Colstrip coal plant owners sue over Montana law
Four co-owners of the Colstrip coal-fired power plant in Montana are suing their partners over a new law they say invalidates a longstanding operations agreement between the companies.
Puget Sound Energy (PSE), PacifiCorp, Avista and Portland General Electric (PGE) filed a lawsuit against Northwestern Corporation and Talen Energy in the US District Court for the District of Montana on 4 May, saying SB265 violates both the US and Montana constitutions. They asked the court to declare the law unconstitutional.
The new law, which Montana governor Greg Gianforte (R) signed on 3 May, requires all disputes concerning power plants in the state be settled within Montana and be overseen by state courts. That would give NorthWestern and Talen, which supported the law, a means to invalidate part of Colstrip's 1981 ownership and operations agreement that requires arbitration take place in Washington state, PSE, PacifiCorp, Avista and PGE said.
The new law comes at a time when "there is an actual and substantial controversy between plaintiffs and defendants," PSE, PacifiCorp, Avista and PGE said.
PSE, PacifiCorp, Avista and PGE are bound by state laws in Washington and Oregon to stop supplying coal-fired generation to retail customers in those states by 2025 and 2030, respectively. They have said that a determination to close Colstrip units needs the approval of only 55pc of the owners, but NorthWestern and Talen say the vote must be unanimous.
A companion bill that Gianforte also signed into law on 3 May, SB266, also requires a unanimous vote for Colstrip's owners to close the units and would give the state attorney general the right to fine each plant owner $100,000 a day for not funding their share of operating costs.
NorthWestern, which has a 30pc stake in Colstrip unit 4, initiated arbitration over the voting dispute in March, with Talen following up with a proposal to move the venue to Montana. NorthWestern declined to discuss details of the talks with Argus but said it wants the voting question "answered as soon as possible."
Talen did not respond to a request for comment.
The plaintiffs said in the lawsuit that moving the arbitration to Montana would slow down the dispute process and be more costly since the companies or a judge would have to find three arbitrators. Colstrip's ownership and operations agreement calls for one arbitrator.
Neither the state of Montana nor Gianforte were named in the lawsuit. Avista said its does not intend to sue the state but the state attorney general may seek to intervene since the lawsuit involves a challenge to a statute's constitutionality.
The lawsuit also does not mention SB266, but Avista, PSE, PacifiCorp and PGE expressed disappointment in the measure.
The new bills allow a third party to rewrite long-standing business contracts, which is "unconstitutional and sends the wrong message to businesses," PSE said.
PSE holds a 25pc stake in Colstrip units 3 and 4, while PGE has 20pc, Avistra has 15pc stake and PacifiCorp holds 10pc. Talen holds a 30pc stake in unit 3 and operates the plant. Talen also has a vote sharing agreement with NorthWestern.
State senator Steve Fitzpatrick (R), who sponsored both bills, said the purpose of SB265 "is to ensure a fair arbitration is conducted for any issues relating to the Colstrip plant. And SB266 will "prevent the west coast utilities from prematurely closing the plant or operating the plant in a manner which will destroy the value of the plant."
"I believe there will be a market for power from Colstrip," Fitzpatrick said.
Colstrip is the largest coal plant in the US northwest. PSE and Talen closed units 1 and 2 were closed in January 2020.
The plant generated 7.9mn MWh in 2020 and received 5.1mn short tons (4.5mn metric tonnes) of coal from Westmoreland's Rosebud mine in Montana, US Energy Information Administration data shows.
Related news posts
Barge delays at Algiers lock near New Orleans
Barge delays at Algiers lock near New Orleans
Houston, 24 April (Argus) — Barges are facing lengthy delays at the Algiers lock near New Orleans as vessels reroute around closures at the Port Allen lock and the Algiers Canal. Delays at the Algiers Lock —at the interconnection of the Mississippi River and the Gulf Intracoastal Waterway— have reached around 37 hours in the past day, according to the US Army Corps of Engineers' lock report. Around 50 vessels are waiting to cross the Algiers lock. Another 70 vessels were waiting at the nearby Harvey lock with a six-hour wait in the past day. The closure at Port Allen lock has spurred the delays, causing vessels to reroute through the Algiers lock. The Port Allen lock is expected to reopen on 28 April, which should relieve pressure on the Algiers lock. Some traffic has been rerouted through the nearby Harvey lock since the Algiers Canal was closed by a collapsed powerline, the US Coast Guard said. The powerline fell on two barges, but no injuries or damages were reported. The wire is being removed by energy company Entergy. The canal is anticipated to reopen at midnight on 25 April. By Meghan Yoyotte Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Baltimore to temporarily open 4th shipping channel
Baltimore to temporarily open 4th shipping channel
Cheyenne, 24 April (Argus) — The Port of Baltimore is preparing to open another, deeper temporary shipping channel this week so at least some of the vessels that have been stranded at the port can depart. The new 35-ft deep Fort McHenry Limited Access Channel is scheduled to be open to commercially essential vessels from 25 April until 6am ET on 29 April or 30 April "if weather adversely impacts vessel transits," according to a US Coast Guard Marine Safety Information Bulletin. The channel will then be closed again until 10 May. The channel also will have a 300-ft horizontal clearance and 214-ft vertical clearance. This will be the fourth and largest channel opened since the 26 March collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge. The Unified Command has said that the new limited access channel should allow passage of about 75pc of the types of vessels that typically move through the waterway. Vessels that have greater than 60,000 long tons (60,963 metric tonnes) of displacement will likely not be able to move through the channel and those between 50,000-60,000 long tons of displacement "will be closely evaluated" for transit. There were seven vessels blocked from exiting the port as of 27 March, including three dry bulk carriers, one vehicle carrier and one tanker, according to the US Department of Transportation. Two of the bulk carriers at berth in Baltimore are Kamsarmax-sized coal vessels, data from analytics firm Kpler show. The US Army Corps of Engineers still expects to reopen the Port of Baltimore's permanent 700-foot wide, 50-foot deep channel by the end of May. The Key Bridge collapsed into the water late last month when the 116,851dwt container ship Dali lost power and crashed into a bridge support column. Salvage teams have been working to remove debris from the water and containers from the ship in order to clear the main channel. By Courtney Schlisserman Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
EU adopts sustainability due diligence rules
EU adopts sustainability due diligence rules
Brussels, 24 April (Argus) — The European parliament has formally approved a Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), which will require large EU companies to make "best efforts" for climate change mitigation. The law will mean that relevant companies will have to adopt a transition plan to make their business model compatible with the 1.5°C temperature limit set by the Paris climate agreement. It will apply to EU firms with over 1,000 employees and turnover above €450mn ($481mn). It will also apply to some companies with franchising or licensing agreements in the EU. The directive requires transposition into different EU national laws. It obliges member states to ensure relevant firms adopt and put into effect a transition plan for climate change mitigation. Transition plans must aim to "ensure, through best efforts" that business models and company strategies are compatible with transition to a sustainable economy, limiting global warming to 1.5°C and achieving climate neutrality by 2050. Where "relevant", the plans should limit "exposure of the company to coal-, oil- and gas-related activities". Despite a provisional agreement, EU states initially failed to formally approve the provisional agreement reached with parliament in December, after some member states blocked the deal. Parliament's adoption — at its last session before breaking for EU elections — paves the way for entry into force later in the year. Industry has obtained clarification, in the non-legal introduction, that the directive's requirements are an "obligation of means and not of results" with "due account" being given to progress that firms make as well as the "complexity and evolving" nature of climate transitioning. Still, firms' climate transition plans need to contain "time-bound" targets for 2030 and in five-year intervals until 2050 based on "conclusive scientific" evidence and, where appropriate, absolute reduction targets for greenhouse gas (GHG) for direct scope 1 emissions as well as scope 2 and scope 3 emissions. Scope 1 refers to emissions directly stemming from an organisation's activity, while scope 2 refers to indirect emissions from purchased energy. Scope 3 refers to end-use emissions. "It is alarming to see how member states weakened the law in the final negotiations. And the law lacks an effective mechanism to force companies to reduce their climate emissions," said Paul de Clerck, campaigner at non-governmental organisation Friends of the Earth Europe, pointing to "gaping" loopholes in the adopted text. By Dafydd ab Iago Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Ayala’s South Luzon coal plant eligible for retirement
Ayala’s South Luzon coal plant eligible for retirement
Manila, 24 April (Argus) — Early decommissioning of coal-fired power plants in the Philippines has advanced with utility Ayala Energy's 246MW South Luzon Thermal Energy eligible for the US-based Rockefeller Foundation's coal to clean credit initiative (CCCI). The Rockefeller Foundation is a non-profit philanthropic group that creates and implements programmes in partnership with the private sector across different industries aimed at reversing climate change. Ayala has been working with the foundation to further shorten South Luzon's operating life from an original decommissioning date of 2040 to 2030. Doing so could result in the reduction of up to 19mn t of carbon emissions, Ayala said. An assessment by the Rocky Mountain Institute, the technical partner of the foundation for its energy-related projects, found that an early retirement date of 2030 instead of the original retirement date of 2040 could yield positive financial, social and climate outcomes. But decommissioning by this date will require carbon finance. Carbon financing will need to cover costs associated with the early retirement of the power plant's power supply contract, costs associated with 100pc clean replacement of the plant's power generation, plant decommissioning and transition support for workers affected by the plant's early closure, Ayala said. Ayala's listed arm ACEN welcomed the plant's eligibility for the CCCI programme, as its retirement is part of the company's goal to have its power generation portfolio composed solely of 100pc renewable sources by 2025. The Philippines' Department of Energy (DOE) said if successful, the pilot programme could serve as a basis for the development of other early retirement efforts as part of the country's plan to reduce carbon emissions. The DOE is seeking the early decommissioning of coal-fired power plants older than 20 years with a combined total capacity of 3.8GW by 2050, as part of the Philippines' transition to clean energy. By Antonio delos Reyes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more