Coal edges oil in gas price formation

Author Edward Bentley

This is the second of two blogs looking at the influence of coal, emissions and oil markets on gas prices.

Oil prices increased so European gas prices are up — that is the usual story.

Except crude markets have not been the main driver behind the recent rally of NBP and TTF forward prices, at least not directly.

Coal swaps have led prompt prices higher — as shown in yesterday’s blog — and this is also the case for forward contracts.

The NBP first-quarter 2019 market has largely followed the UK fuel-switching price, based on a 55pc-efficient gas-fired plant and a 39pc-efficient coal-fired unit.


This combination of coal and emissions prices has driven gas forward markets on more days than the cost of oil-indexed gas.

There have been 60 days since 1 November when UK first-quarter 2019 fuel-switching prices and North Sea Dated denominated in pounds have moved in opposite directions. The NBP first-quarter 2019 contract has moved with fuel-switching levels on 32 days and with oil on 28.

While this is only a small difference, the TTF first-quarter 2019 market moved with continental fuel-switching levels on 36 occasions and just 23 with euro-denominated North Sea Dated prices.

And taking every trading day since 1 November, the percentage change in the NBP first-quarter 2019 market has been most similar to the change in fuel switching 81 times and North Sea Dated just 56.

Oil retains its importance

This shows that crude prices still have a significant influence on gas hubs, even if the fuel-switching range is setting the main support levels for NBP and TTF prompt and forward markets.

The traditional mechanism for oil driving gas markets has largely disappeared. The International Gas Union found that only 9pc of contracts in northwest Europe were linked to oil prices in 2016.

Instead of the obsolete story that higher crude prices filter into northwest Europe’s import costs, there are other mechanisms at work.

Oil prices have been a driver of coal markets because diesel can comprise up to 40pc of operating and inland transportation costs. The recent rally has contributed to pushing up the European fuel-switching range.

And the integration of the European gas market combined with a drop in Dutch production has made the northwest more dependent on other regions, particularly Iberia, where there is still substantial oil indexation.

Links to crude prices in the LNG market can also filter through to European hubs. The decline of Dutch production could result in more demand for LNG, at least during cold spells or severe supply disruption.

NBP and TTF prompt prices rose to become the global premium markets at times last winter, including during the late February-early March cold snap.

Firmer crude markets driving global LNG prices up increases the potential upside risk at European hubs if the region has to once again compete for cargoes.

The UK fuel-switching price is typically the first soft price ceiling European hubs hit if the supply-demand balance is tight. But prompt prices can rapidly jump towards Middle East and northeast Asian LNG prices if the UK’s switch to coal from gas for power generation is not enough to help the region balance.

Global LNG prices have typically peaked at oil parity in recent winters. Another European cold snap coinciding with strong northeast Asian demand could result in NBP and TTF prompt prices also testing oil parity, requiring this risk to be factored in to first-quarter 2019 contracts.


Related blog posts

23 May 2018

Whatever it takes

This is the first of two blogs looking at the influence of coal, emissions and oil markets on gas prices.


Natural gas/LNG Europe English

09 May 2018

UK government rebuffs gas storage pressure

There could be more price spikes and calls for support for facilities in the coming winters, although the real issue could again be limited availability of gas rather than storage.


Natural gas/LNG Europe English

11 April 2018

Northwest Europe meets record gas demand

Europe faced high heating demand in the face of bitter cold in late February-early March, and Europe's declining gas production could mean more prompt price spikes even if it is not as cold.


Natural gas/LNG Europe English