Mexican industry prepares lawsuits on power reform
Companies in an array of sectors from manufacturing to convenience stores plan to pursue legal action against the Mexican government if congress approves a proposed power sector reform bill.
More than 500 domestic and foreign companies are planning to file amparos, or constitutional appeals, against the proposed reform, said Jorge Arrambide, a Mexican attorney representing companies preparing legal action.
"Without a doubt, we are expecting a tsunami of amparos," said Adrian Sada, chief executive of Mexican glass producer Vitro and head of industrial chamber Caintra. "[The reform] violates many rights for practically all the small, medium and large industrial companies."
The bill, approved by the lower house of congress and under debate in the upper house today, seeks to prioritize power dispatch generated by state power company CFE, revoke self-supply permits and review all long-term power purchase agreements with independent power producers.
The reform would raise the cost of electricity for manufacturers and would put at risk arrangements to buy electric power directly from generators at lower prices, said Sada, whose company is the largest glass producer in Mexico.
"Many investors came to produce or invest in our country, and many Mexican companies invested in electric power generation, with certain rules of the game that are now being threatened," he said.
Companies are already preparing injunctions that allege the proposed law violates the Mexican constitution in areas such as free competition and environmental protection, said Arrambide, an attorney at law firm Santos Elizondo.
Some appeals also allege violations to international agreements such as the US-Mexico-Canada free trade agreement (USMCA), he said.
Foreign firms may also pursue international arbitrage under USMCA, but will begin with appeals in Mexico because they are quicker and can suspend immediate implications for plaintiffs, Arrambide and Caintra said.
Companies that file successful injunctions will not have to abide by the reform, but such actions will not undo the law or suspend it for other companies, he said.
Sada said the appeals have a "very high probability of success" because judges have ruled in favor of similar legal actions in the past. Arrambide also said he expected judges to rule in favor of the injunctions.
"The federal government has not considered the magnitude of the impact that this law will have," said Guillermo Dillon, director general of Caintra. "When [the law] moves forward, the government will be overwhelmed by the repercussions."
Related news posts
Idemitsu books rare US Gulf-Vancouver HVO cargo
Idemitsu books rare US Gulf-Vancouver HVO cargo
New York, 17 April (Argus) — Japanese oil company Idemitsu provisionally hired a medium range (MR) tanker to carry hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) from the US Gulf coast to Vancouver on 16 April, a sign of the growing HVO trade from the region into west coast North America. Idemitsu put the Stolt Sisto MR on subjects for a US Gulf coast-Vancouver voyage from 20-25 April at $2.35mn lumpsum. The fixture may be part of an agreement under which Vertex Energy supplies Idemitsu's California-based subsidiary, Idemitsu Apollo, with all of its renewable diesel production from its plant in Mobile, Alabama. The plant's exports are targeting "growing regional markets in the western United States and Canada", according to Vertex. High freight costs for US domestic shipments because of the Jones Act may be encouraging Idemitsu to focus on the Canadian market. In comparison, freight for a US-flagged MR on a New Orleans-Los Angeles voyage was equivalent to $4.34mn, nearly double the cost of a voyage to more distant Vancouver. "I think [demand from Vancouver] will keep expanding with the subsidies/grants," a shipbroker said. "There is not much production in Vancouver, just Parkland [refinery]." Canadian oil company Suncor typically books one MR vessel a month to carry HVO from the US Gulf coast to Vancouver, with two charters in October 2023 standing out as a particularly active month for the trade, according to ship fixtures compiled by Argus . But Idemitsu has been "jumping in on the action" in recent months, according to the shipbroker, provisionally hiring at least one MR tanker on the spot market in January and February before yesterday's deal. Vancouver buyers are also getting HVO from Asia-Pacific suppliers, and countries like South Korea could become increasingly competitive in the renewable trade overall as they ramp up their sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) and HVO production in the coming years. Vancouver imported around 29,500 b/d of HVO in January 2024, including 16,612 b/d from the US, 7,548 b/d from South Korea, and 5,351 b/d from Taiwan, according to Kpler data. By Ross Griffith Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Sheinbaum pledges $13bn for Mexican energy transition
Sheinbaum pledges $13bn for Mexican energy transition
Mexico City, 17 April (Argus) — Mexican presidential candidate Claudia Sheinbaum pledged to invest $13.6bn in electricity infrastructure through 2030, with a key focus on Mexico's energy transition. "We are going to accelerate the energy transition with new solar, wind and hydropower projects," Sheinbaum told a meeting of business associations in Merida, Yucatan, on 15 April. Former Mexico City mayor Sheinbaum is ahead of opposition candidate Xochitl Galvez for the 2 June presidential election, according to recent polls. While Sheinbaum is the continuity candidate for President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador's Morena party, she has been a vocal supporter of clean energy development in contrast to Lopez Obrador's pursuit of conventional power projects and a restriction on private sector renewable energy development. "We are developing a national energy plan not just to 2030 but towards 2050 to coincide with our international climate change commitments," Sheinbaum said. Mexico committed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 35pc by 2030 from a 2000 baseline at the Cop 27 climate talks in 2022. Key projects through 2030 include 13.66GW of new power capacity across three hydropower plants, the third and fourth phases of the 1GW Puerto Penasco solar plant, two gas-fired combined cycle plants, cogeneration plants for the Cadereyta and Salina Cruz refineries, and additional wind and solar capacity. In addition to large scale electricity projects, Sheinbaum also committed to a build out of distributed generation, calling for the installation of solar panels in residential and commercial property. But while Sheinbaum pledged her "commitment to reaping the benefits of the historic moment Mexico is seeing in terms of foreign direct investment," she also recommitted to cap private sector electricity participation at 47pc. Foreign direct investment into Mexico hit $36.1bn in the fourth quarter of last year, 22pc above the same period in 2022, but investment into the energy sector has tanked under Lopez Obrador's statist energy policies, according to the latest statistics from the economy ministry. Lopez Obrador's government has largely focused on fossil fuel-based electricity generation, including the construction of new gas-fired combined cycle plants. But despite a commitment to build at least five combined cycle plants during his administration, Sheinbaum confirmed that only the Merida plant is due to launch by the end of this year. Launch dates for the Valladolid, San Luis Colorado, Gonzalez Ortega and Tuxpan plants have been pushed back to 2025-2030. By Rebecca Conan Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Exxon German refinery sale in limbo after court ruling
Exxon German refinery sale in limbo after court ruling
Hamburg, 17 April (Argus) — ExxonMobil's plan to sell its share in German refining joint venture Miro has been delayed by a court order following a petition by fellow Miro shareholder Shell. ExxonMobil agreed to sell its 25pc stake in Miro , operator of the 310,000 b/d Karlsruhe refinery, to Vienna-based Alcmene in October last year. The two sides were aiming to close the deal in the first quarter of this year, but in a letter seen by Argus last month, ExxonMobil said completion had been pushed back to the summer because some of the administrative procedures had yet to be finalised. Argus has since learned that a regional court in Karlsruhe issued an interim order against the sale on 18 January at Shell's request. Shell originally petitioned a court in Hamburg on 20 November, but the case was later moved to Karlsruhe, according to a court spokesperson. The judgement prohibits ExxonMobil from splitting off or transferring its Miro shares. The firm has already appealed against the judgement to a higher court in the region. A decision is pending. Exonmobil's partners in Miro are Shell with a 32.25pc stake, Russia's Rosneft with 24pc and US firm Phillips 66 with 18.75pc. Rosneft's German refinery assets have been under state trusteeship since September 2022. By Natalie Mueller Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Nigeria's Dangote diesel offers cut local prices
Nigeria's Dangote diesel offers cut local prices
London, 17 April (Argus) — Nigeria's 650,000 b/d Dangote refinery has offered road diesel at the lowest price since it began distillate sales earlier this month, and market participants said this is likely to weigh heavily on local values and import markets. The refinery dropped prices for diesel, known in Nigeria as automotive gasoil (AGO), to 1,000 naira/litre (87¢/l) for a minimum of 1mn l, and offered a discount of N30/l for offtake of 5mn l and above, it said. The price changes took effect today. The N1,000/l offer equates to around $950/t for product that market participants say contains 700ppm sulphur. The move by Dangote was labelled as "very aggressive pricing" by a trader, while other sources said it "crashed the market". Local marketing companies were offering AGO at as low as N1,140/l ex-depot by the close on 16 April, according to a source, while Dangote was offering at N1,210/l. Dangote began offering AGO at around N1,200/l three weeks ago, which was a 30pc reduction from the then market levels of around N1,600/l, the company said today. The Major Energies Marketers Association of Nigeria (MEMAN) assessed ex-depot prices at the Apapa Hub in Lagos at N1,396/l on 29 February. Output from Dangote is altering Nigeria's import structures, with local high sulphur gasoil buyers captive to the refinery's supply. The refinery operator has secured an exemption from Nigeria's 200ppm sulphur product import cap , allowing it to supply its 700ppm sulphur product locally. The high sulphur gasoil offshore Lome ship to ship (STS) market was described by a market participant today as "almost dead". No bid or offer levels for 10,000-20,000t STS transfers were reported today. The most competitive offer was at a premium of $25/t against Ice May gasoil futures, for loading between the last week of April and the first week of May. Dangote refinery began selling diesel and jet to the domestic market earlier this month . A spokesman told Argus then that Nigerian product marketing companies began loading diesel and jet from the refinery onto 30t trucks and minimum 22,000t tankers. Around 70-80pc of truck loadings from the refinery are destined for areas of the country outside Lagos, according to a market participant. Dangote said today it had loaded diesel onto the 35,000 dwt tanker Golden Lavender, which appeared to make the first domestic seaborne delivery of Dangote-origin diesel and jet since the refinery started middle-distillate production, discharging on 10 April at Tincan Island, Lagos, according to Kpler. Dangote's jet output may not yet be fit for use in aviation, according to a source who said it may currently be used as dual-purpose kerosine for power and heat generation. By George Maher-Bonnett Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more