Lower ship scrubber uptake may encourage coking

  • Market: Petroleum coke
  • 23/10/19

The shipping industry appears much less likely to install scrubbers to comply with new marine fuel rules than analysts once anticipated, suggesting that a glut of high-sulphur fuel oil (HSFO) could keep coking margins higher for longer than expected.

This surplus HSFO could ultimately lead to more cokers being built in the coming years, producing as much as 30pc more seaborne petroleum coke in the long term, said Ben Ziesmer, carbon group manager for consulting firm Advisian at the Cemprospects 2019 conference in Krakow, Poland, this month.

"The refining industry was assuming a very high adoption of scrubbing by the shipping industry," Ziesmer said. "My opinion is a lot of refiners will find their strategy was not solid and there will be a move to start building more cokers."

Many in the industry are sceptical that there will be that much investment in units that cost hundreds of millions of dollars and take several years to complete. But it does not appear that a large-scale move to install scrubbers in order to comply with new International Maritime Organization (IMO) regulations will materialise.

Less than 20pc of the global shipping fleet is likely to install scrubbers by next year, Gibson Shipbrokers dry cargo analyst Joy Scurr said at the conference. Only around 5pc of supramax and handymax dry bulk carriers that typically carry petroleum coke will end up installing scrubbers, Scurr said.

Most analysts had expected that shipowners would eventually turn to scrubbers once the rules cause less than 0.5pc sulphur compliant fuels to be very expensive while traditional 3.5pc sulphur fuel oil will be available cheaply. But a number of other factors have put this outlook into question.

Rather than a glut of HSFO available at very low prices, the fuel has already become scarce at times, and there could even be a shortage next year. Because of the relatively low number of scrubber-fitted vessels, there is less incentive for ports to stock this fuel.

Scrubber install challenges

There is also a short-term obstacle to installing scrubbers in that it means taking a vessel out of service at a time when freight rates are relatively strong. Shipyards have become increasingly congested with demand for scrubber installations, which has led to a 33pc increase in the length of time ships need to remain out of service to complete the work, according to shipping firm Clarksons.

Another more serious obstacle to scrubber installation is the difficulty of securing financing, particularly for the more common open-loop type, Scurr said. Shipowners have already found procuring loans from large banks increasingly difficult because of stringent loan requirements. Open-loop scrubbers discharge their effluent directly into the ocean, a design that has already lead a number of important destinations, including China, Singapore, Fujairah and the Panama Canal, to block their use.

"I do think there will be an environment two or three years down the line when discharging scrubber effluent in nearby coastal waters will be regarded as an environmental crime," Scurr said.

Another serious risk shipowners must consider is potential damage to their vessels. Norwegian marine insurer Gard recently said that vessels have had fires during scrubber retrofitting or have had accelerated corrosion within 10 to 15 months of scrubbers being installed.

Because of the lower likelihood of the vessel fleet moving en masse to scrubbers, analysts like Ziesmer and Scurr are sceptical of the idea that the spread between 0.5-3.5pc sulphur fuel oil will sharply narrow as many refiners have feared.

"Gibson thinks it is highly unlikely that the 0.5-3.5pc fuel oil spread will move to $50," Scurr said. "We expect it will remain more like $100-$250."

Differing coke supply outlooks

Ziesmer estimates that seaborne coke volumes could increase by 10pc in the near term because of the increase in high-sulphur vacuum tower bottoms moving to existing cokers. But the 150mn t/yr of vacuum tower bottoms he estimates will be displaced could theoretically produce 45mn t/yr of coke, or about 80pc of the current seaborne market. He acknowledges such a huge increase is probably not likely, but "when coking economics blow out, and I believe they will become very very favourable, some people are going to decide to build cokers," he said.

But many refiners are not convinced that coke supply will increase so dramatically. The world's crude slate has been getting lighter overall, some note, meaning there are fewer bottoms to be processed. Heavier crudes are in shorter supply for political reasons, including US sanctions on Venezuelan and Iranian crude.

And changing logistics are making it easier for US Gulf refiners to access light US domestic crudes, including the startup of Phillips 66's Gray Oak pipeline moving shale crude from the Permian basin in west Texas to the US Gulf coast. With more light crudes available, refiners may be able to simply produce less HSFO rather than building new units to process it.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
26/03/24

Baltimore bridge collapse forces freight changes

Baltimore bridge collapse forces freight changes

Washington, 26 March (Argus) — Vessel traffic in and out of the Port of Baltimore, Maryland, has been suspended indefinitely in the wake of a container ship collision early today that brought down the Francis Scott Key Bridge, an accident that will force the rerouting of coal, car and light truck shipments. The prolonged closure of one of the largest ports on the US east coast could have a ripple effect on trade flows across much of the US, as shippers grapple for alternatives in the absence of a certain reopening timeline. Search and rescue efforts are still ongoing in the Patapsco River, after the 116,851dwt Dali headed to Colombo, Sri Lanka, slammed into a bridge support. The crew had lost control of the vessel. The Dali is owned by Grace Ocean and managed by Synergy Marine Group. The Maryland Port Administration said it does not know how long it will take for the shipping channel to be cleared and for traffic to resume. Shipping companies are bracing for a closure of at least two weeks, but many expect the clean-up effort could take significantly longer. President Joe Biden vowed the federal government will provide whatever resources are needed to get the port "up and running again as soon as possible." The port is a major trade hub for steam and coking coal, automobiles and scrap metal. Many market sources are still trying to determine whether the disruption will be dramatic enough to move prices. But coal markets were already being affected today. Baltimore is home to two key coal export terminals: eastern US railroad CSX's Curtis Bay Coal Piers and coal producer Consol Energy's Consol Marine Terminal. The facilities are upstream of the bridge, meaning ships will not be able to serve them until the route reopens. The terminals handle thermal and coking coal from Northern and Central Appalachia. They have a combined export capacity of 34mn short tons (30.8mn metric tonnes). The two terminals loaded 2.4mn t of coal in February, up from 2.1mn t a year earlier, according to analytics firm Kpler, mostly exports to India and China. An India-based trader said that the suspension of coal exports will probably raise prices in India, as brick kilns enter the peak production season in the summer. Buyers could look to petroleum coke as a substitute, but the higher sulphur content may not be appealing to some users despite the higher calorific value. Prices for deliveries to northern Europe are also likely to rise given that the Netherlands, Germany and Belgium combined are the second-largest market for North Appalachian coal. April API 2 futures rose by $2/t to $113.30/t. The incident has added a "level of volatility [which] could have big implications," a European paper broker said. The lack of information has prompted some coal producers to hold off on activating force majeure clauses in their contracts. Curtis Bay is served only by CSX, while CSX and fellow eastern carrier Norfolk Southern serve Consol. CSX said it is in contact with existing coal customers and contingency plans are being implemented. The railroad at this point intends to keep Curtis Bay open but will continue to assess the circumstances moving forward. Norfolk Southern did not respond to questions. Some scheduled Baltimore coal exports may be redirected to the other three eastern US coal export terminals in Hampton Roads, Virginia, but such reroutings likely will entail increased costs. Not all coal mines will be able to shift terminals. Such decisions will depend on available capacity in Hampton Roads. Exports from the three terminals in January reached a five-year high , signaling somewhat limited capacity. Mine location and railroad access may also determine whether coal can be rerouted, an industry source said. But some producers do not have much of a choice about trying to send coal to Hampton Roads. They may need the cash so will be forced into a decision. The producers most vulnerable to delays may be Consol and Arch Resources. Arch's Leer coking coal mine may be in the best position because it co-owns Dominion Terminal Associates in Hampton Roads with Alpha Metallurgical Coal Resources. The sudden lack of export capacity could put a floor under US coal prices, which have mostly been falling since last year amid low domestic demand. The competition to replace Baltimore coal exports could prevent further cuts, another coal trading source said. Metals sources say the accident will have only isolated effects on the global ferrous scrap market, but many market participants are still assessing the situation. The port is the 10th largest ferrous scrap export port in the US, and over the last five years an average of 44,000 metric tonnes/month of ferrous scrap was exported from Baltimore, according to US Department of Commerce data. But the port closure is likely to affect other freight. Baltimore is the nation's top handler of automobile traffic. Motor vehicles and parts accounted for about 42pc of all Baltimore port imports and 27pc of all exports, according to state data. The Port of Baltimore handled 847,158 cars and light trucks in 2023. "It's too early to say what impact this incident will have on the auto business — but there will certainly be a disruption," said John Bozzella, chief executive of industry trade group Alliance for Automotive Innovation. Dry bulk freight rates likely unaffected Several sources told Argus Baltimore's closure is unlikely to have a major impact on dry freight rates despite short-term interruptions to coal transports. "We are in the shoulder months with less demand for thermal coal," a shipbroker said, suggesting mild global temperatures means the collapse "may not have too much of an impact" on freight markets overall. Vessel traffic in ports such as Charleston, South Carolina, and Savannah, Georgia, may increase on diversions from Baltimore. Kpler identified 17 vessels that will likely be impacted because they are either in the Port of Baltimore or were expected to load there in the coming days. By Abby Caplan, Gabriel Squitieri, Luis Gronda, Evan Millard and Brad MacAulay Port of Baltimore coal terminals Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

Final locks to open on upper Mississippi River


13/03/24
News
13/03/24

Final locks to open on upper Mississippi River

Houston, 13 March (Argus) — Locks 3 and 7 on the upper Mississippi River will open at midnight on 15 March after being closed for repairs, allowing access to St Paul, Minnesota, for barge carriers, according to the US Army Corps of Engineers. Barges are already heading toward the locks carrying plenty of commodities, to the northern Plains for distribution. Locks 7 and 3 are located at miles 703 and 796 of the upper Mississippi River, respectively. The Corps anticipates barges passing through the locks starting over the weekend. Navigation repairs for the locks have been finished as well, the Corps said. Maintenance for the locks determined the opening date this year, as the Lake Pepin ice measurements that typically establish the date were cancelled due to unseasonably warm weather. A barge carrier mentioned some of their barges may arrive in time to cross at midnight. By Meghan Yoyotte Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Cement maker Intercement in talks to sell assets


06/03/24
News
06/03/24

Cement maker Intercement in talks to sell assets

London, 6 March (Argus) — Brazilian cement maker Intercement is in talks with Votorantim, Brazil's largest cement maker, along with other potential buyers, to sell some of its assets to help pay down debt. Votorantim, which boasts a cement production capacity of 31.8mn t/yr, confirmed on 22 February that it has submitted an offer to acquire a portion of Intercement's assets. Such a deal would have to be approved by Brazilian antitrust authority CADE. The next day, Intercement said that over the last few months it has received "a series of inquiries and expressions of interest in its assets." Intercement is evaluating "strategic alternatives, such as private placement, merger, or partnership with a strategic player or even a potential divestment." Company officials said those talks are in an "embryonic stage." In June 2023, Intercement reached an agreement with China's Huaxin to purchase the company's assets in Mozambique and South Africa. Intercement sold its business in Egypt to an undisclosed buyer in January 2023. Intercement owns 23 cement plants, 15 concrete plants and two aggregates plants in Brazil and Argentina. Lower cement demand, stronger competition and higher costs of raw materials have pressured the company's earnings in recent quarters. In its third-quarter earnings report, the company cited increases in petroleum coke prices in 2022 as a particular drain on its operational margins and cash flow. The company had $1.5bn in debt as of 30 September 2023, according to a company financial statement. By Alexander Makhlay Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

ExxonMobil Baton Rouge coke quality shifts


26/02/24
News
26/02/24

ExxonMobil Baton Rouge coke quality shifts

Houston, 26 February (Argus) — ExxonMobil's 522,500 b/d Baton Rouge, Louisiana, refinery has begun producing petroleum coke with a higher shot content because of a project to expand the range of crudes processed at the facility, curbing demand from some anode-grade coke market participants in China. Buyers in China have in recent years taken most of the fuel-grade coke produced by two of the refinery's cokers as it had a high HGI and low shot content, making it applicable for use in calcining blends. But upgrades at the plant to allow for a wider crude diet have lowered Baton Rouge fuel-grade coke's HGI and increased its shot content, with coke produced in December and January ranging from 81-93pc shot and 64-84 HGI, according to quality analysis reports. Quality analysis reports in 2021 and in early 2022 showed the coke had a shot content of 0pc, with HGI ranging from 100-128 and 85-96, respectively. While the refinery's fuel-grade cokers have produced various amounts of shot coke in 2023 and in previous years, shot content became elevated on a regular basis in November, an independent coke market analyst said. High shot content coke production at Baton Rouge looks to be continuing through the first quarter, the analyst said, "but the situation can change quickly." ExxonMobil on 22 February closed the bidding period for a Baton Rouge term tender offering coke with 4.8-5.3pc sulphur on a dry basis and a variable shot content of up to 100pc for loading in 35,000-70,000t cargoes from April-December. The refiner also accepted bids for shot-free cargoes, although it postponed contracting deals for them because "the time required to build a segregated shot-free pile is uncertain," the tender document said. Market participants expect that most of the coke Baton Rouge's fuel-grade cokers produce will go to cement makers this year, perhaps in South America or Turkey, while exports to China — where volumes were often used in anode-grade coke blends — will decrease. One trader that typically purchases at least one term Baton Rouge cargo each year said it did not submit a bid, as it saw lower interest from its Chinese customers now that the refinery is not currently selling coke suitable for calcining blends. Its Chinese customers are also focusing on spot rather than term volumes as China's imported coke stockpiles reached record levels on record high imports in 2023 . But some anode-grade coke market participants will continue to receive material from another of the refinery's coking units, which produces anode-grade coke. Term coke from this unit was tendered around October and was of a similar quality to the year prior, market participants said. By Delaney Ramirez Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Ven sanctions unlikely to shift US coke quality


07/02/24
News
07/02/24

Ven sanctions unlikely to shift US coke quality

Houston, 7 February (Argus) — A potential re-imposition of US sanctions on Venezuelan oil is unlikely to have much impact on US Gulf coast petroleum coke quality, as the loosening of sanctions since late 2022 has failed to result in significant changes to mid-sulphur coke availability. Uncertainty has arisen in recent weeks about whether the US will restore sanctions on Venezuelan state-owned oil company PdV, which has affected demand for the country's petroleum coke . But this would not necessarily affect Chevron's ability to import Venezuelan crude into the US, which the US Treasury Department has allowed since late 2022 , separate from its decision to temporarily lift the sanctions against Venezuelan oil products in general in October 2023 . The easing of sanctions has seen the crude more regularly supply US Gulf coking refineries over the past year, but the overall impact on coke quality has not been notable, suggesting that even a substantial shift in US policy against the Latin American country would not significantly change US mid-sulphur coke availability. The sulphur content of Venezuelan sour crude does not concentrate in coke as much as many other crude grades, which has allowed some refineries to experience occasional changes in their coke's sulphur content from processing Venezuelan crude. Sanctions were seen as a major impediment to mid-sulphur coke availability when they were first issued in 2019 . Although one or two US refineries have been able to increase sales of some higher-quality petroleum coke as a result of imports of Venezuelan crude in the past year, most have not used it as a significant proportion of their feedstock. Chevron imported 46,700 b/d of Venezuelan crude to its 356,000 b/d Pascagoula, Mississippi, refinery, according to US Energy Information Administration (EIA) monthly data spanning January-November 2023. A coke cargo loading from the refinery in the fourth quarter was reported to be just under 6pc sulphur, according to a market participant. And Phillips 66 imported a total of about 2.4mn bl — or less than 10,000 b/d — of Venezuelan crude to its 265,000 b/d Sweeny refinery in Old Ocean, Texas, once a heavy consumer of Venezuelan crude and mid-sulphur coke producer. The refinery has been able to segregate the mid-sulphur-quality coke from higher-sulphur production and market it separately. Of this refinery's projected annual production capacity, approximately 14pc is expected to be mid-sulphur quality, according to a market participant. But the lower-sulphur quality is not consistently produced, occurring in batches, as the refiner imported the Venezuelan crude sporadically. But other US refiners like Marathon Petroleum, PBF Energy, and ExxonMobil have not imported Venezuelan crude frequently enough to have an impact on coke sulphur content. Valero was a relatively frequent importer, taking 50,900 b/d of Venezuelan crude from January-November. But it divided the volumes between its 335,000 b/d Port Arthur, Texas; 215,000 b/d St Charles in Norco, Louisiana; and 290,000 b/d Corpus Christi, Texas, refineries, diminishing the crude's impact on coke sulphur content. The impact of Venezuelan crude imports on US coke quality in the past year has also been limited as a result of the crude being largely absorbed by China. In 2023, China was the top importer of Venezuelan crude, imported approximately 390,800 b/d, compared with the 128,900 b/d imported to the US Gulf Coast, according to preliminary data from Vortexa. By Mykah Briscoe and Delaney Ramirez US Gulf refinery 2023 Venezuelan crude imports b/d Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more