Latest market news

EU green hydrogen uncompetitive into 2030s: Aurora

  • Market: Biofuels, Electricity
  • 26/01/21

Consultancy Aurora Energy Research expects blue hydrogen and imported green hydrogen to be cheaper than domestically produced green hydrogen in Europe in the medium term, according to a report released today.

European hydrogen demand could increase eight-fold by 2050, as countries work toward net zero, Aurora said. Hydrogen consumption rises to 2,500TWh by 2050 in a high-use scenario, where heating switches to hydrogen. By comparison, the European power system is currently around 3,000-3,3200TWh, Aurora said.

The cheapest source of low-carbon hydrogen by 2030 would be blue hydrogen produced in the Netherlands or Norway, followed by imported green hydrogen from Morocco. Aurora defines blue hydrogen as made from natural gas but combined with carbon capture and storage, and green hydrogen as made from water and electricity using electrolysis.

Green hydrogen from Morocco will be cheaper because power prices are much lower. A large rollout of solar is depressing power prices in Morocco, although it is still building coal-fired capacity. As a result, such green hydrogen may be more carbon intensive than blue hydrogen. This problem will also exist in European countries slow to decarbonise, for example in Germany, which still has a high share of coal and lignite in its power generation mix, Aurora said.

Aurora sees levelised costs of green hydrogen at €91-121/MWh for electrolyser plants built in 2025.

The lower end comes from flexible projects that can optimise production according to power prices. The optimal load factor for such projects would be around 50pc. If the load factor gets too high, it would be running during times of higher power prices, while if it falls too low, the capex costs per MWh produced would rise, Aurora said.

In Britain and Spain, hydrogen from flexible electrolysers will be cheaper than blue hydrogen by the late 2030s. It becomes cheaper in France by the early 2040s, and in Germany by the mid 2040s, Aurora's modelling shows.

Electrolysers co-located with renewable capacity will have higher costs than flexible or inflexible assets using power from the grid. This is primarily because low load factors increase capex — an electrolyser co-located with solar in Spain would have a load factor of just 22pc. Such a plant would still be cheaper than an inflexible asset using grid power in Spain in the 2030s, but will always remain more expensive than a flexible asset, the report said.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
18/09/24

EU needs future power grids task force: Ember

EU needs future power grids task force: Ember

London, 18 September (Argus) — The EU must put in place a future grid task force to bring together scattered legislation and directives, so the bloc can better implement its power grid roadmap and integrate renewable capacity, according to UK-based think-tank Ember. Integrating intermittent renewables into the power grid adequately will require substantial upgrades to the power network across the continent. This is a political priority for the EU but responsibility is shared across a number of European governmental bodies, Ember said. Most of the 80 action points laid out in EU policy and legislation are the European Commission's responsibility, but some objectives are overseen by EU distribution system body DSO Entity, European grid operators association Entso-E, energy regulators' agency Acer, the EU's High-Level Forum on European Standardisation, and individual member states. The policy framework is a "positive step", Ember said. But significant grid work and modernisation are needed, which would be best met through a single body that can ensure "timely and effective" delivery, according to Ember. A dedicated task force would centralise policy support and monitoring through a single channel, provide access to financing from the European Investment Bank and European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, and develop a clear roadmap for all actions that are currently in the commission's remit. The need for a roadmap is significant as several of the commission's targets do not have scheduled completion dates, Ember said. The EU must centralise funding access for member states and grid operators to ensure stakeholders can use as much of the funding available to them as possible, according to Ember. Funding is currently underutilised and spread across several financial instruments. In addition to uniting these instruments, the access mechanisms should be streamlined and administrative burdens reduced so that stakeholders of varying sizes can utilise these funds. The EU should provide targeted funding for pilot projects on grid digitalisation, and then create a "technical toolbox" to support the digitalisation of distribution grids. The toolbox would detail best practice approaches, standardisation guidelines and interoperability technologies to ease digitalising the power network. These innovative grid technologies (IGTs) or grid-enhancing technologies (GETs) use existing infrastructure to improve renewable integration while reducing overall investment needs. IGT and GET technologies could improve renewable integration with costly network upgrades by as much as 40pc, according to a study by Latvian grid operator AST. By Daniel Craig Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more
News

Indonesian Sumsel 1 coal-fired unit eyes December start


18/09/24
News
18/09/24

Indonesian Sumsel 1 coal-fired unit eyes December start

Manila, 18 September (Argus) — The first 300MW unit of the 600MW Sumsel 1 mine-mouth coal-fired power plant in Indonesia's south Sumatra province is scheduled to begin commercial operations in December following several years of delays. The plant, which is located in Muara Enim regency, is being developed by China Shenhua Energy and Lion Power Energy, which have 75pc and 25pc respective stakes in the project. Once fully operational it is expected to consume around 2-3mn t/yr of coal. Lion will be responsible for sourcing the coal. The $750mn plant is part of Indonesia's 35GW power generation roadmap developed by the Indonesian government in 2015. The project was contracted to China Shenhua Energy in 2016. The first unit at the plant was originally scheduled for completion by 2020. But land acquisition delays and the Covid-19 pandemic and resulting restrictions on the movement of people and travel bans delayed construction, Lion said. Construction work on the plant structure is now in the final stages and operational testing is expected to begin soon. But hitting the operational target date also depends on the completion of a 275kV high-voltage line that will connect the plant to the grid, state-owned utility PLN said. The 80km transmission line will pass through four districts in south Sumatra. The local government is pushing for the acceleration of the voltage line construction and has instructed the sub-district head and local government offices to provide support for the power line construction, PLN said. Sumsel 1, once fully operational, will operate on a build-own-operate basis with a 25-year power supply contract with PLN, the utility said. By Antonio delos Reyes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

EPA already at work on 2026-forward RFS rules


17/09/24
News
17/09/24

EPA already at work on 2026-forward RFS rules

Monterey, 17 September (Argus) — The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has started work on the second set of rules for the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), expected to span multiple years beginning in 2026, a spokesperson said today. The rule will likely establish renewable volume targets for multiple years under the RFS, although the exact timeframe has not been confirmed, EPA deputy office director Ben Hengst said today at the Argus North American Biofuels, LCFS and Carbon Summit in Monterey, California. Work on the incoming rule was originally not expected to begin until early 2025. Updated analysis, especially regarding advanced biofuels and feedstocks, will inform new rulemaking, as well as the inclusion of regulatory changes intended to improve the program's implementation, Hengst said. Unprecedented growth in US biofuels imports led overall advanced biofuel supply in 2023 to far surpass EPA projections. But biomass-based diesel volumes for the current rules were based on projected growth in North American feedstock supply — not international availability nor the nameplate capacities of US refineries, Hengst said. There were also large increases in imported feedstocks for biofuel production, namely in used cooking oil and tallow. But the potential for an upset in global trade flows remains an agency concern. Domestic policy in some countries could boost offshore consumption of feedstocks and finished fuels that have arrived to the US market in recent years, while the US policy environment itself remains vulnerable to change. The EPA is also navigating recent adverse judgments against its interpretation of the Small Refinery Exemption program and is prioritizing the development of options that would comply with court orders. There was no clarity provided on eRINs as the EPA continues to consider its options. By Jasmine Davis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US regulatory clarity vital to sustain biofuels growth


17/09/24
News
17/09/24

US regulatory clarity vital to sustain biofuels growth

Monterey, 17 September (Argus) — Clarity from both US state and federal regulators regarding the rules and incentives for biofuels production is essential to ensure continued growth to achieve underlying carbon-reduction targets, industry stakeholders said today. A lack of guidance for incentive programs and qualifications for 2025 and beyond is already hindering trade and investment in key US biofuels markets, panelists said today at the Argus North American Biofuels, LCFS and Carbon Summit in Monterey, California. The current biodiesel tax credit (BTC) is scheduled to give way to the Inflation Reduction Act's Clean Fuels Production Credit (CFPC) in January, while narrowed proposed targets and credit qualifications in state Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) programs has effectively left key portions of the biofuels market in a holding pattern. Alignment and certainty between regulatory bodies on what will be incentivized and credited in the future will be an essential component of business and investment decisions in the industry, necessary to reach ambitious carbon-reduction targets within the next decade. "The fact that we don't have clarity mid-September for a tax credit going into effect on 1 January, is really hard to believe," said Kurt Kovarik, vice president of federal affairs for Clean Fuels Alliance America. "No one knows the rules of the road with respect to 45Z." Panelists echoed opposition to proposed California caps on crop-based renewable feedstocks that discussed on Monday at the conference during sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) discussions. "If the goal is to remove carbon, the extent to which we can base it on science and not pick winners and losers is in everyone's interests," Kovarik said. "All you're going to end up doing is limiting the driving out of carbon." But speakers today further warned of the potential for a duplication of efforts by parties trying to satisfy both state LCFS programs and the federal Renewable Fuel Standard program. Proposed requirements may also require an unprecedented level of collaboration between segments of the US renewables supply chain. Those requirements could be more disruptive than the feedstock cap itself and potentially have the greatest limiting effect on fuel supply into California, said Don Gilstrap, Chevron's manager of fuels regulations. With that goal in mind, declining carbon intensity targets are already providing the necessary incentive for producers to pivot away from crop-based renewable feedstocks, Gilstrap said. But panelists were optimistic about rising interest in replicating LCFS-style focuses on carbon intensity — an approach they theorized would "unleash innovation" across both the finished fuels and feedstocks segments of the industry. By Jasmine Davis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

California regulator floats future LCFS linkage


17/09/24
News
17/09/24

California regulator floats future LCFS linkage

Monterey, 17 September (Argus) — California would welcome bringing US low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) programs together in a common market, one of the state's top regulators said on Tuesday. Such a linkage is unlikely to occur in the near future, but California Air Resources Board (CARB) deputy executive director Rajinder Sahota said it is something worth pursuing. "I totally think we should link our LCFS programs," she said at the Argus North American Biofuels, LCFS and Carbon Markets Summit in Monterey, California. Sahota said California and other LCFS states are working on a system that could allow the trading of compliance credits between companies covered by each program, but did not provide any other details. Her comments mark a change in tenor from CARB, which historically has said a linkage would be difficult given the differing starting points and carbon intensity targets of each program. Oregon's Clean Fuels Program (CFP) started five years after California's LCFS, while Washington launched its Clean Fuel Standard just last year. New Mexico is working on its own program that will begin by 2026. Oregon and Washington regulators at the conference said there have not been any formal discussions about a linkage, but did not completely dismiss the idea, highlighting the close informal coordination between the states. "All puzzles can be solved eventually," said Bill Peters, interim director of the CFP. By Michael Ball Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more