Viewpoint: 1H 2020 US ethylene oversupplied
US spot ethylene prices may continue their recent decline into 2020 as two major Gulf coast ethane crackers totaling 2.75mn t/yr of capacity started up in December with two smaller crackers slated to come online in early 2020.
Fundamental oversupply of the US ethylene market is the main driver behind price declines and could keep prices weak into 2020. To find an outlet for supply US ethylene producers are looking to Enterprise and Navigator Holdings' new 1mn t/yr ethylene export terminal at Morgan's Point, Texas. The terminal is coming online on schedule with the first cargo loading for Asia in December, but US ethylene exporters face an uncertain trade environment.
China, always the main intended export market for US ethylene, is unlikely to remove its 25pc tariffs on the monomer until a comprehensive trade deal is finalized. "Phase 1" of the US-China trade deal did impact some polymers, but did not remove tariffs on ethylene. This tariff has effectively closed the arbitrage for US ethylene to China, sending US exports into neighboring countries, particularly Taiwan. The arbitrage to China would open if US ethylene were to fall another 3-4¢/lb, or if Chinese domestic prices increased by a similar amount.
The recent decline in US prices comes on the heels of US spot prices doubling in the third quarter amid new PE demand and traders covering short positions following an explosion that took a cracker offline for over two months. Ethylene at Mont Belvieu, Texas, on 1 July stood at 14¢/lb and began rising on demand from the startup of ExxonMobil's 650,000 t/yr polyethylene (PE) unit in Beaumont, Texas. Spot ethylene extended gains on 31 July, when an explosion of a propylene recovery unit attached to the back end of ExxonMobil's 1.179mn t/yr cracker at Baytown, Texas, lifted prices to 20¢/lb.
The weeks following the blast prompted a rush on ethylene from Boardwalk's Choctaw, Louisiana, system. The rapid ethylene withdrawals depleted brine levels too quickly at the Choctaw ethylene cavern, prompting a force majeure. Only when the force majeure lifted did Mont Belvieu ethylene tumble from the 2019 peak of 29¢/lb on 2 October to less than 20¢/lb by 15 October.
Start-up delays at new Gulf coast crackers thwarted supply expectations in the second half of 2019. Five new crackers totaling 4.67mn t/yr of new ethylene capacity were slated to come online in 2019.Through early December, only Lotte/Westlake's 1mn t/yr cracker in Lake Charles, Louisiana, had started up, representing only 22pc of this year's expected expansion.
The largest capacity startup of 2019 is Sasol's 1.5mn t/yr cracker in Lake Charles, Louisiana. That plant started up in late August but could only achieve 50pc operational rates. The facility was then shut down on 30 November to perform maintenance on acetylene reactor catalysts, work that finished on 17 December, after which the company reported 90pc run rates, sending ethylene prices to under 16¢/lb at Nova and under 15¢/lb at the Choctaw cavern.
Formosa's 1.25mn t/yr cracker began its 3-week start up on 21 December, the very back end of its original second-half 2019 target. Indorama's 420,000 t/yr ethylene unit in Lake Charles achieved stable production in early May before shutting down in June and is now expected to restart this month. Shintech's 500,000 t/yr cracker in Plaquemine, Louisiana, was supposed to begin commissioning in February 2019, but only began by mid-October and has yet to be confirmed as fully operational.
The US remains in a structural oversupply of ethylene that may deepen as cracker startup issues are resolved, keeping prices from rising into 2020. Current inventories, while much lower than they were to start the year, are still around 35pc above the level needed for supply to be closer to demand with sufficient cushion for unforeseen events.
New demand from US polyethylene units may keep ethylene prices from falling to all-time lows, with four of six planned units already online. The final two units, Formosa's and Sasol's, are expected to start up in early 2020.
By Michael Camarda
Related news posts
Singapore's MPA, IEA unite on maritime decarbonisation
Singapore's MPA, IEA unite on maritime decarbonisation
Singapore, 17 April (Argus) — The Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA) and the IEA have signed an initial deal to push the transition to zero and near zero emission fuels, while working on technology as well as digitalisation to meet the maritime decarbonisation agenda. The agreement, signed by MPA chief executive Teo Eng Dih and IEA executive director Faith Birol, was announced at the Singapore Maritime Week 2024 (SMW) this week. "Greater international collaboration in maritime and energy industries is critical for international shipping to meet international decarbonisation goals," Teo said. "Shipping is one of the hardest sectors to decarbonise and we need to spur development and deployment of new technologies to slow and then reverse the rise in its emissions," said IEA chief economist Tim Gould. "This will require strong collaboration at a national and international level." Training programmes will be built to support the adoption of new fuels. There will also be partnerships made towards fuel-related projects and initiatives such as the International Maritime Organisation-Singapore NextGen project. The IEA plans to open its first regional co-operation centre in Singapore, which will be its first regional office outside of its headquarters in Paris, France. By Mahua Chakravarty Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Japan’s Idemitsu builds stake in refiner Fuji Oil
Japan’s Idemitsu builds stake in refiner Fuji Oil
Tokyo, 17 April (Argus) — Idemitsu has agreed to buy an additional stake in fellow Japanese refiner Fuji Oil from domestic power producer Jera, adding to their existing partnership. Idemitsu on 16 April said it will buy Jera's entire 8.75pc share of Fuji, raising its stake to 21.79pc, for ¥2.5bn ($16.2mn). It is unclear when the companies will complete the deal. Jera declined to disclose the reasons for selling its stake. Idemitsu in March also bought domestic petrochemical producer Sumitomo Chemical's stake in Fuji to boost its share to 13.04pc from 6.58pc, becoming its main shareholder. It aims to further optimise fuel oil production and sales including refinery operations, while promoting decarbonisaton of its businesses. Idemitsu is enhancing its partnership with Fuji in the face of shrinking domestic oil and petrochemical demand and growing consumption in overseas, especially in southeast Asia. Idemitsu owns the 190,000 b/d Chiba refinery in the Keiyo industrial complex in east Japan's Chiba prefecture where Fuji operates the 143,000 b/d Sodegaura refinery. Their refineries are connected to Sumitomo Chemical's Chiba plant. Idemitsu's refineries also include the 150,000 b/d Hokkaido in the northernmost prefecture of Hokkaido, the 160,000 b/d Aichi in Aichi prefecture in central Japan and the 255,000 b/d Yokkaichi in Mie prefecture in the country's west. Idemitsu's subsidiary Toa Oil operates the 70,000 b/d Kawasaki refinery in east Japan's Kanagawa prefecture. By Nanami Oki Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
US Gulf lowest-cost green ammonia in 2030: Report
US Gulf lowest-cost green ammonia in 2030: Report
New York, 16 April (Argus) — The US Gulf coast will likely be the lowest cost source of green ammonia to top global bunkering ports Singapore and Rotterdam by 2030, according to a study by independent non-profits Rocky Mountain Institute and the Global Maritime Forum. Green ammonia in Singapore is projected to be sourced from the US Gulf coast at $1,100/t, Chile at $1,850/t, Australia at $1,940/t, Namibia at $2,050/t and India at $2,090/t very low-sulphur fuel oil equivalent (VLSFOe) in 2030. Singapore is also projected to procure green methanol from the US Gulf coast at $1,330/t, China at $1,640/t, Australia at $2,610/t and Egypt at $2,810/t VLSFOe in 2030. The US Gulf coast would be cheaper for both Chinese bio-methanol and Egyptian or Australian e-methanol. But modeling suggests that competition could result in US methanol going to other ports, particularly in Europe, unless the Singaporean port ecosystem moves to proactively secure supply, says the study. In addition to space constraints imposed by its geography, Singapore has relatively poor wind and solar energy sources, which makes local production of green hydrogen-based-fuels expensive, says the study. Singapore locally produced green methanol and green ammonia are projected at $2,910/t and $2,800/t VLSFOe, respectively, in 2030, higher than imports, even when considering the extra transport costs. The study projects that fossil fuels would account for 47mn t VLSFOe, or 95pc of Singapore's marine fuel demand in 2030. The remaining 5pc will be allocated between green ammonia (about 1.89mn t VLSFOe) and green methanol (3.30mn t VLSFOe). Rotterdam to pull from US Gulf Green ammonia in Rotterdam is projected to be sourced from the US Gulf coast at $1,080/t, locally produced at $2,120/t, sourced from Spain at $2,150/t and from Brazil at $2,310/t. Rotterdam is also projected to procure green methanol from China at $1,830/t, Denmark at $2,060/t, locally produce it at $2,180/t and from Finland at $2,190/t VLSFOe, among other countries, but not the US Gulf coast . The study projects that fossil fuels would account for 8.1mn t VLSFOe, or 95pc of Rotterdam's marine fuel demand in 2030. The remaining 5pc will be allocated between green ammonia, at about 326,000t, and green methanol, at about 570,000t VLSFOe. Rotterdam has a good renewable energy potential, according to the study. But Rotterdam is also a significant industrial cluster and several of the industries in the port's hinterland are seeking to use hydrogen for decarbonisation. As such, the port is expected to import most of its green hydrogen-based fuel supply. Though US-produced green fuels are likely to be in high demand, Rotterdam can benefit from EU incentives for hydrogen imports, lower-emission fuel demand created by the EU emissions trading system and FuelEU Maritime. But the EU's draft Renewable Energy Directive could limit the potential for European ports like Rotterdam to import US green fuels. The draft requirements in the Directive disallow fuel from some projects that benefit from renewable electricity incentives, like the renewable energy production tax credit provided by the US's Inflation Reduction Act, after 2028. If these draft requirements are accepted in the final regulation, they could limit the window of opportunity for hydrogen imports from the US to Rotterdam to the period before 2028, says the study. By Stefka Wechsler Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Romania's growing autogas market boosts 2023 imports
Romania's growing autogas market boosts 2023 imports
Demand for autogas is expected to continue rising in the country as it maintains a discount to competing motor fuels Moscow, 16 April (Argus) — Romania's autogas consumption increased last year as more drivers were attracted by its lower price compared with gasoline and diesel, helping to lift imports to the country by over a quarter on the year. Autogas sales in the country rose by 10,000-30,000t on the year to 270,000-300,000t as a result of its lower price against other motor fuels. "The ratio of autogas to gasoline prices fell below 50pc last year from 60-65pc owing to rising global gasoline and diesel prices," a Romanian trader says. Romanian autogas prices stood at 3.27-3.35 lei/litre (71-73¢/l) last week, while gasoline prices were Lei7.12-7.15/l ($1.50/l), putting the former at 47pc of the latter . This compares with autogas' cost of Lei3.91-3.98/l in April 2023, and gasoline at Lei6.63-6.69/l, with a ratio of 59-60pc. The country's autogas demand could have been even stronger last year had it not been for a fire at the Flagas refuelling station in Crevedia, near Bucharest, in August. Immediately after the accident, a special commission consisting of firefighters, police, an environmental body and tax authorities was formed to carry out inspections at the country's autogas stations, resulting in many being closed. "The commission would close a fuelling station for a slightest non-compliance, so some retail operators shut down their fuelling stations before it arrived," a market participant says. Romania has more than 1,000 autogas refuelling sites. But around 300 stations are reported to have closed since September 2023 following the incident. This resulted in sales dropping in September-December last year compared with the same period in 2022, according to local market participants. The growth in autogas sales over the whole of last year boosted Romania's LPG imports to around 353,000t compared with 278,000t in 2022, Vortexa data show. All of the country's LPG deliveries were to its sea ports of Midia, Mangalia and Galati, as rail shipments from Russia transiting Ukraine, which had been 2,000-3,000 t/month, halted after the war in Ukraine began in late February 2022. Imports were also supported by cuts to domestic output and an increase in overland exports. Exports rose by about 5,000–10,000t to 330,000–340,000t in 2023, according to market participants, with most of this supported by rising shipments to Ukraine, growing by 45,600t to 235,600t. Romania's LPG imports from Egypt doubled to 104,200t, Vortexa data show, with most of this supplied by trading firms Naftomar and Evicor. Arrivals from Turkey grew by 51,300t to 69,600t, mostly delivered by Turkish distributors Aygaz and Milangaz. More Kazakh LPG arrived from Georgia's Batumi port, rising by 14,800t to 27,600t, to partially offset the loss of supply from Russia's Taman terminal after exports halted in May 2023. LPG arrivals from Algeria and the US also increased last year (see table). Gassing up Romania's autogas demand should be on course to continue expanding this year, with autogas prices at around an 80¢/l discount to gasoline at the beginning of April. The government raised autogas excise duty again from 1 January, to around Lei874/t ($191/t). But it also increased the duty on gasoline to Lei2.02/l and on diesel to Lei1.85/l, and will do so again from 1 July to Lei2.38/l and Lei2.18/l, respectively, while the rate on autogas is expected to remain unchanged. Autogas sales in the country are expected to increase to 280,000-320,000t this year from 270,000-300,000t in 2023 because of lower excise tax on LPG compared with gasoline and diesel, according to traders. Exports should stabilise while domestic output will increase as technical issues at the Rompetrol refinery are resolved, they say. Seaborne LPG imports to Romania '000t 2023 ±% 2022 Egypt 104.2 99.5 Turkey 69.5 35.7 Russia/Kazakhstan 54.5 -163.0 Georgia 27.6 86.8 US 27.1 49.0 Algeria 26.9 50.2 Tunisia 12.0 11.1 Greece 6.3 -235.4 Croatia 5.7 -456.2 Italy 3.7 183.2 Netherlands 3.4 247.4 Libya 1.1 -283.3 Other 11.6 11.6 Total 353.5 30.8 — Vortexa Romania LPG demand by sector 2022 Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more