Distillate blending in VLSFO raises concerns
Blending jet and road fuels into the marine fuel pool could lead to a lower flash point, increasing cleaning costs and risking engine damage, ship testing data has shown.
The practice is understood not to be widespread in Europe, but has been a greater concern in Asia-Pacific bunker markets.
Fuel testing company Veritas Petroleum Services (VPS) told Argus that density and viscosity values of 0.5pc fuel oil (VLSFO) around the world have become lower as the year has progressed. This suggests lighter fuels, such as road and aviation fuels, have been blended into the VLSFO pool, VPS said. The firm said 46pc of the 37 bunker alerts it has issued this year have been for low flash points with all marine fuel types affected.
"We believe these [transport fuels] may have been blended into marine fuels and being more volatile, this blending has lowered the flash point. In addition, viscosities and densities of VLSFOs have been wide ranging since their introduction," group commercial director at VPS Steve Bee said.
The impact of Covid-19 on jet and transport fuel demand has led to a surplus of these fuels at relatively lower costs. The strength of marine fuel prices over jet fuel prompted some blending of straight-run kerosine to produce VLSFO in Singapore, the world's largest bunkering hub. VLSFO has held a premium to jet fuel traded in Singapore since the end of August, averaging $10/t in September. In Europe, VLSFO averaged a discount of $30/t to jet during the same period. Comparatively, jet fuel averaged a $66/t premium to VLSFO in Singapore and $130/t in Europe in September 2019.
Market participants confirmed that the blending of distillates in to the marine pool is not happening on a significant scale in Europe.
But blending of jet and road fuels in to VLSFO has caused concern. Too much straight-run kerosine has the potential to lower the temperature at which fuels ignite, known as the flash point, posing a dangerous risk to ship engines. The minimum flash point for A1 jet fuel is 38°C compared with a minimum for VLSFO of 60°C.
These blending practices could also result in fuel instability and lead to asphaltene precipitation in tanks and ship engines resulting in the formation of sludge. This has the potential to block pipes, filters and centrifuges and result in higher cleaning costs for tank and ship owners.
Marine lubricant performance could be impacted by higher asphaltene precipitation. Lubricants could struggle to keep a higher asphaltene content in suspension. The deposition of sludge in ship engines can lead to loss of fuel economy and, at worst, irreversible engine damage.
UK-based testing firm Bureau Veritas has previously warned that "extreme caution" should be used when blending jet fuel with bunker fuel.
Efforts to keep distillate blending within marine fuel specifications would minimise the risk of adverse effects. "The amount of jet fuel that eventually can be blended into marine fuel is certainly restricted by the minimum flashpoint requirement for marine fuels of 60°C," Monique Vermeire, fuels technologist at Chevron, said. There is also the requirement that "all delivered fuels shall be stable, meaning asphaltenes kept in solution which is covered by the potential total sediment limit of 0.1pc maximum," she said. Vermeire is also the convenor of the ISO working group responsible for marine fuels standard ISO 8217.
Related news posts
Italy's Falconara refinery widens crude slate
Italy's Falconara refinery widens crude slate
Barcelona, 10 September (Argus) — Italian refiner API is widening the crude slate at its 83,000 b/d Falconara refinery, joining other Mediterranean operators in seeking new grades because of political disruption and ownership changes. Falconara was a keen importer of Iraqi Kirkuk crude between 2019-23, before a dispute between the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) and Turkey halted exports. In 2022 Falconara received 33 crude cargoes, all but five of which were Kirkuk grade. Since the second half of July this year Falconara received six cargoes, all of different grades. August receipts were 75,000 b/d, up from 50,000 b/d a month earlier, according to Argus tracking. Deliveries were 35,000 b/d of Saudi Arab Light and 40,000 b/d of Libyan crude, split between Es Sider and Sarir. The latter was the first at Falconara in eight years. In September Falconara has taken 1mn bl of Kazakh Kebco and, according to Kpler data, a first cargo of 125,000bl cargo of Italian onshore Val'd Agri. At 38.4°API and 2.1pc sulphur Val'd Agri is close to Kirkuk's 36°API and 2pc sulphur, although output is far lower. Argus assessed Falconara's receipts at 55,000 b/d in January-August. The slate was a weighted average gravity of 30.6°API and 2pc sulphur content, compared with 31.8°API and 2pc sulphur overall last year and 35.6°API and 1.8pc in 2022, when Kirkuk dominated. Other regional refiners have changed their sourcing. Italy's Saras is importing a first cargo of Azeri Light since February 2022 , with light sweet Libyan alternatives halted by conflict. It may take different grades as trading firm Vitol becomes its new owner, after Trafigura had supplied large amounts of US WTI. Greece's Motor Oil Hellas (MOH) had to find an alternative to a 1mn bl cargo of Basrah Medium that was attacked in the Red Sea on the way to its 180,000 b/d Corinth facility. MOH opted for a first cargo of Guyanese Unity Gold. Helleniq Energy has changed its slate in the absence of Kirkuk and sanctioned Russian Urals, and it took first cargoes of Guyanese crude , and Ivory Coast crude and struck a deal with Iraq for Basrah grades. . Spain's Repsol is boosting cargoes of heavy Venezuelan crude under a sanctions waver and API's Trecate refinery has increased receipts of Nigerian Qua Iboe since it bought out ExxonMobil. Argus estimates Italian seaborne crude imports — excluding the northeast terminal of Trieste — at 1.13mn b/d in August, a four-month high and up from 1.06mn b/d in July. For a seventh consecutive month, Azeri BTC Blend and Libyan grades were Italy's largest imports, at 205,000 b/d and 195,000 b/d respectively. Nigeria and Caspian CPC Blend each supplied 125,000 b/d and Arab Light 115,000 b/d. By Adam Porter Italy crude imports mn bl Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Paraguay River's record low slows fuel imports
Paraguay River's record low slows fuel imports
Sao Paulo, 9 September (Argus) — Water levels in the Paraguay River reached an all-time low in the capital of Asuncion today, hindering fuel imports. River depth at the Asuncion port was 89cm (35 inches) below normal levels for the first time in 120 years of measurement, according to Paraguay's meteorology and hydrology department DMH. Fuel imports into Paraguay largely depend on 3,000m³-capacity (18,990 bl) barges that carry product from the 171km (106-mile) mark of the Parana Guacu River, in the Parana River's delta in Argentina. As a result, barges are being loaded to about 80pc of capacity, or 2,500m³ each. One of the three docks belonging to state-owned oil company Petropar is inoperative because of the low river level in Villa Elisa, in Asuncion's metropolitan region. Another Petropar dock has a stationary barge serving as a bridge to access another barge. Still, freight tariffs have not increased yet, market participants said. The river's low levels are the result of scarce rainfall amid a persistent drought for the last few years, DMH said. DMH forecasts below-average rains in most of the region and especially in the Paraguay River basin for the next months. By Flavia Alemi Paraguay river draft in Asunción m Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Venezuelan vote ends in opposition leader's exile
Venezuelan vote ends in opposition leader's exile
Caracas, 9 September (Argus) — Venezuelan opposition leader Edmundo Gonzalez landed in Spain on Sunday after an arrest warrant accused him of terrorism as President Nicolas Maduro continues to crack down on dissent despite international condemnation. Gonzalez fled to Spain after several days of shuttling between foreign embassies in Caracas "to save his liberty, integrity and life," Maria Corina Machado, Gonzalez's ally and the key opposition figure blocked by Maduro from running in the election, said on social media. "My departure from Caracas was surrounded by episodes of pressure, coercion and threats in order to not allow me to leave," Gonzalez said in an audio post to his followers. "I am confident that in the near future we will continue the struggle to achieve freedom and recover democracy in Venezuela." The US and other countries have not recognized official election results from 28 July and backed the opposition coalition's claim that Gonzalez likely was the winner. But Washington has refrained from taking any action, including enforcing an even stricter regime of oil and other sanctions, to force Maduro to cede power. "The United States strongly condemns Maduro's decision to use repression and intimidation to cling to power by brute force rather than acknowledge his defeat at the polls," secretary of state Antony Blinken said. Gonzalez's departure highlighted pessimism over the possibility of a negotiated departure for Maduro, who claims that he won a third term. "Today is a sad day for democracy," EU foreign affairs representative Josep Borrell said, saying that removing Gonzalez from Venezuela was the only solution for now. Oil minister and vice-president Delcy Rodriguez confirmed Gonzalez's departure late on 7 September, labeling Gonzalez an "opposition citizen" who was granted safe passage after requesting political asylum. In the days after the election, 23 demonstrators and one national guard member were killed, according to figures from the Organization of American States. Maduro boasted of arresting 2,500 "terrorists", but human rights non-governmental organizations say the detainees are demonstrators, election workers, politicians and journalists. According to the human-rights group Foro Penal, more than 1,700 are still in jail. By Carlos Camacho Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Plaza Marine alleges Ankora used company secrets
Plaza Marine alleges Ankora used company secrets
New York, 6 September (Argus) — New Jersey-based marine fuel supplier Plaza Marine is suing another supplier, Ankora Fuels, alleging that two former Plaza Marine employees used company trade secrets to benefit a rival company and to compete in the same market. Plaza Marine alleges that the two ex-employees, John and Zachary Barbarise, used its trade secrets, confidential information, customer, and supplier relationships to conduct business that is virtually identical to Plaza Marine, according to the suit filed last month in US District Court for the District of New Jersey. John Barbarise was vice president of sales and trading at Plaza Marine until May 2023 and Zachary Barbarise was an operations manager until July 2024. Both individuals are listed as defendants in the suit in addition to Ankora Fuels. According to the lawsuit, John and Zachary's positions at Plaza Marine gave them access to proprietary information about Plaza Marine's business including contracts with its customers, supplier lists and long-term planning like price strategies for its customers. Plaza Marine alleges that John and Zachary used this information to attempt to "clone" Plaza Marine including chartering a vessel that is a long-term vendor of the company and creating a pricing methodology that is like Plaza Marine. This has created confusion in the marine fuel market, according to Plaza Marine. "By creating a competing company engaged in virtually the same activities as Plaza Marine, it is inevitable that John and Zachary will necessarily use and disclose Plaza Marine's trade secrets for their own personal gain and to create an unfair competitive advantage for Ankora," the company said in the suit. According to the lawsuit, prior to resigning from Plaza Marine, Zachary allegedly contacted John on multiple occasions and accessed files related to Plaza Marine's customers, including once after an internal meeting that discussed confidential information related to its customers and suppliers. Zachary also allegedly created Google document files on a personal device and copied and pasted Plaza Marine's trade secrets into that file prior to departing from the company. Plaza Marine alleges that Zachary was passing along this confidential information to John for use at Ankora. Ankora said the allegations are "completely baseless" and that John and Zachary have never taken any information from Plaza Marine. The company said that Zachary has never worked for Ankora and the Google sheets Plaza Marine allegedly found in Zachary's computer were files "for a fantasy football draft and an ultimate fighting championship contest." "The simple truth is Plaza Marine does not want to face competition from a new player in its space. Plaza Marine wants to continue to mistreat customers and other business partners by blocking Ankora Fuels' entry into the market. That's why Plaza Marine has filed this baseless lawsuit. Plain and simple. We are confident that our customers will see the same, and that they will realize – if they haven't already – that Plaza Marine is not a good partner for their businesses," Ankora said. By Luis Gronda Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more