National Grid cites lightning as trigger for blackout
A lightning strike was the initial trigger for a series of events that culminated in the UK's largest power cut since 2008, transmission system operator National Grid said.
In an interim report to regulator Ofgem, National Grid said there was a lightning strike on a transmission circuit in Cambridgeshire at 16:52 local time on 9 August. Automatic protection systems operated as planned to clear the lightning and the line returned to normal operations in under 20 seconds, although around 500MW of embedded generation connected to the low-voltage distribution grid was disconnected.
But immediately following this, two large generation sites — the Hornsea offshore wind farm and the Little Barford gas plant — both suddenly reduced output to the grid, with a combined fall of 1,378MW.
It was this loss of generation that caused the frequency on the grid to fall below its normal range and then triggered some automatic disconnections of demand at local distribution grids, known as low frequency demand disconnection (LFDD).
Lightning strikes on the transmission grid are a regular occurrence, with more than 1,000 a year in the UK. National Grid said the decline in output at Little Barford and Hornsea "occurred independently of one another but each [was] associated with the lightning strike".
Large generation units would not be expected to trip as a result of a lightning strike and so this "appears to represent an extremely rare and unexpected event", it said. National Grid will make a final report to Ofgem next month, with more detailed information.
The operators of the plants described different circumstances that led to their plants tripping, making it unclear what exact role the lightning strike played.
Danish utility Orsted, which owns Hornsea, said that the plant had immediately ramped down from 799MW to 62MW after a system voltage fluctuation "with unusual characteristics" that was coincident with the lightning strike.
Little Barford, owned by German utility RWE, saw its 244MW steam turbine trip, followed automatically by a gas turbine because of a change in steam pressure. A second gas turbine was manually tripped by staff in response to high steam pressure 30 second later, taking 641MW off line.
National Grid had 1,000MW of capacity on rapid response standby at the time but the combined decline of 1,378MW was too large for it to handle, leading to the frequency deviation. The capacity available included 472MW of battery storage and all of this was dispatched automatically in response to the frequency deviation.
As electricity system operator, National Grid is obliged to hold enough immediate frequency response and reserve capacity to ensure that the system remains stable following the loss of the single largest unit without the disconnection of any demand, but the combined effect of two simultaneous outages proved too much.
The most widespread disruption caused by the power cut was to rail services around London and the southeast of England. Trains halted as the frequency deviation caused an automatic shutdown, rather than because of a total loss of power. Two makes of train "reacted unexpectedly to the electrical disturbance" and half of these trains could not be restarted by their drivers, requiring visits from engineers, which extended the effective shutdown of rail services for several hours. This will be investigated further by Network Rail, which owns most of the railway network, and train operator Govia Thameslink.
A final report is due to be presented to Ofgem by 6 September.
Related news posts
Malaysia sets up cross-border renewable energy exchange
Malaysia sets up cross-border renewable energy exchange
Singapore, 17 April (Argus) — The Malaysian government is creating the Energy Exchange Malaysia (Enegem) to allow for cross-border "green electricity" sales to neighbouring countries, starting with pilot sales to Singapore. The auctioning process for cross-border sales of clean electricity will begin with a 100MW pilot run utilising the existing connection between peninsular Malaysia and Singapore, announced Malaysia's Ministry of Energy Transition and Water Transformation on 15 April. The auction will be open to renewable energy bidders in Singapore that have import licences issued by Singapore's Energy Market Authority. This pilot phase of 100MW is to "make sure that it works, and then if it does work, hopefully it can be expanded to a gigawatt level," said the chairman of the Energy Commission Malaysia Rashdan Yusof at the Atozero conference in Singapore on 17 April. "On the demand side, there will also be an auction for suppliers of renewable energy into the exchange," said Rashdan, adding that the exchange will aggregate all the renewable energy sector participants, predominantly in the solar sector, and then provide the energy to Singapore, depending on requirements such as load factors, among other things. Malaysia aims to catalyse the development of the Asean regional electricity grid and cross-border energy trading. There are "tremendous discussions" on future interconnections, said Rashdan. Malaysian state-owned utility TNB has signed six agreements with utility counterparts in Thailand, Vietnam and Laos, and has two feasibility studies planned with utilities in Indonesia and Singapore, he said, without providing additional details on these deals. There is great willingness to establish this regional power grid but one of the obstacles is that "each jurisdiction has different energy pricing systems," said Rashdan. There is a significant difference in energy pricing between Singapore and Malaysia, for example, as energy is largely subsidised in Malaysia. "These subsidies, I find, will be a core impediment in terms of the free flow of electrons," he added. "The energy exchange can level the economic and commercial playing field, so that money can flow. Once the money can flow, the electrons will flow. That's the aim of the energy exchange, to have that transparency and market-based system, without the distortion of price subsidies." There are a number of bilateral power agreements in the region, with some even crossing multiple borders, such as the Laos-Thailand-Malaysia-Singapore Power Integration Project, which connects renewable power supplies from Laos to Singapore. But Asean countries need to scale up to multilateral power trading to fully benefit from regional grid interconnectivity. Regional grid optimisation in Asean could cut the net present cost of full decarbonisation by 11pc from $7.2 trillion to $6.5 trillion, according to international classification society DNV's Asia-Pacific regional director for energy systems Brice Le Gallo last year. By Prethika Nair Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
BHP to expand gas-fired West Australia power station
BHP to expand gas-fired West Australia power station
Sydney, 17 April (Argus) — Australian resources firm BHP plans to increase power generation at its 154MW Yarnima gas and diesel-fired facility near the Pilbara iron ore mining hub of Newman in Western Australia (WA) state. The proposal, according to documents filed with WA's Environmental Protection Authority (EPA), will see output increase by 85MW to a total of 239MW through gas reciprocating engines and associated infrastructure with up to 120MW of nominal new capacity to be built in stages. Peak scope 1 greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the project are predicted to be 480,030 t/yr of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e), while scope 3 emissions related to supplying the gas are expected to be 37,260t CO2e/yr. Power demand at BHP's iron ore operations in the Pilbara is forecast to increase from 150MW currently to 1GW by 2040, as the company reduces its GHG emissions through electrification of its rail and mining fleets and must balance renewables with firmed generation. The iron ore mining sector is a large-scale producer of Australian GHG emissions through its Pilbara-based operations. Displacing liquid fuels such as diesel, which Australia consumes at an average rate of around 500,000 b/d by electrifying processes and switching to lower CO2-emitting sources such as gas, is expected to trend as Australia's largest polluters meet government mandates . Yarmina currently runs a 35MW diesel-fired temporary power station as part of its installed capacity. Canadian energy firm TransAlta earlier this year lodged plans to build a new 150MW gas-fired power station for BHP's Nickel West operations in WA's Northern Goldfields region. WA's domestic market is likely to be short on gas later this decade despite being Australia's largest LNG export state, the Australian Energy Market Operator (Aemo) has warned in its Western Australia Gas Statement of Opportunities. Aemo's modelling released last year shows the closure of WA's state-owned coal-fired power stations will drive increased requirements for gas-fired electricity generation in the next decade. By Tom Major Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
AES closes 276MW coal-fired power in Chile
AES closes 276MW coal-fired power in Chile
Santiago, 16 April (Argus) — US utility AES has disconnected its two Norgener coal-fired plants from Chile's national grid, removing 276MW of combined capacity almost two years earlier than scheduled. The plants in northern Chile's Antofagasta region were originally due to close on 31 December 2025. AES has 3.4GW of generation assets in Chile of which now more than half are renewable, it said. The early closure of Norgener 1 and 2, which began operations in 1995 and 1997, respectively, is part of the country's commitment to close all coal-fired plants by 2040. To date, it has closed 11 coal-fired plants with combined capacity of nearly 1.7GW, or 30pc of the 5.5GW in operation in 2019 when the phase-out plan was announced. A further four plants with a combined capacity of 873MW are scheduled to close in 2025, according to the energy ministry. A public-private decarbonization working group is developing a roadmap through 2030 to speed up the closure of Chile's remaining coal plants. By Emily Russell Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Jera targets 20GW renewable power capacity by 2035-36
Jera targets 20GW renewable power capacity by 2035-36
Tokyo, 16 April (Argus) — Japan's largest power producer by capacity Jera has renewed its renewable power output target to 20GW by the 2035-36 fiscal year ending 31 March, in line with the acceleration of its offshore wind power presence in Europe. Jera originally planned to increase its renewable power portfolio to 5GW by 2025-26 in its business plan in 2019. But the acquisition of Belgian offshore wind firm Parkwind accelerated the plan and renewable power output will be 3.4GW this year, Jera said. It last month set up a 100pc subsidiary Jera Nex in UK to achieve the new target. Jera last month won an auction to develop a 1.5GW offshore wind farm in Norway's North Sea Sorlige Nordsjo II through Ventyr, a joint venture between Parkwind and Netherlands-based Ingka Investments. The new firm is specialising in global renewable energy and will cover new projects in Norway. By Reina Maeda Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more