EU fines three ethylene buyers over collusion
The European Commission has fined three companies a total of €260mn for breaching EU antitrust rules by co-ordinating their approach to negotiating the price of ethylene purchases.
The three companies are Clariant, which purchases ethylene for the production of ethylene oxide in its home country of Germany; US-based Celanese, which produces vinyl acetate monomer (VAM) and acetaldehyde from ethylene; and Mexico's Orbia, parent company of German PVC producer Vestolit. All three acknowledged their involvement and agreed to settle the case.
The individual fines were calculated in relation to the size of the companies' ethylene purchases and the duration of the infringement, with various reductions related to co-operation with the investigation, for example. Clariant was fined €155.8mn, Celanese €82.3mn, and Orbia €22.4mn. A fourth company, US-based Westlake, parent of German-based PVC manufacturer Vinnolit, avoided a potential €190mn fine as it blew the whistle on the cartel arrangement. The companies involved represent a significant volume of ethylene purchases across Belgium, France, the Netherlands and Germany.
"Unlike in most cartels where companies conspire to increase their sales prices, the four companies colluded to lower the value of ethylene, to the detriment of ethylene sellers," the commission said.
Contracts between European ethylene producers and consumers typically reference a single monthly contract price (MCP). The MCP is set when a consensus emerges from individual, bilateral discussions between counterparties and is communicated to and published by price reporting agencies, including Argus. The commission said that from December 2011 to March 2017 the four purchasers "co-ordinated their price negotiation strategy to influence the MCP to their advantage."
The MCP process continues to function and is used by many ethylene buyers and sellers. The use of a single MCP for the European ethylene industry gives companies confidence that they are working from a common basis in the context of a market where the choice of alternative suppliers and/or customers can be limited by location and logistics. Ethylene is difficult and expensive to move, often limiting the options for many producers and consumers to work with alternate counterparties. The actual prices paid for ethylene remain private and confidential, dependent on the terms of individual contracts, including individually negotiated discounts.
Related news posts
Brightmark to build Georgia pyrolysis plant
Brightmark to build Georgia pyrolysis plant
Houston, 24 April (Argus) — Chemical recycler Brightmark plans to build a 400,00t/yr pyrolysis plant in Thomaston, Georgia, two years after the company terminated its plan to build a similar plant in a nearby Georgia community. Pyrolysis is a form of chemical recycling that breaks down used plastic into pyrolysis oil, which can then be reprocessed into new plastics at virgin polymers facilities. The 2.5mn ft² plant will cost $950mn, including infrastructure such as roads and rail access, Brightmark said. A previous plan to build a chemical recycling facility in Macon, Georgia, ended in 2022 after Mayor Lester Miller withdrew his support, citing "long-term safety concerns" from Brightmark's "unproven process". The company finished construction of its first chemical recycling plant in Ashley, Indiana, in 2022. Brightmark said it has recycled 2,000t of plastic waste so far at its Indiana plant, well behind its anticipated volume of 100,000 t/yr. By Zach Kluver Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
TUI Cruises receives methanol-ready ship
TUI Cruises receives methanol-ready ship
New York, 18 April (Argus) — Cruise ship company TUI Cruises took delivery of a methanol-ready cruise ship which will start operations at the end of June. Methanol-ready vessels allow ship owners to easily retrofit their vessels to burning methanol in the future. The 7,900t deadweight Mein Schiff 7 will operate in the North Sea, the Baltic Sea, along the European Atlantic coast and in the Mediterranean and run on marine gasoil (MGO). It was built by Finland's Meyer Turku shipyard. In January, TUI Cruises signed a memorandum of understanding with trading company Mabanaft for future supply of green methanol. Mabanaft would cover TUI's methanol needs in northern Germany, and gradually add other European locations. Grey methanol was pegged at $717/t MGO equivalent and biomethanol at $2,279/t MGOe average from 1-18 April in Amsterdam-Rotterdam-Antwerp. About 0.9 times and 2.9 times, respectively, the price of MGO, Argus assessments showed. TUI Cruises is a joint venture between the German tourism company TUI AG and US-based cruise ship company Royal Caribbean. By Stefka Wechsler Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Nova Chemicals preps for potential Canadian rail strike
Nova Chemicals preps for potential Canadian rail strike
Houston, 18 April (Argus) — Nova Chemicals is taking certain precautions such as making early shipments and forward placement of inventory at US storage locations to mitigate against potential polyethylene (PE) supply disruptions caused by a possible Canadian rail strike that could take place as early as 22 May, the company said in a letter to customers. The Canadian National (CN) and Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPKC) railroads are (currently negotiating contracts)[https://direct.argusmedia.com/newsandanalysis/article/2553764] with the Teamsters Canada Rail Conference, which represents 9,300 employees across both railroads. The earliest a strike could begin is 12:01am ET on 22 May, but any work stoppage at either railroad could cause widespread disruption to rail traffic across Canada. "NOVA Chemicals utilizes CN and CPKC to serve our manufacturing facilities and delivery polyethylene products and co-products to our customers," the company said in a 15 April letter to customers. "A labor strike within the Canadian railroad industry will result in disruptions and delays, impacting the timely delivery of these products." Where practical, the company said it will ship product early prior to any strike, it said in the letter. It will also attempt to place some inventory at US off-site storage locations before the strike takes place, which will allow it to continue to serve US customers during a strike. Additionally, Nova said it is maintaining a direct line of communication with rail officials, and creating contingency plans for raw materials supply. "Despite our best efforts to mitigate these challenges, there may be instances where shipments are delayed or rerouted due to the strike action," the letter says. If a strike takes place, market participants said it would likely last around 3-4 days, but could cause delays to shipments for up to two weeks. However, the overall US/Canada market is well-supplied, so any shipment delays should not create significant tightness in the market, sources said. Union employees at each railroad will vote electronically from 8 April to 1 May on whether to approve a strike. By Michelle Klump Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
US spot PGP falls to lowest since November
US spot PGP falls to lowest since November
Houston, 17 April (Argus) — US prompt-month spot polymer-grade propylene (PGP) fell this week to the lowest in nearly five months on weak domestic demand for some smaller volume propylene derivatives, especially acrylonitrile (ACN) and propylene oxide (PO). US PGP traded on Tuesday at 41.5¢/lb, down by 30pc since 5 March and the lowest price since late November. US PGP's pricing in recent years has mostly been driven by supply changes, but market participants believe that some of the price drop since early March stems from weakness in PGP's smaller demand sources like ACN and PO. ACN consumes about 7pc of US propylene, declining from 10pc over the last six years, and PO accounts for around 11pc of US demand for propylene. US demand remains weak for polypropylene (PP), which accounts for about half of domestic PGP demand, but has increased over the last few weeks, with operating rates improving. Rising PGP demand has been offset by falling production of smaller volume derivatives like ACN and PO, largely driven by elevated PGP spot prices in the first quarter that narrowed margins. Cornerstone's 257,000 metric tonne (t)/yr ACN unit in Waggaman, Louisiana, has been down on an extended turnaround, according to market sources. That unit comprises 16pc of the US ACN capacity, according to Argus data. Another producer told Argus that ACN is being produced "to order," as demand has not been steady, saying "these are tough times" for ACN. A PO producer in Texas began a planned turnaround this month that is expected to last until mid-May, reducing demand for US propylene. The turnaround has shut 20pc of US PO capacity, according to Argus data. By Michael Camarda Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more