with supplies to residential users rising by 5.6pc to 595mn m³ and sales to the industry and commercial sectors edging up by 0.3pc to 2.8bn m³. The company sold 3.37bn m³ of city gas in 2023-24, down by 2.4pc from a year earlier, pressured by the warmer weather. City gas sales by Saibu Gas are expected to rise by 2.3pc from a year earlier to 940mn m³ in 2024-25. The company expanded sales by 3pc to 919mn m³ in 2023-24. Possible increased city gas sales in 2024-25 would increase demand for its main feedstock of LNG. But the 2024-25 sales forecast by Tokyo Gas and Toho Gas would remain lower compared with their 2022-23 sales. Japan's city gas production in 2022-23 totalled 35bn m³, which required 25.5mn t of LNG, according to trade and industry ministry data. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
LNG Energy eyes sanctions-hit Venezuela oil blocks
LNG Energy eyes sanctions-hit Venezuela oil blocks
Caracas, 25 April (Argus) — A Canadian firm plans to revive two onshore oil blocks in Venezuela, but the conditional deals signed with struggling state-owned PdV come just as the US is reinstating broad sanctions on the South American country. LNG Energy Group's Venezuela unit agreed two deals with PdV to boost output in five fields in the Nipa-Nardo-Niebla and Budare-Elotes blocks, which produce about 3,000 b/d of light- to medium-grade crude, the company said on Wednesday. The Canadian company, which operates in neighboring Colombia, would receive 50-56pc of production of the blocks. Venezuela's oil ministry declined to comment. But finalizing the contracts depends on providing required investment to develop the fields within 120 days of the contract signing on 17 April, LNG Energy said. And the signing came on the same day as the US reimposed oil sanctions on Venezuela and gave most companies until 31 May to wind down business. LNG Energy Group said it intends to comply with existing and upcoming US sanctions, noting that the conditional contracts were executed within the terms of the temporary lifting of sanctions — general license 44 — but it will abide by the new license 44A. The reimposition of US sanctions on Venezuela prohibits new investment in the country's energy sector, at the threat of US criminal and economic penalties. "The company will assess in the coming days the applicability of license 44A to its intended operations in Venezuela and determine the most appropriate course of action," LNG Energy said. "The company intends to operate in full compliance with the applicable sanctions regimes." The two blocks are in the adjacent Anzoategui and Monagas states, part of the Orinoco extra heavy oil belt. Most of Venezuela's output is medium- to heavy-grade crude. Both PdV and Chevron have drilling rigs working in those two states, in separate workover and drilling campaigns. Venezuela is now producing above 800,000 b/d, after the US allowed Chevron to increase production and investment under separate waivers. By Carlos Camacho Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more