Carbon price to impact biofuels markets: Ieta

Market: Biofuels, Emissions
29/09/21

The range of legal proposals aligning climate and energy legislation with the EU's 55pc emissions-reduction target by 2030 — including the revision of the bloc's emissions trading system (ETS) — will impact the biofuels markets, Adam Berman, EU policy director at the International Emissions Trading Association (Ieta), told Argus.

How important is carbon pricing for biofuels markets?

Carbon pricing is really important as a tool for climate action in the road transport sector. But it is not the silver bullet and needs to be complemented by sector specific policies to make alternatives, such as biofuels, price-competitive. On top of an enhanced ETS, with a separate road transport and buildings ETS, changes to energy taxation and other mechanisms will enable cost competitive biofuels to be rolled-out at scale.

Is there enough political support for road transport under the EU ETS?

Let's be clear, there is no direct inclusion of road transport or buildings into the general ETS. The commission's proposal is to establish a separate ETS for road transport and buildings. Sectors predominantly covered by the ETS have reduced emissions by over 30pc since 1990. For road transport, emissions have gone up by over 33pc since 1990. So a carbon price will provide a strong signal alongside enhanced policies like higher renewables ambition levels. Ultimately, the EU ETS covers 40pc of emissions, works well and provides really significant revenues for decarbonisation.

Will there not be political push-back?

It is a precarious moment politically. A reasonable carbon price for transport is needed that increases over time with revenues redistributed in a meaningful way to low-income households. Mitigating push back might also include moderating the proposed price structure.

As it stands the commission's proposal allows, from the very first day, for the road transport/building ETS price to float freely. We have no idea what that price could be with estimates ranging from €50 to even €150 per tonne. Germany has a good national ETS for road transport with a fixed price and price corridor. All said, there's a good chance that the ETS for road transport and buildings will get through. Otherwise it'll be very hard to reach the overall GHG emission reduction targets.

Will there be enough of an ETS carbon price signal to push biofuels?

This separate ETS for road transport and buildings is more suited to the higher abatement costs in the transport sector. It is a quicker path to biofuel usage than if regulation alone were used or if road transport had been put into the general ETS. Over time, there will almost certainly be a higher road transport/housing ETS price, because of the higher abatement costs with those sectors.

The general ETS is multi-sector so it would take some time before solutions like biofuels would equate to where the [separate road transport] abatement cost is. I would not want to hazard a guess as to the exact carbon price if the market is allowed to float freely, but it may well be above €100/t.

What will carbon pricing do for sustainable aviation fuels (SAFs)?

Carbon pricing is part of the picture. At the moment, the International Civil Aviation Organisation's (ICAO) Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (Corsia) scheme is at an early stage. SAFs and other solutions have to be brought in. But it is very hard to know at exactly what carbon price solutions like SAFs become cost-effective as a result of fuel price fluctuations, national regulation and more.

And it is not just about SAFs getting cheaper but also about traditional emitting fuels getting more expensive, also via carbon pricing. The EU ETS will not reach the point of driving change towards SAFs very soon. Still, only three years ago, we were at an ETS price of less than €10/t. The higher the ETS price gets, the more acceptable solutions like SAFs become for hard-to-abate sectors.

Is there impact from inclusion of maritime shipping under the ETS?

The expansion of the ETS to cover maritime shipping will quite substantially increase the biofuels market. The maritime industry has not achieved significant decarbonisation. Placing shipping under a carbon price is a starting point and sends a very clear signal to biofuel producers that they need to be ready at scale with solutions. Maritime is likely to be a net purchaser of allowances. So firms will be shown quite quickly that the carbon price signal is strong enough to incentivise low-carbon solutions like biofuels.

By Dafydd ab Iago

Adam Berman will be one of the speakers at the forthcoming Argus Biofuels Europe and Asia Markets virtual conference, which takes place 9-11 November. For details of the conference programme and how to register to attend, please visit our website.

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

20/06/25

Brazil's carbon market rulemaking could pick up

Sao Paulo, 20 June (Argus) — Regulations required to put Brazil's regulated carbon emissions market into force have advanced slowly since congress passed legislation in late 2024, but this year may speed several key pieces. The government plans to gradually implement the market by 2030, even as it prepares to host the Cop 30 climate summit in Belem, Para state in the heart of the Brazilian Amazon in November. So far this year, the working group responsible for issuing the regulations that will govern the new market has met 20 times. Participants in the working group include representatives from 10 government ministries, but the finance ministry is spearheading regulations. A first round should be ready by July, the ministry said this week. The working group could define several elements in coming weeks, including clarity regarding the creation of the new agency that will oversee this market. The law stipulates that this new entity have its own technical staff and be independent from the government. "We urgently need to know who is going to be in charge of this market," Guilherme Lefevre, the director of the Getulio Vargas Foundation's sustainability center said, adding that the market needs to have a strong regulator to have credibility. For the market to move forward, Brazil also needs to create a national system for monitoring, reporting, and verification of greenhouse gas emissions. "Brazil still does not have this system, which is fundamental for the development of the regulated carbon market," Lefevre said. This system will underpin the national emissions allocation plan, which will grant companies emission quotas, which can be traded. The law requires companies that emit over 10,000 metric tonnes (t) of CO2 equivalent (tCO2e/yr) to report their emissions and companies with over 25,0000 tCO2e/yr in emissions to participate in the cap-and-trade system that will go into effect when the new carbon market begins operating completely in 2030. "So far, roughly 600 companies have reported their emissions and a total of around 5,000 companies will need to do so to comply with the market requirements," Laura Albuquerque, chief climate officer at Future Climate consultancy said. She added that that while companies in some sectors, such as steel and pulp and paper are already more prepared for the market, others are behind and are working to understand the extent to which the new market represents a risk or an opportunity. The government is also in a race against time to show progress towards creating the new market ahead of the November Cop 30 meeting, when it plans to launch an initiative that will integrate the Brazilian carbon market with markets in the EU, China and California. The goal is to use this coalition of carbons markets as a test case for a future, global carbon market. Not a silver bullet While the creation of a regulated carbon market is an important element of Brazil's decarbonization efforts, it is only part of the plan to meet its emissions-reduction targets. Compared with other countries, industry represents a small share of total emissions. In 2023 — the most recent year with available data — non-agricultural industry only accounted for just 4pc of Brazil's total emissions. Still, because the law permits companies on the regulated market to purchase a share of their credits from the voluntary market, tropical forest protection and restoration projects will also benefit. With Cop 30 leadership pushing for the next gathering to put into effect what has been agreed at previous summits, Brazil will likely feel pressure to advance more quickly on his own initiatives. Brazil's CO2 equivalent emissions by sector, 2023 mn t Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more

News

Pakistan loses EU GSP+ ethanol status

20/06/25

News

20/06/25

Pakistan loses EU GSP+ ethanol status

London, 20 June (Argus) — The European Commission today suspended Pakistan's Generalised Scheme of Preferences Plus (GSP+) status for imports of ethanol. The removal is effective from today, 20 June. A request was lodged in May last year by France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Hungary and Poland, who sought to activate Article 30 of the GSP Regulation, arguing that ethanol coming from Pakistan since 2022 has "caused a serious disturbance to the Union ethanol market". Under Article 30, the commission can "adopt an implementing act in order to suspend the preferential arrangement in respect of the products concerned". Pakistan was granted GSP+ status in 2014, and this expired at the end of 2023. The status was temporarily extended until 2027. The GSP+ grants reduced-tariff or tariff-free access to the EU for vulnerable low- and lower- to middle-income countries that, according to the EU, "implement 27 international conventions related to human rights, labour rights, protection of the environment and good governance". It fully removes custom duties on two-thirds of the bloc's tariff lines in Pakistan's case, including ethanol. Pakistan is a major supplier of industrial-grade ethanol to Europe, but it does not export fuel-grade ethanol. According to market participants, this is because production facilities in the country lack sustainability certifications such as the International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC) that are required for biofuels to qualify under the EU Renewable Energy Directive (RED) targets. Fuel-grade ethanol was not included in the bloc's measures. Several Pakistani market participants were hopeful the GSP+ status will remain in place, which has continued to support ethanol exports from the country to the EU ( see table ). But uncertainty has weighed on demand from Europe recently, suppliers said. A participant told Argus that Pakistani sellers may look to offer more into Africa to soften the drop in demand. Some European suppliers anticipated this outcome, and have already stopped importing from Pakistan. European renewable ethanol association ePure expressed concern about the decision to exclude fuel ethanol from the scope of the measures, noting this could open the door to unintended loopholes and weaken the overall effect of the safeguard efforts. By Evelina Lungu and Deborah Sun European ethanol imports from Pakistan Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Cop 28 outcome must be implemented in full: Cop 30 head

20/06/25

News

20/06/25

Cop 28 outcome must be implemented in full: Cop 30 head

London, 20 June (Argus) — The incoming UN Cop 30 summit president Andre Correa do Lago has set out his objectives for the conference in November, placing as a key priority the Cop 28 outcome of trebling renewables capacity and transitioning away from fossil fuels. Correa do Lago today said his plan is to drive "collective action" to tackle climate change, placing a strong emphasis on the global stocktake, the first of which was concluded at Cop 28 in 2023 . That outcome saw almost 200 countries commit to "transition away" from fossil fuels, as well as treble renewables capacity by 2030. The global stocktake, a five-yearly process, sets out progress made towards Paris climate agreement goals. Today's "Action Agenda must drive momentum towards the full implementation of the GST [global stocktake]", Correa do Lago said. The incoming Cop president is focusing on implementing agreements made at previous Cops, and ensuring that countries and all other stakeholders — such as sub-nationals and the private sector — work together to put the decisions into action. Correa do Lago's letter today repeated language from the Cop 28 outcome, and noted his other main themes for Cop 30, which will take place in Belem, in Brazil's Para state, on 10-21 November. As well as shifting energy, industry and transport from fossil fuel-powered to lower- or zero-carbon alternatives, he listed forests, oceans and biodiversity and agriculture and food as key topics. Further topics involved building resilience for cities, infrastructure and water and human and social development. A final priority was enablers and accelerators across the board, including for finance and technology. Correa do Lago said in May that Cop 30 should be a "pivot point" to action on climate change, and "a new era of putting into practice" what has been agreed at previous Cop summits. He has noted a difficult geopolitical situation , which could make talks more challenging. Brazil's Cop 30 presidency is also focused on climate finance at UN climate talks, currently underway in Bonn, Germany. These 'halfway point' discussions serve to cover substantial technical groundwork ahead of political talks at Cop summits each November. Brazil yesterday at Bonn presented a draft of a roadmap to scale up climate finance — from all sources — to $1.3 trillion/year by 2035. The roadmap will not be officially negotiated, although it was a key outcome from Cop 29 in 2024 and is likely to be finalised just ahead of Cop 30 this year. By Georgia Gratton Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Australia’s carbon credit supply remains strong in May

19/06/25

News

19/06/25

Australia’s carbon credit supply remains strong in May

Sydney, 19 June (Argus) — Australian Carbon Credit Unit (ACCU) supply remained strong in May, bringing total issuances over January-May 2025 closer to the combined volume in the first half of 2024, according to data published on 19 June. A total of 2.11mn ACCUs were issued in May, up from 1.99mn in April , register data released by the Clean Energy Regulator (CER) show. This takes total supply over January-May 2025 to 7.15mn, close to the 7.66mn issued in the first six months of 2024. The regulator did not publish monthly data before 2025. Vegetation methods, mainly from human-induced regeneration (HIR) and avoided deforestation (AD) projects, accounted for 1.32mn ACCUs in May, or nearly 63pc of the total. This was up from just 29pc in April, but below shares of around 82-90pc in February and March. Waste methods, mostly from landfill gas projects, made up 670,596 units, or approximately 32pc of the total. Savana burning, agriculture and energy efficiency methods accounted for the remaining issuances in May ( see chart ). The high number of issuances in April was because of a "backlog of crediting applications for waste methods" , which was expected to clear in the second quarter, the CER said last week. A total of 3.04mn ACCUs were issued in the first quarter, and 5mn applications were "on hand" as of 31 March 2025, the regulator said. The CER maintained its supply forecast of 19mn-24mn for 2025. Bioenergy company LMS Energy remained the largest recipient of new ACCUs in May at 329,879 units, followed by environmental market investor GreenCollar's subsidiary Terra Carbon at 315,420 units and waste management firm Veolia at 154,015 units. ACCU spot prices have been stable in June but continued to rise slowly on the month. The Argus ACCU generic no avoided deforestation (No AD) spot price assessments averaged A$35.65/t CO2 equivalent ($23.20/t CO2e) so far in June, up from A$35.35/t CO2e in May and the highest so far in 2025. By Juan Weik ACCU issuance by method type (mn) Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Poland wraps up CBAM changes with European Parliament

18/06/25

News

18/06/25

Poland wraps up CBAM changes with European Parliament

Brussels, 18 June (Argus) — Poland has concluded negotiations on behalf of EU member states with the European Parliament for a revised carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), ahead of handing over the bloc's six-month rotating presidency to Denmark at the end of June. But Warsaw will not lead discussions on the EU's emissions cut target for 2040 and the bloc's updated nationally determined contribution (NDC) to the Paris climate agreement. Leading negotiations for EU states with parliament, Poland's deputy climate minister Krzysztof Bolesta said the revised CBAM would exempt 90pc of originally covered EU companies from reporting obligations, while 99pc of emissions embedded in imported products would remain covered. The agreement on CBAM now has to be formally approved by parliament and EU ministers. Once published in the bloc's official journal, the revised CBAM text will exempt importers that do not exceed a new single mass-based threshold of 50 t/yr of imported goods. Bolesta admitted that progress has been held up on concluding the EU's NDC during Warsaw's presidency of EU ministerial meetings. CBAM was also listed by Bolesta as one of the points for flexibility in discussions on the 2040 climate target, alongside carbon credits under Article 6 of the Paris agreement, additional funding and flexibility between climate sub-targets. At a meeting of environment ministers yesterday, Bolesta indicated that most states still favour the European Commission linking its submission of an EU NDC to the UN — which includes a 2035 emissions cut target — with the bloc's planned 2 July proposal for a 2040 EU climate target. The CBAM yesterday contributed to delays in technical negotiations held in Bonn, Germany, for the UN Cop 30 climate conference in Brazil. The Like-Minded Group of Developing Countries, including countries such as Bolivia, China, Saudi Arabia, Cuba and Vietnam, had urged the need to address concerns "with climate change-related trade-restrictive unilateral measures". Despite "very, very divergent views", EU member states agree that it "is absolutely urgent to come up with an NDC before the end of September", Bolesta said. The Polish presidency of the EU, chairing climate ministers' meetings, has advanced NDC work as much as possible in the absence of the commission's proposal to revise the bloc's climate law. "We really have only a couple of months to come up with something. What lacks in the NDC draft is now the headline target," Bolesta said. Countries have not yet discussed the quality of Article 6 offsets, Bolesta added. "Everyone in the room realises that we need to be very stringent on what kind of offset will be let into the system," he said. EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra is "cautiously optimistic" that a landing ground can be found on the 2040 climate target. He called for more assertive climate diplomacy, as a large part of the problem lies outside Europe. For China, Hoekstra noted unfair trade practices and "serious" concerns about plans to build additional coal-fired plants. "It's a mixed bag. And we invite them to step up their ambition," he said. By Dafydd ab Iago Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more