Generic Hero BannerGeneric Hero Banner
Latest market news

Doubts persist on suitability of EU CBAM

  • Market: Emissions, Metals
  • 08/12/21

The European Commission's proposals for a carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) may not be the most effective way of preventing emissions, and divisions remain on how the measure should be implemented, delegates at a conference this week heard.

Speaking at a conference organised by the International Emissions Trading Association, research lead at the Cambridge Institute for Sustainability Leadership Sanna Markkanen said it is difficult to see how the CBAM could be implemented quickly enough to make the emissions cuts required, questioning whether there might be other more effective tools that could be implemented quicker.

Markkanen agreed with Cillian O'Donoghue of European non-ferrous association Eurometaux that the mechanism should be tested before free allocations of EU emissions trading system (ETS) allowances to industry are phased out.

And both called for anti-circumvention measures to be strengthened, to ensure that countries do not simply export the already "green" section of their products to the EU and sell the others elsewhere, leading to no material reduction in emissions.

The scope of the mechanism should to be extended to avoid market distortions, Markkanen said. Eurometaux wants a number of finished aluminium products to be added to the scope, which should also extend as far down the value chain as possible for any additional metals.

But indirect emissions should be excluded from the CBAM until 2030, O'Donoghue said, by which point the decarbonisation of the power sector would reduce related costs for producers.

CBAM "makes no sense" unless a solution to the problem of exports is found, O'Donoghue added, saying that maintaining free EU ETS allowances until 2030 would be the easiest workaround until then.

Producers could be allowed to keep their free allocations for the percentage of products they export, or be paid back at the end of the year, O'Donoghue suggested. If exports are integrated in both directions on the border it can be compatible with World Trade Organisation rules, he said.

But head of unit for the commission's directorate-general for taxation and customs union Vicente Hurtado Roa said there were doubts as to what a solution for exports would look like, adding that it is an ongoing discussion.

France, which will take over the presidency of the EU Council for the first half of next year, wishes to make enough progress to be in a position to launch trilogue discussions between the European Parliament, the commission and the EU Council from July, Hurtado Roa said, with the aim of finalising discussions by the end of 2022.

But he warned that positions on the matter remain unclear, with some calling for a faster full implementation of the mechanism from 2025 and some for the scope to be expanded to more sectors and emissions from the same date.

The commission put forward its proposals for a CBAM in July. The mechanism is designed to impose a carbon price on certain goods imported to the EU, thereby tackling carbon leakage — when companies relocate to other jurisdictions to avoid carbon costs, or more carbon-intensive imports replace EU products. Under the commission's plans, the measure would be fully implemented in 2026 following a transitional phase over 2023-25.

Representatives from the commission and parliament indicated that they saw a softening of international opposition to the CBAM during their attendance of the UN Cop 26 climate conference last month.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

Cop 30 is ‘pivot point’ to climate action: Summit head


23/05/25
News
23/05/25

Cop 30 is ‘pivot point’ to climate action: Summit head

London, 23 May (Argus) — The UN Cop 30 climate conference will launch a "a new era of putting into practice" what has been agreed at previous Cop summits, Cop 30 president-designate Andre Correa do Lago said in a letter issued today. Correa do Lago focused on implementing the Paris climate agreement by driving action in the letter — his third setting out the Cop 30 presidency's priorities. Cop 30 "can be that pivot point" to "a new generation of climate conferences", delivering progress in climate action, Correa do Lago said. He reiterated the findings of the first global stocktake, including the call to transition away from fossil fuels — the first mention of fossil fuels in the letters that the Cop 30 president-designate has issued. The global stocktake was the main outcome of Cop 28 in 2023 , and measured global progress on tackling climate change. Today's letter was released ahead of ‘halfway-point' climate talks in June, hosted by UN climate body the UNFCCC in Bonn, Germany. Correa do Lago urged negotiators in Bonn to deliver "concrete results" that can be formally adopted at Cop 30. This "can help our process avoid the risks and stresses that have been damaging mutual trust year by year", he added. Correa do Lago acknowledged "ongoing calls" for reforming the Cop process and asked parties to "consider the future of the process itself", including a more efficient approach. In the meantime, "it is advisable to avoid introducing potentially contentious new agenda items that could further burden the process or detract from agreed priorities", he noted. Cops should focus on implementation and concrete actions, Cop 30 executive director and climate change secretary at Brazil's environment ministry Ana Toni said this week. "We need to do much more", and countries should not rely just on Cop summits, she told the Financial Times Climate and Impact Summit Europe on 22 May. In Bonn, the Cop 30 presidency will give "special focus" to adaptation, the just transition, and implementing the outcomes of the global stocktake. But "all substantive items under discussion are important", Correa do Lago emphasised. Cop 30 is scheduled for 10-21 November in Belem, in Brazil's Para state. By Georgia Gratton Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

EU defence spending to support PGM demand


23/05/25
News
23/05/25

EU defence spending to support PGM demand

London, 23 May (Argus) — Higher defence spending by Europe and its allies in response to changing US foreign policy will support platinum group metal (PGM) demand in the coming years. Increased defence spending is expected to boost demand across specialty metals as the EU attempts to meet the short-term needs of Ukraine's military and to strengthen Europe's defence in the longer term. The European Commission's ReArm Europe plan aims to drive €800bn in defence investment. Higher defence spending is unlikely to result in an immediate increase in demand for specialty metals — orders for the EU plan are expected to translate into increased demand no earlier than the second quarter of 2026. PGMs are key components in aircraft engines, with platinum and rhodium used for temperature sensing and platinum for protective plating on blades. Platinum and iridium are also present in missile nose cones. "In the case of PGMs, it is often the heat resistance that is very important. In some rocket systems, you need extremely high-performing metals to guarantee that they work," a senior market analyst said. PGMs also have crucial avionics and electronics applications. Ruthenium is used for chip resistors, while palladium is used for capacitors and other components. Rhodium and iridium are also utilised for reed switches. Lasers and optical systems, such as night-vision goggles, also use PGMs. Platinum-rhodium alloys are used in the production of technical glass, while iridium complexes are key for organic light-emitting diodes. And platinum is used in fuel cells for non-nuclear air-independent submarines and fuel cells for silent, long-duration field power and drones. Price no barrier for defence consumption Defence is market where the high price of certain PGMs compared with base metal substitutes does not weigh on demand. "PGMs are used because they provide certain characteristics and properties that lend themselves to defence applications. You would use PGMs rather than base metal alternatives because you are looking for that safety and longevity — price isn't an issue," Johnson Matthey market research director Rupen Riathatha told Argus in an interview. Raithatha cited electronics as a clear example of differing approaches to metal consumption. In the 1990s, producers of multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs) for consumer markets largely substituted nickel for palladium because of nickel's lower cost. But the defence sector has continued to use palladium metal electrode MLCCs because of their better performance and reliability. PGM supply to stay constrained But supply constraints might be a challenge for the defence sector. In December 2024, Nato included platinum on a list of 12 critical raw materials essential for advanced defence systems. "The availability and secure supply of these materials are vital to maintaining Nato's technological edge and operational readiness. Disruptions in their supply could impact the production of essential defence equipment," Nato said. Many countries have platinum on their critical mineral list because of the concentration of production in South Africa and Russia. In the near term, recognition of PGMs' importance to defence is unlikely to impact market dynamics, as low PGM prices continue to limit output. The platinum market is entering its third consecutive year of deficit, according to the World Platinum Investment Council. The deficit is expected to deepen to 966,000oz in 2025. Supply in 2025 is forecast at its lowest in five years, down by 4pc from 2024 to 6,999,000oz. South African mines, which supply much of the world's PGMs, have struggled in recent years with industrial action, high energy costs and low PGM basket prices. The challenging price landscape resulted in significant restructuring and production cuts in 2024. Platinum mine supply continues to face downside risks in 2025, WPIC said. But the PGM market has a large recycling circuit that is often not taken into account in critical mineral discussions, which often overemphasise primary mine supply. "There is a wide network of PGM flows that do not require panic stockpiling of metals," the senior analyst said, referring to the recycling circuit. "There is sufficient production capacity, it is just the economic side that needs to come up." By Maeve Flaherty Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

China’s Sinopec invests in CATL for EV battery growth


23/05/25
News
23/05/25

China’s Sinopec invests in CATL for EV battery growth

Beijing, 23 May (Argus) — Chinese state-controlled oil refiner Sinopec has invested in country's largest battery producer CATL, to help reach its target of building 10,000 electric vehicle (EV) battery exchange stations. Sinopec was the largest cornerstone investor in CATL's initial public offering (IPO) this week, it said on 23 May. CATL raised $4.6bn from the sale of 135.6mn of its shares on the main board of the Hong Kong Stock Exchange on 20 May, in what was likely the world's largest IPO this year. The two firms reached an initial agreement in April to build more than 500 EV battery exchange stations nationwide this year. They have set a target of building 10,000 stations in the long term. Sinopec and CATL on 21 May also reached final agreement to co-operate on the Qiji Exchange Station project for heavy trucks in southeast China's Fujian province. The project will serve road freight transportation on the coastal route between the Yangtze River Delta and the Pearl River Delta using CATL's latest battery exchange system. Sinopec has so far built 30,000 integrated energy charging stations in China to serve 300mn users, including around 10,000 EV charging and battery exchange stations. An increasing number of conventional energy companies in China have accelerated investments in the new energy market in recent years, particularly given rapid growth in the country's EV sales. State-run energy firm and refiner PetroChina launched a "supercharger satiation" in the Yili road area of Shanghai in March. PetroChina, domestic automaker SAIC, Sinopec and CATL established the Shanghai JieNeng Zhidui New Energy Technology joint venture in September 2022, to lease EV battery packs and develop EV battery exchange technology. CATL is building a 40 GWh/yr factory in Dongying, which is the largest oil refining city in China. Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US car tariffs cut Japan's auto industry sales orders


23/05/25
News
23/05/25

US car tariffs cut Japan's auto industry sales orders

Tokyo, 23 May (Argus) — The Japanese auto industry, especially component producers, are receiving lower-than-usual sales orders from clients likely because of the US' blanket 25pc tariff on car imports, the country's trade and industry ministry (Meti) said today. The impact of the US levy on domestic industries is emerging, according to a survey conducted by Meti. Concerns about the future sales outlook and business climate are also growing, it added. Meti has been conducting the survey on the US measure since early April, and released the preliminary results based on around 3,100 responses . An unnamed auto part producer received slightly lower than usual sales orders for April-June. But the tariff could cut its July orders by 20pc from usual levels, according to the survey. The actual sales order volume was not disclosed. Meanwhile, a manufacturer of car air conditioners was asked to delay its delivery for three months from June to September, likely because of the tariff measure, Meti said. An auto interior material producer said its business is reaching its breakeven cost, adding that it received 15pc fewer orders. The firm also said it may have to consider seeking new clients in non-car industries to secure profits, according to Meti. Another component producer said its US subsidiary is bearing the 25pc tariff on its raw material imports from Japan, adding that it is concerned about to what extent the situation would deteriorate. It remains unclear if or how much Japanese car producers will reduce their deliveries to the US, as Tokyo and Washington continues negotiations regarding the measure. Japan's passenger vehicle exports to the US increased by 12pc in April from a year earlier to 124,428 units, despite the tariff. By Yusuke Maekawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more