Cop 27: Climate deal falls short on GHG reduction
Countries at the UN Cop 27 climate conference have adopted a final deal in the early hours of Sunday, agreeing on the creation of a loss and damage fund for vulnerable countries but making no additional progress on efforts to limit global emissions.
The creation of a loss and damage fund has been the most contentious issue debated at Cop 27, but parties finally agreed and "responded to the voices of the vulnerable", said Pakistan climate change minister Sherry Rehman, who spoke on behalf of the Group of 77 (G77) plus China. The inter-governmental organisation of developing nations comprising 134 members pushed hard for a loss and damage fund to be put on the Cop agenda this year.
Countries have decided "to establish new funding arrangements for assisting developing countries that are particularly vulnerable" to the impacts of climate change, including a fund and the mobilisation of new and additional resources, "recognising the need for support from a wide variety of sources, including innovative sources". The EU during the negotiations floated the idea of contributions from oil and gas companies, as well as levies on air tickets and shipping containers, to go towards a loss and damage fund. The creation of the fund is to be established by a transitional committee over the next year.
Countries have hailed the decision on loss and damage, although it is described as imperfect and much work remains to be done. But the lack of progress towards cutting greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions responsible for global warming left many "disheartened", Maldives environment minister Aminath Shauna said. Antigua and Barbuda advisor for climate change Lia Nicholson said — on behalf of the Alliance of Small Island States — that the loss of damage fund was just "a life boat in a brewing hurricane", and Rehman regretted that the parties did not reach "substantive guidance" with regards to updated nationally determined contributions (NDCs) — or countries' pledges to cut emissions.
EU negotiators sought to make the creation of the loss and damage fund conditional to new updated emission reduction targets under the mitigation work programme. EU executive vice-president and lead climate negotiator Frans Timmermans today welcomed the creation of the fund but said that the overall deal reached did "not bring enough added efforts from major emitters to increase and accelerate their emissions cuts". He warned today that a lot of speed was lost since Cop 26 last year.
The Sharm el-Sheikh text reiterates the need to reduce GHG by 43pc by 2030 relative to 2019 levels, unchanged from pledges made in Glasgow last year.
"It does not address the yawning gap between climate science and our climate policies," Timmermans added. The EU and nations part of the high level ambition coalition (HLAC) — including countries such as the Marshall Islands and the UK — wanted to see stronger NDCs aligned with the 1.5°C limit goal, mentions of efforts for global emissions to peak by 2025 and a pledge to phase down fossil fuels. The 2015 Paris Agreement aims to limit global warming to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and ideally to 1.5°C.
Timmermans said that "too many parties are not ready to make progress today" to fight climate change, pointing at "too many attempts" to go back on what was agreed in Glasgow last year and saying that some nations were "afraid of the transition ahead".
Weak on fossil fuels
The energy and mitigation sections of the climate agreement emphasises the urgent need for a rapid reduction in GHG emissions across "all applicable sectors", including through an increase in low-emission and renewable energy, while striving for a "phase down" of unabated coal power and a "phase-out" of inefficient fossil fuel subsidies. This is unchanged from last year's Glasgow Pact and failed to increase ambition on fossil fuels. Mitigation refers to efforts to reduce GHG.
Timmermans said today that more than 80 countries supported the goal of a fossil fuel phase out in the text, but that no solution could be found.
Saudi Arabia was amongst several countries trying to water down the use of fossil fuel language in the final text, with a member of the delegation repeating today on behalf of the 22 countries in the Arab League that "the convention needs to address emissions and not the origin of the emissions".
"It is crucial that commitment [on NDCs] is delivered by all of us, including the major emitters in this room who did not come forward this year," UK lead negotiator and Cop 26 president Alok Sharma said, while pointing at the last minute weakening of the energy section of the text.
Related news posts
Volatile energy prices risk the transition: IEF
Volatile energy prices risk the transition: IEF
Houston, 18 September (Argus) — High or volatile energy prices risk undermining emissions reductions efforts, International Energy Forum (IEF) secretary-general Joseph McMonigle said today at the Gastech conference in Houston, Texas. "If the public starts to connect high prices and volatility to the energy transition, we're in big trouble and we risk losing public support for the transition and climate policy," he said. McMonigle made his comments on a panel with several energy ministers, who discussed the issues of balancing energy security concerns with transitioning to cleaner fuel sources for electricity. When asked what he would consider a "call to action" for the global energy sector, McMonigle suggested investments in emerging technologies. "I think to allow trading of carbon credits is really important to accelerate the transition," he said. "Also, to provide financing for CCS (carbon capture and storage), which I think is one of the technologies that does not have enough investment behind it." By David Haydon Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Citgo auction result delayed amid last-minute motions
Citgo auction result delayed amid last-minute motions
Houston, 18 September (Argus) — The US court-appointed special master overseeing the auction of US refiner Citgo plans to object to a last-minute motion from the Venezuelan government to delay the sale process by four months. The Republic of Venezuela and state-owned oil company PdV filed a motion on Tuesday seeking a four-month pause in the sale of its refining subsidiary Citgo, which is being auctioned off to satisfy debts owed by PdV. Special master Robert Pincus said in a court filing today that he intends to object to Venezuela's motion for a pause. The last-minute motion from Venezuela comes days after the US District Court for the District of Delaware was expected to announce results of the winning bidder. The court asked for a second extension to the auction process in August, delaying announcing a successful bidder to on or about 16 September with a sale hearing on 7 November. But Pincus is now dealing with last-minute legal challenges filed last week outside of the Delaware courts by so-called "alter ego" claimants seeking to "circumvent" the Delaware court's sales process and "jump the line" for enforcing claims against PdV, the special master said in a filing last week. Bidders for Citgo's 804,000 b/d of refining capacity, terminals, retail fuel stations and other plants expect the assets to be sold free and clear of future claims by PdV creditors. Unresolved legal liabilities could lower the value bidders are willing to pay for Citgo, decreasing the pool of money available to those owed by PdV. By Nathan Risser Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
US seeks to purchase 6mn bl for SPR
US seeks to purchase 6mn bl for SPR
Washington, 18 September (Argus) — President Joe Biden's administration is trying to purchase 6mn bl of sour crude for delivery to the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) as part of a plan to issue solicitations when prices are "favorable for taxpayers." The US Department of Energy (DOE) today released a solicitation to purchase up to 6mn bl of sour crude for delivery in February-May to the SPR's Bayou Choctaw site in Louisiana. If the purchase is successful, it would be the largest single purchase since the Biden administration launched its crude purchase program in early 2023. The solicitation offers a chance for the administration to buy crude for the SPR at a lower price than earlier purchases. Nymex WTI crude futures for delivery in February settled at $68.41/bl on Tuesday. The lowest-priced crude purchase under Biden was a 1.7mn purchase at a price of $72/bl in June 2023, and the average purchase price is about $76/bl. Bids for the solicitation are due by noon ET on 25 September. DOE has already purchased more than 50mn bl of sour crude for the SPR, of which 30mn bl have already been delivered. On 9 September, DOE said it purchased 3.42mn bl of sour crude for the SPR's Bryan Mound storage site at a price of $72.46/bl from the trading firm Macquarie Commodities Trading. The crude will be delivered in January-March, adding to an earlier purchase of nearly 2.5mn bl that will be delivered to the Bryan Mound site over the same time frame. By Chris Knight Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Wash. regulators plan for cap-and-trade vote
Wash. regulators plan for cap-and-trade vote
Monterey, 18 September (Argus) — Washington regulators are making a "contingency" plan in the event of a successful repeal of the state's emissions cap-and-trade program. Initiative 2117, which looks to repeal the state's cap-and-trade program and prevent any similar program from taking its place, will be on state ballots for the 5 November election. "We are doing contingency planning in case the ballot measure passes and will update our covered entities when we do have information — and I know this initiative is creating a lot of uncertainty," said Stephanie Potts, senior planner with the state Department of Ecology today at the Argus North American Biofuels, LCFS & Carbon Markets Summit in Monterey, California. The agency also remains focused on continuing to implement the program, "assuming it continues," she said. Washington's "cap-and-invest" program requires large industrial facilities, fuel suppliers, and power plants to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by 45pc by 2030 and by 95pc by 2050, from 1990 levels. The department is in an ongoing rulemaking process to expand and amend its carbon offset protocols, and also continues work to gather input for linkage with the Western Climate Initiative, a linked carbon market between California and Quebec. Potts said Washington expects to have a linkage agreement in place by the end of next year. The uncertainty introduced by the ballot initiative over the fledgling market's future has tempered carbon credit prices and activity this year. Argus assessed Washington carbon allowances (WCAs) for December delivery at $30.25/metric tonne on 4 March, their lowest price since the program's inception in 2023. The drop in prices at that time coincided with a statement by Ecology outlining how a successful repeal would end the agency's authority over the program. Earlier this year, the state Office of Financial Management (OFM) released a fiscal impact statement on a successful repeal that assumed an effective repeal date would be 5 December. By Denise Cathey and Jessica Dell Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more