EU draft exempts private jets, cargo from jet fuel tax

  • Market: Emissions, Oil products
  • 07/06/21

The European Commission has proposed exempting private jets and cargo flights from the planned EU jet fuel tax. A draft indicates that the tax would be phased-in for passenger flights, including ones that carry cargo.

The draft, which the commission will on 14 July present with its proposed revisions to the bloc's 2003 energy-taxation directive, indicates there could be an exemption from taxation for energy products and electricity used for intra-EU air navigation of cargo-only flights. It proposes allowing EU states to only tax such flights either domestically or by virtue of bilateral or multilateral agreements with other member states.

The commission is worried that taxing fuel for cargo-only flights would adversely affect EU carriers. Third-country carriers, also with a significant share of the intra-EU cargo market, have to be exempted from taxation due to aviation services agreements, the commission argues.

Private jets will enjoy an exemption through classification of "business aviation" as the use of aircraft by firms for carriage of passengers or goods as an "aid to the conduct of their business", if generally considered not for public hire. A further exemption is given for "pleasure" flights whereby an aircraft is used for "personal or recreational" purposes not associated with a business or professional use.

Non-governmental organisation Transport & Environment (T&E) called the proposal "generally good".

"The downside, though, is the commission is considering exempting cargo carriers that are often US-run," said its aviation director Andrew Murphy, who noted "multiple" solutions for taxing jet fuel used by cargo carriers that "tend to use older, dirtier aircraft".

In May, Murphy co-authored a report indicating that private-jet CO2 emissions in Europe rose by 31pc between 2005 and 2019, with flights to popular destinations up markedly during summer holiday seasons. He has argued for a fuel tax for this "leisure-driven" private jet sector.

Airlines for Europe (A4E) fears that setting minimum tax rates for intra-EU flights could lead to distortion of competition. The industry association, which counts 16 airline groups as members including Ryanair, Air France/KLM, Lufthansa, IAG, easyJet and Cargolux, indicated that the commission's proposal could lead to aircraft deliberately carrying excess fuel bought outside the EU specifically to avoid the bloc's jet fuel tax.

Airlines should not pay extra under the revised energy taxation directive when they are already paying for CO2 under the EU's emissions trading sytem (ETS) and participating in the International Civil Aviation Organisation's Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (Corsia).

More generally, the commission sees collection of aviation fuel tax as not problematic, with fuel suppliers collecting it and transferring to relevant tax authorities. The commission estimates the administrative cost of this at 0.65pc of revenue.

The draft may change before 14 July, and does not contain the all-important annexes with tax rates. To enter into force it must be approved by all 27 EU member states, and it may change markedly over the coming months. A commission proposal made in April 2011 to update EU energy taxation rules failed after finance ministers could not agree by unanimity in 2014.

The commission wants to align energy taxation with EU climate goals, meaning that taxes should be based on the net calorific value of the energy products and electricity and that minimum levels of taxation across the EU would be set out according to environmental performance and expressed in €/GJ. These minimum levels should be aligned annually on the basis of the EU's harmonised index of consumer prices, excluding energy and unprocessed food.

Next week, the commission will propose changes to the EU's emissions trading system (ETS). A draft of these did not detail how aviation will be treated, but no free allocations are envisaged for maritime, road transport and buildings sectors. Officials will also present the commission's mandate for sustainable aviation fuels (SAF), whereby all firms could be expected to fill up with blended jet fuels at EU airports.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
03/15/24

Lack of snow reduces Mississippi flood risk: NWS

Lack of snow reduces Mississippi flood risk: NWS

Houston, 15 March (Argus) — The Mississippi River faces below normal flood risk this spring because of historically low snowpack, meaning barges carrying fertilizer and other commodities may experience fewer delays from high water. The lack of snowpack in the Mississippi River basin resulted from persistent drought since last September and unseasonably warm temperatures across the Northern Plains, which prevented a base layer of heavy snow from forming, the National Weather Service (NWS) said in its final spring flood outlook on 14 March. Meteorologist Brennan Dettmann told Argus there is no snowpack in Minnesota, with only a light covering along the northern border, making for one of five driest years since the NWS began recording snowpack in 1872. There is no snow at the Minneapolis-St Paul International Airport this week compared to 10 inches of snow on the ground a year ago. This year, the most amount of snow on the ground at the airport was 7 inches on 14 February, according to NWS. Risk of flooding for the upper Mississippi River and tributaries will be entirely dependent on rainfall, with much of the basin already in a precipitation deficit because of the drought. Barges have been navigating through the upper Mississippi and will soon reach the Twin Cities after locks open tonight at midnight . This time last year, tows were just breaking the ice on Lake Pepin , signaling safe passage to begin through the upper Mississippi River. By Meghan Yoyotte Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

Ammonia-fuelled vessel trialled in Singapore


03/15/24
News
03/15/24

Ammonia-fuelled vessel trialled in Singapore

Singapore, 15 March (Argus) — Ammonia as a marine fuel has been trialled in Singapore on a dedicated vessel, in another step towards the port's multi-fuel bunkering capability. The trial, carried out in phases over a period of seven weeks, used ammonia in combination with diesel in the combustion process. The Maritime and Port of Authority of Singapore (MPA), along with government agencies, research partners and industry partners were involved in the trial process, said the MPA and Australian green energy, metals and technology firm Fortescue. Completion of the trial saw the Fortescue Green Pioneer receive flag approval from the Singapore Registry of Ships, along with a notation by classification society DNV to use ammonia, in combination with diesel, as a marine fuel. The trial had two of the four-stroke engines on the Fortescue Green Pioneer loaded with 5m³ (3t) of liquid ammonia supplied by Dutch storage firm Vopak from its 10,000m³ Banyan terminal on Jurong island. The Fortescue Green Pioneer was converted to run on ammonia, in combination with marine gasoil, following its first land-based testing in Australia in 2022. Ammonia has been promoted as a viable low-carbon alternative fuel for the marine shipping industry that is striving to cut its greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. But the use of ammonia as a fuel has often focused on its safety risks because of its toxicity, while burning ammonia releases another GHG nitrous oxide. The Singapore trial was done in phases to ensure safe port operations and the safety of the ship's crew, as well as engineers, the MPA and Fortescue said. The crew and engineers have been having safety training since October 2023. "The Fortescue Green Pioneer is proof that safe, technical solutions for ammonia power engines exist," said Fortescue chairman Andrew Forrest. Alternative marine fuel demand in Singapore is likely to grow because of higher consumption of biofuels, as well as the rise of bio-methanol for bunkering. Singapore is also exploring using ammonia as a fuel for power generation. By Mahua Chakravarty Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Nigeria tightens sulphur cap on oil products: Update


03/14/24
News
03/14/24

Nigeria tightens sulphur cap on oil products: Update

Updates throughout London, 14 March (Argus) — Nigeria has set the sulphur content limit on refined oil products to 200ppm, effective from 1 March, according to a letter from the country's downstream regulatory body NMDPRA seen by Argus . Oil products containing sulphur levels above 200ppm are no longer permitted to discharge in Nigeria, the NMDPRA said. The sulphur limit for all oil products will be gradually reduced to 50ppm, although a timeframe has not been given. One market participant suggested the sulphur cap for gasoline may be lowered to 150ppm in the short to medium term. Some oil products recently imported to Nigeria contained up to 1,200ppm of sulphur, the NMDPRA said. The old sulphur cap in Nigeria was 1,000ppm for gasoline and 3,000ppm for diesel, according to a source. The regulator did not list penalties for non-compliance but said market participants should be "mindful of the excess sulphur content in products going forward". Enforcement of the new cap will begin at the port of origin through the online documentation process that importers have to complete, a source at the NMDPRA told Argus . Only cargoes with approved third-party certification of sulphur content below the specified limit will be approved to sail for Nigeria. A second set of tests will be conducted on cargoes when they arrive in Nigeria and only those that meet the specifications will be allowed to discharge, the NMDPRA source said. A cargo of 2,000ppm diesel has already been prevented from discharging, according to one market participant. The new sulphur limit will not hamper Nigeria's new 650,000 b/d Dangote refinery in the long run as it is configured to produce Euro V specification oil products, which should mean its road fuels contain no more than 10ppm sulphur. But according to market participants, the refinery has yet to start up its secondary units, including desulphurisation units. Since starting up, the refinery has offered at least one 60,000t cargo of 700ppm sulphur gasoil for loading on a Long Range 1 (LR1) vessel and recently agreed to supply a 20,000t clip of gasoil to a local downstream marketer later this month, according to market participants. The Major Energies Marketers Association of Nigeria told Argus last week that supply of diesel from Dangote to the domestic market is "imminent". Dangote has applied for a waiver to supply 600ppm diesel to the domestic market, the NMDPRA source said. The waiver was likely to be granted this week but would be for a limited quantity of products, the source added. The Dangote refinery has worked with the NMDPRA over the past month to gain approval for the start of secondary units that will enable it to produce diesel with a sulphur content of about 55ppm, according to a market participant. The Netherlands, one of Europe's top gasoline suppliers to west Africa, tightened its rules governing the quality of road fuel exports in April last year . It requires road fuels produced for export to low- and middle-income countries to adhere to a limit of 50ppm sulphur. Belgium is due to follow suit . By George Maher-Bonnett and Adebiyi Olusolape Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

MAN to produce SCR converter for ammonia engines


03/14/24
News
03/14/24

MAN to produce SCR converter for ammonia engines

London, 14 March (Argus) — German manufacturer MAN Energy Solutions has announced it will begin series production of an ammonia-ready selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalytic converter shortly. SCR technology is typically equipped for the purpose of minimising nitrogen oxide (NOX) tailpipe emissions. MAN said this system will be able to reduce NOX emissions by 90pc on cruise ships and cargo vessels, helping to meet International Maritime Organisation (IMO) regulations on NOX in emission control areas (ECA). MAN said the SCR will also aid in improving fuel consumption efficiency. The SCR system has passed final inspection by MAN Energy solutions and Japanese engineering and shipbuilding firm Mitsui E&S, the latter of which will be taking deliveries of the product. By Hussein Al-Khalisy Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Singapore’s Feb B24 demand lowest in more than a year


03/14/24
News
03/14/24

Singapore’s Feb B24 demand lowest in more than a year

Singapore, 14 March (Argus) — Singapore's consumption of biofuels blended bunkers fell to its lowest for more than a year in February with a slowdown in demand from shipowners and charterers, according to statistics from the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA). Consumption of B24 — made of 24pc used cooking oil methyl ester (UCOME) and 76pc very low sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) — was seen at 15,600t in February, down by 65.5pc on a month on month basis and the lowest compared with monthly volumes consumed throughout 2023. "Many SMEs are still testing biofuels, but the larger players aren't increasing their demand because they are meeting their CO2 reductions through other energy saving devices in the short term," a London-based broker said. A key buyer in Singapore confirmed that its purchases have been limited for Singapore and a key Malaysian port in February, corroborating the sharp reduction in demand for bio-bunkers in February. Singapore's consumption of B24 stood at 60,800t for January and February this year, up slightly compared with the same period in 2023. The steady and dramatic rise in demand throughout 2023, that ended with the record-high 518,000t of consumption, has stagnated, with spot sales dipping. "No one is prepared to pay the premiums," a key international trader said, referring to the average of $189/t spread on B24 over VLSFO in the past year, calculated based on Argus' data. "Owners were doing trials on different volumes, but charterers are not paying premium and so owners are not lifting much," the trader added. It remains to be seen when demand will pick up, a key Singapore-based trader said, despite the pressure on shipowners to meet CII ratings by reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from this year. Among other emerging alternative marine fuels, demand for liquefied natural gas (LNG) touched the record highest at 26,900t as key players have explored the option of bunkering LNG in Singapore in the past couple of months. Singapore's VLSFO consumption dipped to 2.55mn t for February, down from 2.86mn t seen in January. Demand for marine gasoil (MGO) also dipped, from 317,000t in January to 296,800t in February. But consumption of high sulphur fuel oil (HSFO) was maintained at 1.6mn t for January and again February. Total bunker consumption in Singapore year to date stood at 9.4mn t, up from 8.1mn t in the same period last year. Overall consumption of bunkers in 2023 rose sharply through the year and hit a record high of 51mn t. By Mahua Chakravarty Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.