Latest market news

EPA plans audit of renewable fuel credit system

  • Market: Biofuels, Oil products
  • 21/09/21

US environmental regulators are stepping up efforts to root out fraud in the trading of renewable fuel blending credits that some small refiners have called a drag on the industry.

The Office of Inspector General for the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) plans to audit trading of invalid Renewable Identification Numbers, a type of credit used to signify compliance with federal fuel blending standards, according to an EPA letter dated 17 September.

RIN credits, which are generated when renewable fuels are blended with traditional fuels for the US transportation supply, have been the subject of controversy since they were introduced as part of the Renewable Fuel Standard in the mid-2000's. Small independent refiners, which typically lack blending capabilities, have alleged the credits disproportionately affect them, while stakeholders on all sides of the issue have called for more transparency into RIN generation, trading and regulation.

In the audit, the EPA inspector will evaluate whether the agency's Moderated Transaction System used to verify RIN trades includes "controls to identify and reduce the generation and trading of invalid RINs."

The US over the past decade has successfully prosecuted a number of RIN fraud cases.

The EPA's latest probe into RIN trading was identified earlier this year as one measure the agency could use to ensure better data reliability as part of its fiscal year 2021 oversight plan. The inquiry comes at a time when rising prices for credits have prompted some obligated parties to step away from the market, while political calls for reformation of the credit system continue to increase.

Prices for RINs, as reflected by the Argus-assessed Renewable Volume Obligation (RVO) benchmark, reached all-time highs this summer, topping 20¢/USG, amid uncertainty about how the new administration of President Joe Biden planned to handle renewable fuel mandates after a raft of lawsuits from US refiners and biofuel interests. The RVO so far this month has averaged 16.08¢/USG, down from the recent record but still more than triple the price 16 months ago and more than five times the average price in 2019.

Several refiners, including Delek, have called RIN credits an "overhang on the industry." Delta Airlines, owner of the 185,000 b/d Trainer refinery outside Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, responded in July to a question about its RIN obligations by saying it was not planning to "spend good cash chasing a marketplace that isn't transparent."

The credit compliance system is also a hot-button political issue in states with strong refining and union interests, as well as those with the agricultural interests backing renewable fuels production. On 16 September, Pennsylvania lawmakers wrote a letter to President Biden claiming that the Trainer refinery's operators will be required this year to "spend twice as much to comply with the RFS program as it spent to purchase the entire company only ten years ago," in a plea to the White House to provide the EPA "with a stronger hand in stabilizing RINs pricing."

Conversely, biofuel lobby Growth Energy in a letter today asked the EPA to set "ambitious" biofuel blending targets when it updates RFS blending obligations later this year.

This is not the first time potential RIN fraud has come under the eye of US oversight bodies. In 2019, the US Government Accountability Office drew attention to "opportunities for fraud" in the trading of computerized RIN numbers, such as the double counting of RINs or generation of RINs for biofuels that do not exist.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

LNG-burning vessels well positioned ahead of 2025


19/09/24
News
19/09/24

LNG-burning vessels well positioned ahead of 2025

New York, 19 September (Argus) — Vessels outfitted with dual-fuel LNG-burning engines are poised to have the lowest marine fuel expense heading into 2025 when the EU will tighten its marine EU emissions trading system (ETS) regulations and add a new regulation, " FuelEU", from 1 January 2025. Considering both regulations, at current price levels, fossil LNG (also known as grey LNG) will be priced the cheapest compared with conventional marine fuels and other commonly considered alternative fuels such as biodiesel and methanol. The EU's FuelEU maritime regulation will require ship operators traveling in, out and within EU territorial waters to gradually reduce their greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity on a lifecycle basis, starting with a 2pc reduction in 2025, 6pc in 2030 and so on until getting to an 80pc drop, compared with 2020 base year levels. The FuelEU GHG intensity maximum is set at 85.69 grams of CO2-equivalent per MJ (gCO2e/MJ) from 2030 to 2034, dropping to 77.94 gCO2e/MJ in 2035. Vessel pools exceeding the FuelEU's limits will be fined €2,400/t ($2,675/t) of very low-sulphur fuel oil (VLFSO) energy equivalent. GHG emissions from grey LNG vary depending on the type of marine engine used to burn the LNG, but ranges from about 76.3-92.3 gCO2e/MJ, according to non-governmental environmental lobby group Transport & Environment. This makes a number of LNG-burning, ocean-going vessels compliant with FuelEU regulation through 2034. The EU's ETS for marine shipping commenced this year and requires that ship operators pay for 40pc of their GHG generated on voyages within, in and out of the EU. Next year, the EU ETS emissions limit will increase to 70pc. Even with the added 70pc CO2 emissions cost, US Gulf coast grey LNG was assessed at $639/t VLSFOe, compared with the second cheapest VLSFO at $689/t, B30 biodiesel at $922/t and grey methanol at $931/t VLSFOe average from 1-18 September (see chart). "In 2025, we expect [US natural gas] prices to rise as [US] LNG exports increase while domestic consumption and production remain relatively flat for much of the year," says the US Energy Information Administration. "We forecast the Henry Hub price to average around $2.20/million British thermal units (mmBtu) in 2024 and $3.10/mmBtu in 2025." Provided that prices of biodiesel and methanol remain relatively flat, the projected EIA US 2025 LNG price gains would not affect LNG's price ranking, keeping it the cheapest alternative marine fuel option for ship owners traveling between the US Gulf coast and Europe. LNG for bunkering global consumption from vessels 5,000 gross tonnes and over reached 12.9mn t in 2023, according to the International Maritime Organization (IMO), up from 11mn t in 2022 and 12.6mn t in 2021. The maritime port authority of Singapore reported 111,000t of LNG bunker sales and the port authorities of Rotterdam and Antwerp reported 319,000t in 2023 from all size vessels. Among vessels 5,000 gross tonnes and over, LNG carriers accounted for 89pc of LNG bunker demand globally, followed by container ships at 3.6pc, according to the IMO. The large gap between LNG global and LNG Singapore, Rotterdam, and Antwerp bunker demand, is likely the result of most of the demand taking place at the biggest LNG export locations where LNG carriers call, such as the US Gulf coast, Qatar, Australia, Russia and Malaysia. By Stefka Wechsler USGC bunkers and bunker alternatives $/t VLSFOe Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US court asked for third Citgo auction extension


19/09/24
News
19/09/24

US court asked for third Citgo auction extension

Houston, 19 September (Argus) — The court-appointed special master overseeing the auction of US refiner Citgo has asked the court to delay the announcement of a successful bidder to 26 September and a sale hearing to December. Special master Robert Pincus planned to make an announcement of the proposed buyer on or about 16 September followed by a November sale hearing, but last minute legal challenges derailed what have otherwise been "robust negotiations with a bidder," according to a court filing today. "The special master is continuing to negotiate sale documentation with a bidder," today's motion said. Pincus previously requested a second extension in August and a first extension in late July . By Nathan Risser Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

South Korea's GS Caltex supplies SAF to Japan


19/09/24
News
19/09/24

South Korea's GS Caltex supplies SAF to Japan

Singapore, 19 September (Argus) — South Korean refiner GS Caltex exported around 5,000 kilolitres of sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) to Japan's Narita airport via Japanese trading firm Itochu on 13 September, GS Caltex said today. The SAF was a blend of neat SAF from Finnish biofuel producer Neste and jet fuel. It is compliant with the Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (Corsia) and is International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC)-certified. Neste said it supplied over 1,000t of neat Corsia-eligible and ISCC-certified SAF to GS Caltex's refinery in Yeosu for blending, in what it described as the first time SAF was blended locally in South Korea. The blended SAF was then transported to Japan. The first batch is scheduled to be sold to major Japanese airlines All Nippon Airways (ANA) and Japan Airlines (JAL), ahead of the International Civil Aviation Organization's (ICAO) mandate to use Corsia-eligible SAF from 2027. ANA and JAL have previous agreements with Itochu to secure SAF for their flights departing and landing at Haneda, Narita, and Chubu International Airport. GS Caltex, Neste and Itochu have been collaborating on this project since last year, and will continue to sell Corsia-compliant SAF commercially to Japan. Japan is proposing stricter rules for domestic SAF producers , with further details expected later this year. The country in 2022 mandated that SAF has to account for at least 10pc of domestic airlines' jet fuel consumption by 2030. GS Caltex will likely be the fourth South Korean refiner to produce biofuels this year. S-Oil has been co-processing SAF at its Onsan refinery since January, and SK Energy in September completed a dedicated SAF production line at its 840,000 b/d Ulsan refinery which will begin commercial output next month. Hyundai Oilbank also supplied co-processed SAF to ANA via Japanese trading firm Marubeni earlier this year, marking Japan's first import of South Korean SAF. South Korea's Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy and the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport announced an SAF expansion strategy on 30 August, which includes a target for South Korea to capture 30pc of the global blended SAF export market. By Deborah Sun Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Pertamina supplies first SAF to Virgin Australia


19/09/24
News
19/09/24

Pertamina supplies first SAF to Virgin Australia

Singapore, 19 September (Argus) — Indonesian state-owned refiner Pertamina has supplied its first sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) to airline Virgin Australia, as part of the continuing Bali International Air Show. Pertamina is supplying around 160 kilolitres (kl) of SAF to Virgin Australia's Boeing 737 aircraft from the Ngurah Rai aviation fuel terminal in Bali for flights during 18-19 September. This was part of the 3,500 kl of blended SAF that Pertamina had sought for end-August delivery, intended to be used at the air show. The remaining volumes will be sold to other airlines and sales will be assessed before any further SAF purchases are made, a company source said. The SAF is a blend of 38.43pc synthetic kerosine produced from used cooking oil (UCO) and 61.57pc fossil jet fuel, said the director of central marketing and commerce at Pertamina Patra Niaga Maya Kusmaya. Pertamina also has plans to co-process SAF from UCO at its Cilacap refinery next year, before producing SAF by the hydrotreated esters and fatty acids pathway when its Cilacap "green refinery" comes on line, said a company source, although more details have yet to be disclosed. SAF distributed at Ngurah Rai is also managed using mass balancing, meaning that while jet fuel is mixed with SAF in the same tank as both have similar technical specifications, recording and bookkeeping for both products are managed separately. Pertamina obtained International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC) Corsia and ISCC EU RED-compliant certification for its SAF last month. The SAF supplied also meets ASTM international standards. By Sarah Giam Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more