Italy's coal demand outlook bleak for 2024

Market: Coal
12/02/24

Italian coal-fired generation is likely to remain soft over the coming months, barring a stark reversal in coal-to-gas fuel-switching trends. And coal imports this year are likely to fall sharply from 2023 levels ahead of a swath of coal-fired plant retirements and as utilities struggle with oversupply in the spot market.

Italy's coal-fired generation last year collapsed by 42pc, compared with 2022 (see chart), and generation of 440MW in January was the lowest since April last year, grid operator data show.

Average coal-fired generation from August 2023-January 2024 of 740MW is equivalent to 1.2mn t of NAR 5,800 kcal/kg coal burned at a 40pc-efficient plant, Argus calculations show. This is about 2.8mn t less implied coal burn than in October 2022-January 2023.

Italy's coal imports have also fallen, but to a lesser degree than its generation, leaving the market saturated. Receipts over August 2023-January 2024 declined by 2.3mn t on the year to 1.7mn t, shipping data show.

A major Italian utility in recent weeks has been looking to resell contracted cargoes back into the market, indicating oversupply, trading firms said.

There is little concern about Italy's gas supply situation heading into the end of winter. The country's gas stocks were 61pc full as of 12 February, data from GIE show. This is up from 45pc in February 2022, just before the tumult caused by the Russia-Ukraine war.

The Italian government has announced that, at the advice of system operator Snam, the country will maintain strategic gas stocks at 4.62bn m³ for 2024-25, to ensure sufficient supply in case of a crisis.

This reduces the likelihood of a significant shift in coal-to-gas fuel-switching levels. The decline in Italy's coal-fired generation "is about the order of merit", a European trading source said. "At the moment, gas is cheaper, and coal is more expensive. It comes down to the cost," it said.

Fuel switch, maximisation plan end

Day-ahead clean dark spreads for 44pc-efficient coal-fired units were assessed by Argus at an average of €11.59/MWh last month, well below the €54.42/MWh recorded in January last year. Day-ahead clean spark spreads for 55pc-efficient gas-fired plants held an average advantage of €9.20/MWh to clean dark spreads last month, flipping from a €30.61/MWh disadvantage in January last year. Italian gas-fired generation reached 11.8GW last month, up from 11.2GW in the same month last year.

And based on forward prices, standard-efficiency coal is behind standard-efficiency gas in the Italian merit order for base and peak-load power generation for the balance of 2024.

Another key factor that cut Italian coal burn in the second half of last year was that emergency measures enacted following Russia's invasion of Ukraine came to an end. The Italian government authorised measures to operate six key coal-fired plants at a higher capacity until March 2023, later extended to 30 September 2023. The "maximisation" sought by the plan to prioritise coal and oil-fired plants over gas-fired units during periods of peak heating and cooling demand has ended.

Consumption dictated by phase-out

In the longer term, Italy's coal demand outlook will be dictated by the pace of its phase-out schedule, which is set to ramp up in the next few years.

The Italian government's National Energy Strategy (Sen), adopted at the end of 2017, outlined the country's commitment to phase out coal by 2025. In June last year, environment minister Gilberto Pichetto Fratin said Italy intended to "abandon coal by 2025 or even earlier" and switch to LNG if gas prices hold low.

Italy has 6GW of installed coal-fired power capacity, with state-run utility Enel operating 4.7GW of this. Last year, the operator said it wanted to shut all of its coal-fired plants by 2027.

The Fusina power station, with an installed capacity of 540MW, in December last year was the latest Enel plant to retire. It will be replaced by a new gas-fired plant in August this year. The 2GW Torrevaldaliga Nord is scheduled to retire by 2025, while the closure of the Sulcis plant in Sardinia has been pushed back to 2027 because of delayed interconnections with mainland Italy.

The 640MW Fiume Santo coal-fired power plant, also in Sardinia and operated by EP Produzione, is set to remain operational until 2027 for the same reason. The Fiume Santo unit has been Italy's hardest-running coal-fired facility in the past few months, with generation having averaged 240MW from 1 October-31 January.

Diversifying imports

Since August 2022, when imports of seaborne coal from Russia came under sanctions, Italy has diversified its supply and doubled down on imports from South Africa and Indonesia.

South African coal receipts rose to 1.9mn t last year, up by 32pc from 2022, while Indonesia emerged as a key player, with imports from the country rising to 830,054t in 2023, the highest in five years.

By Ashima Sharma and Timothy Santonastaso

Italy seaborne coal imports mn t

Italian coal-fired generation GW

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

18/06/25

US Fed sees 2 rate cuts in '25, eyes tariffs: Update

Adds Powell comments, economic backdrop. Houston, 18 June (Argus) — US Federal Reserve policymakers kept the target interest rate unchanged today and signaled two quarter-point cuts are still likely this year while downgrading forecasts for the US economy in the face of largely tariff-driven uncertainty. The Fed's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) held the federal funds rate unchanged at 4.25-4.50pc, in the fourth meeting of 2025. This followed rate cuts of 100 basis points over the last three meetings of 2024, which lowered the target rate from more than two-decade highs. In the Fed's first release of updated economic projections since President Donald Trump's 2 April "Liberation Day" announcement of far-ranging tariffs, policymakers continued to pencil in two quarter-point rate cuts for the remainder of the year. "Changes to trade, immigration, fiscal and regulatory policies continue to evolve and their effects on the economy remain uncertain," Fed chair Jerome Powell told reporters after the meeting. "Today, the amount of the tariff effects — the size of the tariff effects, their duration and the time it will take, are all highly uncertain. So that is why we think the appropriate thing to do is to hold where we are as we learn more." Policymakers and Fed officials Wednesday lowered their median estimate for GDP growth this year to 1.4pc from a prior estimate of 1.7pc in the March economic outlook. They see inflation rising to a median 3pc for 2025 from the prior estimate of 2.7pc, with unemployment rising to 4.5pc from 4.4pc in the prior forecast. Economists have warned that Trump's erratic use of tariffs and plans to raise the national debt, along with mounting geopolitical risk highlighted by the latest Israel-Iran clashes, threaten to throw the economy into a recession or marked slowdown. Consumer confidence has tumbled and financial markets have been volatile while the dollar has slumped to three-year lows. Still, the labor market and inflation — the two pillars of the Fed's policy mandate — have remained relatively stable into the fifth month of Trump's administration. "As long as the economy is solid, as long as we're seeing the kind of labor market that we have and reasonably decent growth, and inflation moving down, we feel like the right thing to do is to be where we are, where our policy stance is and learn more," Powell said. US job growth slowed to 139,000 in May, near the average gain of 149,000 over the prior 12 months and unemployment has remained in a range of 4-4.2pc since May 2024. Consumer inflation was at an annual 2.4pc in May, down from 3pc in January. US GDP growth contracted by an annual 0.2pc in the first quarter, largely due to an increase in imports on pre-tariff stockpiling, down from 2.4pc in the fourth quarter and the lowest in three years. "What we're waiting for to reduce rates is to understand what will happen with the tariff inflation," Powell said. "And there's a lot of uncertainty about that. Every forecaster you can name who is a professional is forecasting a meaningful increase in inflation in coming months from tariffs because someone has to pay for the tariffs." Before Wednesday's FOMC announcement, Trump made a rambling attack on the Fed's policy under Powell, in remarks to reporters at the White House. "I call him 'too late Powell', because he's always too late" in lowering rates. "Am I allowed to appoint myself at the Fed? I do a much better job than these people." Powell's term in office as Fed chair expires in May 2026. Powell declined to directly address Trump's comments. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more

News

US Fed keeps rate flat, still eyes 2 cuts in 2025

18/06/25

News

18/06/25

US Fed keeps rate flat, still eyes 2 cuts in 2025

Houston, 18 June (Argus) — US Federal Reserve policymakers kept the target interest rate unchanged today and signaled two quarter-point cuts are still likely this year. The Fed's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) held the federal funds rate unchanged at 4.25-4.50pc, in the fourth meeting of 2025. This followed rate cuts of 100 basis points over the last three meetings of 2024, which lowered the target rate from more than two-decade highs. In the Fed's first release of updated economic projections since President Donald Trump's 2 April "Liberation Day" announcement of far-ranging tariffs, policymakers continued to pencil in two quarter-point rate cuts for the remainder of the year. Policymakers and Fed officials Wednesday lowered their estimate for GDP growth this year to 1.4pc from a prior estimate of 1.7pc in the March economic outlook. They see inflation rising to 3pc for 2025 from the prior estimate of 2.7pc, with unemployment rising to 4.5pc from 4.4pc in the prior forecast. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Banks increased fossil fuel financing in 2024: Report

18/06/25

News

18/06/25

Banks increased fossil fuel financing in 2024: Report

London, 18 June (Argus) — Banks "significantly increased" their fossil fuel financing in 2024, reversing a trend of steadily declining fossil fuel financing since 2021, a report from a group of non-profit organisations found this week. The 65 biggest banks globally committed $869bn in 2024 to "companies conducting business in fossil fuels", the report — Banking on Climate Chaos — found. Those banks committed $429bn last year to companies expanding fossil fuel production and infrastructure. The report assesses lending and underwriting in 2024 from the world's top 65 banks to more than 2,700 fossil fuel companies. Figures are not directly comparable year-on-year, as the previous report, which assessed 2023, covered financing from 60 banks. The 60 biggest banks globally committed $705bn in 2023 to companies with fossil fuel business, last year's report found. Those banks committed $347bn in 2023 to companies with fossil fuel expansion plans. Of the five banks providing the most fossil fuel finance in 2024, four were US banks — JP Morgan Chase, Bank of America, Citigroup and Wells Fargo. The 65 banks assessed in this year's report have committed $7.9 trillion in fossil fuel financing since 2016, when the Paris climate agreement took effect, the report found. Finance is at the core of climate negotiations like UN Cop summits. Developed countries are typically called upon at such events to provide more public climate finance to developing nations, but the focus is also shifting to private finance, as overseas development finance looks set to drop . But fossil fuel financing banks are increasingly facing the risk of targeted and more complex climate-related litigation, according to a recent report by the London School of Economics' centre for economic transition expertise (Cetex). Climate litigation is not currently adequately accounted for in financial risk assessment, with case filing and decisions negatively impacting carbon financiers, it said. "While early climate cases primarily targeted governments and big-emitting ‘carbon majors', cases against other firms have proliferated quickly," Cetex said. The report also showed that, based on a review of disclosures from 20 banks supervised by the European Central Bank, many banks across Europe recognise litigation risks as material in the context of climate and environmental factors but tend to not be specific about the risks incurred. By Georgia Gratton and Caroline Varin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

EPA seeks end to power plant CO2, mercury rules

11/06/25

News

11/06/25

EPA seeks end to power plant CO2, mercury rules

Washington, 11 June (Argus) — The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on Wednesday proposed the repeal of CO2 and mercury emissions standards for power plants, its latest steps in an effort to undo many of the regulations enacted by President Donald Trump's predecessors The agency said the repeals will help bring about an end to the "war on much of our domestic energy supply" waged by previous administrations, while saving consumers money "We have chosen to both protect the environment and grow the economy," EPA administrator Lee Zeldin said. "There was this false binary choice made before we got here." Together, the repeals would save more than $1bn/yr for American families, Zeldin said. The standards, finalized last year by EPA during the administration of former president Joe Biden, cover CO2 emissions from existing and new coal-fired power plants and new natural gas-fired units, as well as mercury emissions from coal- and oil-fired power plants. At the time, EPA said the CO2 rules will lead to a 90pc reduction in emissions from coal-fired power plants, while it tightened the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (MATS) for coal- and oil-fired units by 67pc and included new emissions-monitoring requirements. In addition, the MATS for lignite-fired units were tightened by 70pc to put them in line with the standards for other coal plants. The CO2 rule includes standards for new coal and gas units and guidance for existing coal-fired power plants, the latter of which vary by unit type, size and other factors such as whether a power plant provides baseload or backup power. It does not include standards for existing gas-fired generators, which EPA had proposed in 2023 but last year decided to scrap in favor of a "new, comprehensive approach". While the CO2 regulation would be fully repealed, Zeldin said the agency is proposing to only undo last year's "gratuitous" changes to MATS, such as the new lignite standards. "If finalized no power plant will be allowed to emit more than they do now or as much as they did one or two years ago," he said. In addition to repealing the two Biden regulations, EPA is proposing to undo the Clean Power Plan, developed by the agency during the administration of former president Barack Obama. It would do this in part by reversing a previous agency determination that it could regulate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from power plants, and by also finding that those emissions "do not contribute significantly to dangerous air pollution." The Clean Power Plan has never been enforced, and the US Supreme Court in 2022 ruled the agency lacked the authority to regulate CO2 emissions from power plants in the way envisioned by that approach. Unlike during Trump's first term, when EPA first sought to repeal the Clean Power Plan, the agency this time around is not proposing any replacement. The previous replacement rule was struck down by the US District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals in 2021. The lack of a new rule could make EPA more vulnerable to legal challenges, which are all but certain to be filed by environmental groups and some states. "This administration is transparently trading American lives for campaign dollars and the support of fossil fuel companies, and Americans ought to be disgusted and outraged that their government has launched an assault on our health and our future," Sierra Club climate policy director Patrick Drupp said. Zeldin said he was not concerned about any potential litigation. "I would say with great enthusiasm and excitement for the future, I know we are absolutely going down the right path," he said. Coal and electric sector groups cheered EPA's proposal. "Today's announcement nullifies two of EPA's most consequential air rules, removing deliberately unattainable standards and leveling the playing field for reliable power sources, instead of stacking the deck against them," National Mining Association president Rich Nolan said. EPA in March included the CO2 and mercury rules among 31 Obama and Biden-era regulations and actions it planned to review and potentially repeal. Since then, the White House has identified more than 60 fossil fuel-fired power plants that will have two extra years to comply with the more-stringent MATS, giving them a reprieve while EPA works to formally repeal the regulations. The March announcement also included a reconsideration of the 2009 endangerment finding for GHG emissions, which underpins all of the major climate regulations EPA issued in recent years. "I don't have anything to announce today as it relates to any proposed rulemaking that may be to come on that topic," Zeldin said. EPA will open a 45-day public comment period on each proposed repeal once they are published in the Federal Register . By Michael Ball Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Vietnam's coal imports hit 23-month high in May

11/06/25

News

11/06/25

Vietnam's coal imports hit 23-month high in May

Singapore, 11 June (Argus) — Vietnam's coal imports in May rose on the year to the highest level in 23 months, supported by restocking by utilities to cater for an increase in power demand in northern parts of the country. Seaborne receipts reached 7.2mn t in May, up from about 6.5mn t a year earlier and 7.16mn t in April , according to customs data. This marks the highest level since the 7.21mn t of coal imported in June 2023. Imports reached 31.64mn t in January-May, up from 27.06mn t a year earlier, Vietnamese customs data show. The data do not differentiate between coking and thermal coal. Receipts rose in May on restocking by utilities and steady industrial coal consumption in line with the economic activity in the country. The country's industrial output grew by 9.4pc in May from a year earlier, according to Vietnam's General Statistics Office (GSO), supporting its economic growth outlook. The utility restocking comes as hot weather peaks in June in northern Vietnam, which could buoy power demand and prompt utilities to boost coal-fired generation. This could support imports as power plants could continue to restock imported cargoes given that seaborne prices are at multi-year lows. Argus assessed the GAR 4,200 kcal/kg coal market for geared Supramaxes at $42.41/t fob Kalimantan on 6 June, the lowest since 26 March, 2021, when it was marked at $39.37/t. The country's overall generation last month stood at 28.62TWh , edging higher from 28.09TWh a year earlier, and 26.85TWh in April, data from state-owned utility EVN show. Coal-fired power accounted for the bulk of the generation last month at 15.8TWh, although this was down from 17.08TWh a year earlier and 16.09TWh in April. Hydropower output rose to 7.65TWh, up by 64pc from a year earlier, and also rising from an estimated 4.7TWh in April. EVN has asked all its units and plants to ensure stable supply of electricity, it said, and it will also ask local authorities to implement measures to save electricity to help manage loads on the grid. Indonesian coal accounted for the bulk of Vietnam's imports at 2.9mn t in in May, little changed from a year earlier and from April, the customs data show. Imports from Australia rose to 2.38mn t in May, up from 1.18mn t a year earlier, and from 2.23mn t in April. By Saurabh Chaturvedi Vietnam coal imports mn t Vietnam coal import trend mn t Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more