EPA plans audit of renewable fuel credit system

  • Market: Biofuels, Oil products
  • 09/21/21

US environmental regulators are stepping up efforts to root out fraud in the trading of renewable fuel blending credits that some small refiners have called a drag on the industry.

The Office of Inspector General for the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) plans to audit trading of invalid Renewable Identification Numbers, a type of credit used to signify compliance with federal fuel blending standards, according to an EPA letter dated 17 September.

RIN credits, which are generated when renewable fuels are blended with traditional fuels for the US transportation supply, have been the subject of controversy since they were introduced as part of the Renewable Fuel Standard in the mid-2000's. Small independent refiners, which typically lack blending capabilities, have alleged the credits disproportionately affect them, while stakeholders on all sides of the issue have called for more transparency into RIN generation, trading and regulation.

In the audit, the EPA inspector will evaluate whether the agency's Moderated Transaction System used to verify RIN trades includes "controls to identify and reduce the generation and trading of invalid RINs."

The US over the past decade has successfully prosecuted a number of RIN fraud cases.

The EPA's latest probe into RIN trading was identified earlier this year as one measure the agency could use to ensure better data reliability as part of its fiscal year 2021 oversight plan. The inquiry comes at a time when rising prices for credits have prompted some obligated parties to step away from the market, while political calls for reformation of the credit system continue to increase.

Prices for RINs, as reflected by the Argus-assessed Renewable Volume Obligation (RVO) benchmark, reached all-time highs this summer, topping 20¢/USG, amid uncertainty about how the new administration of President Joe Biden planned to handle renewable fuel mandates after a raft of lawsuits from US refiners and biofuel interests. The RVO so far this month has averaged 16.08¢/USG, down from the recent record but still more than triple the price 16 months ago and more than five times the average price in 2019.

Several refiners, including Delek, have called RIN credits an "overhang on the industry." Delta Airlines, owner of the 185,000 b/d Trainer refinery outside Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, responded in July to a question about its RIN obligations by saying it was not planning to "spend good cash chasing a marketplace that isn't transparent."

The credit compliance system is also a hot-button political issue in states with strong refining and union interests, as well as those with the agricultural interests backing renewable fuels production. On 16 September, Pennsylvania lawmakers wrote a letter to President Biden claiming that the Trainer refinery's operators will be required this year to "spend twice as much to comply with the RFS program as it spent to purchase the entire company only ten years ago," in a plea to the White House to provide the EPA "with a stronger hand in stabilizing RINs pricing."

Conversely, biofuel lobby Growth Energy in a letter today asked the EPA to set "ambitious" biofuel blending targets when it updates RFS blending obligations later this year.

This is not the first time potential RIN fraud has come under the eye of US oversight bodies. In 2019, the US Government Accountability Office drew attention to "opportunities for fraud" in the trading of computerized RIN numbers, such as the double counting of RINs or generation of RINs for biofuels that do not exist.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
03/18/24

US EPA denies cellulosic biofuel waiver petition

US EPA denies cellulosic biofuel waiver petition

Houston, 18 March (Argus) — The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has denied the American Petrochemical & Fuel Manufacturers' (AFPM) petition requesting a partial waiver of the cellulosic biofuel D3 obligation from the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) for the 2023 compliance year. Current regulatory conditions do not inflict "severe economic harm," the EPA said in its 15 March response. A partial waiver of existing obligation would disrupt existing RFS program participants and potentially reduce future demand for cellulosic biofuel production , the EPA said, adding that its response is immediately effective for all obligated parties but is not a rule making. The EPA estimated that 612.8mn cellulosic D3 renewable identification numbers (RINs) were required for 2022 compliance, including 588mn 2022 vintage RINs and 24.8mn 2021 carryover RINs. RINs are credits traded and produced by refiners and importers to show compliance with the EPA's RFS program. D3 RINs, which make up 2-3pc of overall RIN generation, are tied to biofuel production from biogas, corn stover, and other forms of agricultural waste. In 2022, 663.5mn RINs were generated, leaving 75.5mn RINs available for carryforward into 2023, according to EPA data. For 2023, the EPA projects that 775mn cellulosic RINs will be generated, against an updated industry-wide obligation of 850mns, meaning that 2023 generation plus 2022 carryover will be approximately equal to the total number of RINs required. EPA said it expects no significant shortfall of cellulosic RINs for the 2023 compliance year. AFPM filed the petition in December 2023, requesting a partial reprieve from the RFS obligation due to lower-than-anticipated generation of cellulosic D3 RINs. The organization represents conventional refiners that must acquire or produce D3 RINs to be compliant with the RFS. Following the denial, The Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas expressed its support for the EPA's decision, saying "we appreciate EPA's confirmation that it will enforce the volume requirements it sets under the RFS." By Matthew Cope and Andreas Schwarz Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Read more
News

Brazil's Olfar exports first biodiesel cargo


03/18/24
News
03/18/24

Brazil's Olfar exports first biodiesel cargo

Sao Paulo, 18 March (Argus) — Brazilian biodiesel producer Olfar Group exported its first soy methyl ester (SME) biodiesel cargo on 11 March. The company sent the biofuel to the Kao-hsiung port in Taiwan from the Itapoa port in Santa Catarina state. It did not share the cargo's volume. The cargo was 100pc soybean oil-based and was produced at Olfar's plant in Erechim, in Rio Grande do Sul state. Asia "is increasing biodiesel demand, opening business opportunities for South America," Olfar said. Brazil's biodiesel exports more than doubled in 2023 to 107.9mn l (1,800 b/d) from 41.9mn l in 2022, according to trade ministry data. The most common destinations were Europe and the US. Renewable fuels producer Be8 shipped 85mn l of this total. "With the market opening for exports and the decision to raise the blending mandate to 14pc, the expectation is that the group will increasingly expand its operations," Olfar said. National energy policy council CNPE raised the biodiesel mix mandate to 14pc from 12pc on 1 March. By Laura Guedes Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Norway, Canada propose ECAs for Arctic waters


03/18/24
News
03/18/24

Norway, Canada propose ECAs for Arctic waters

London, 18 March (Argus) — Delegates from Canada and Norway submitted proposals to designate their Arctic Ocean waters as emissions control areas (ECAs) during the International Maritime Organisation's (IMO) 81st Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC) meeting. Canada's proposal would regulate its Arctic waters as an ECA for nitrogen oxide (NOX), sulphur oxide (SOX), and particular matter (PM), while Norway proposes an ECA for NOX and SOX emissions. The two areas are not covered by the existing North Sea and North America ECAs. The proposals were met positively by most other groups at the meeting, including delegates from the Cook Islands, Finland, the US, Mexico, Panama, and Ireland — all of whom supported the proposals going into consideration by the technical committee. But the proposals faced resistance from the Russian Federation, whose delegate said the proposals do not meet the "specified requirements for ECA designation" under MARPOL regulations — pointing to insignificant navigation networks in those areas, lack of a major port, and a sparse population in the two areas under the proposal. The delegate from Russia added that the control measures against NOX and SOX emissions in those areas can be introduced on a national legislative level, rather than being proposed under MARPOL regulations. The session concluded with MEPC agreeing to establish a technical group on the designation of ECAs to evaluate the two proposals. By Hussein Al-Khalisy Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Global standard needed to decarbonise shipping: IMO SG


03/18/24
News
03/18/24

Global standard needed to decarbonise shipping: IMO SG

London, 18 March (Argus) — A global approach to regulations will be essential in meeting the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) decarbonisation and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction targets set in 2023, its secretary general Arsenio Dominguez said today. Dominguez emphasised the need for "global regulations for a global sector", and said existing regional regulations such as the EU emissions trading system (ETS) will need to align to a global standard. He said the timeline to finalise these measures will be by autumn 2025, with the aim for the measures to become effective from 2027. He said an "economic pricing mechanism" will be in place by this time next year, which may be relabelled in the future as a "levy" or a "rebate". The IMO general secretary said the GHG emissions reduction strategy and the economic pricing mechanism will serve as incentives to encourage further uptake of alternative marine fuels. They will be combined with the establishment of an expert group on fuel specification standards, in order to establish marine-specific standards in response to widening specification variety in recent months. Dominguez said the IMO will retain its "fuel agnostic" approach to minimise cross-industry competition and maximise the potential for the maritime sector to meet the GHG emissions reduction targets. In addition to alternative marine fuel specifications, market participants had reported concerns around the viability of carbon intensity index (CII) regulations and how consequences for non-compliant fleets will be enacted. Dominguez said that when CII was adopted, it was regarded as a "soft implementation" that will be revised in 2026. He said a working group will be established at the next Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC) meeting, which will review the CII system. By Hussein Al-Khalisy Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Prates calls for passage of Brazil transition laws


03/18/24
News
03/18/24

Prates calls for passage of Brazil transition laws

Houston, 18 March (Argus) — Brazil needs to approve this year a slate of draft legislation to unlock investment in clean energy technologies and show that the country has done its homework before it hosts the UN Cop 30 climate conference in Belem in 2025, chief executive of Brazil state-controlled Petrobras, Jean Paul Prates, told Argus . Draft bills that create a framework for renewable hydrogen , offshore wind , carbon capture and storage, first and second-generation biofuels and the creation of a carbon market have been through several debates in the lower house and the senate, impeding the development of the respective industries. Prates was the author of several of these bills as a senator before he took on the role of head of Petrobras. "We have been debating in the last year very hard," Prates said on the sidelines of the CERAWeek by S&P Global conference in Houston, Texas, on Monday. "It was the first year of a new government that had to change many things, including in energy policy. They [the draft bills] ensure security for the country and sovereignty. Just because we host Cop 30 in Belem, we need to show that we are doing our homework," he said. Petrobras expects that around half of its revenue will come from renewable technologies, including low-carbon motor fuels, but Prates said the company is being cautious in the process of transforming its business to reduce its emissions. "We are moving in a responsible way, we are not rushing," he said. "We are ready to give new businesses [financial] security because we have the infrastructure, the scale needed [for new projects] and the experience." Apart from biofuels production, green hydrogen and offshore wind development are key areas for the company. The company is analyzing options to replace fossil fuel-based hydrogen used at its refineries with renewable hydrogen. It has also submitted applications for offshore wind areas to the federal environmental protection agency (Ibama). By Jacqueline Echevarria Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.