EU maritime law to encourage LNG over UCO: NGO

  • Market: Biofuels, Natural gas
  • 24/06/21

The forthcoming EU regulation to reduce maritime CO2 emissions provides scope for shipping's continued use of LNG as is a blow to the market for used cooking oil (UCO), said environmental campaign group Transport & Environment (T&E).

The European Commission will next month put forward legislation to force ships to reduce average greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity of energy used by 6pc by 2030, by 49pc by 2050 and by 75pc by 2050, all from 2020 levels. It estimates the cost of achieving this at €90bn by 2050.

T&E says that this simple carbon intensity target would allow for LNG to be compliant for up to two decades even if the low-pressure four-stroke Otto LNG engine ceases to be compliant from 2025. T&E argues that the draft targets would enable the low-pressure two-stroke Otto engine, with medium methane slippage, to be compliant to at least until 2030. A two-stroke high pressure dual-fuel engine, with a diesel cycle, would be compliant until 2040.

T&E calculates that LNG in dual-fuel high-pressure, diesel-cycle engines would be the cheapest compliance option, at €0.85-€0.93/GJ in 2030. It sees waste-based biofuels as the second most cost-competitive option, with a forecast 2030 price of between €1.48-€3.20/GJ, and sees green ammonia's 2030 price at €2.69-€6.72/GJ.

Similarly, a shipping agent calculates that the GHG-intensity threshold is set for LNG-fuelled engines and will incentivise switching fuel oil to LNG. The agent is not sure how much additional carbon-intensity reductions the measure will achieve on top of those pursued by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). And there are questions about how the maritime GHG-intensity reductions will work when the shipping sector is included in the EU emissions trading system (ETS).

The commission's 193-page impact assessment counters that there is a 9.5 factor difference between worst- and best-case scenarios for LNG GHG intensity. It estimates that fossil LNG, in a four-stroke engine, has a GHG performance of 709.49g-CO2 e/kWh, waste-based organic biogas of 248.39g-CO2 e/kWh, and renewable synthetic gas of 75.19g-CO2 e/kWh, all following well-to-wake calculations.

T&E wants the EU to include a sub-target, or ideally a high multiplier of five for 'green' e-fuels. It said that there should be limits on pooling or exchange of credits to e-fuels only, and a clear ban on crop-based biofuels and natural gas as compliance options.

The European Parliament and EU member states will have to agree on a final legal text. If approved as proposed, T&E projects that fossil LNG could reach 18.8pc of total energy used in EU-related shipping in 2030 and 35.3pc by 2035, or 7mn t/yr by 2030 and 11.2mn t/yr by 2035.

T&E sees additional EU shipping demand taking 5.1mn t/yr of UCO feedstock in 2030, on top of demand forecast for road transport and aviation of 6.3mn t/yr in 2030. This means that up to 9.7mn t/yr of UCO imports would be needed, more than six times higher than current levels. T&E noted recent research indicating higher EU demand creating incentives for UCO adulteration.

The commission said that there will be sufficient supply of non-agricultural oils, like UCO, by 2030. It projects the maritime sector to consume only 20pc of feedstock available in the bloc by that date, and between 27-34pc by 2050.

"The remaining feedstock is consumed in other transport sectors such as road transport and aviation," officials note.

The European Waste-to-Advanced Biofuels Association (Ewaba) is less concerned by increased maritime demand, but said the commission's proposals for aviation could "completely" distort the sector and "divert more than half of feedstocks" towards that sector. This would undermine climate mitigation efforts in road and maritime sectors. Ewaba was waste lipids like UCO to be reserved for the road and maritime sectors.


Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News
19/06/24

Investment funds’ long TTF gas position tops 121TWh

Investment funds’ long TTF gas position tops 121TWh

London, 19 June (Argus) — The net long position of investment funds at the Dutch TTF gas hub has reached its highest since January 2022 at more than 121TWh, according to the latest data released by the Intercontinental Exchange (Ice). Investment funds have traded much more heavily at the TTF over the past two months, with their net long position almost tripling to 121.7TWh on 7 June from 31.8TWh in early April, the most recent Ice commitment-of-traders report shows. This is the largest net long position that investment funds have held in the past two and a half years. Late 2020 was the last time that investment funds increased their net long position so quickly, jumping from roughly 75TWh on 27 November 2020 to a peak of nearly 256TWh on 12 February 2021 ( see investment fund graph ). Firms began to unwind this net long position from May, and there was a switch to a net short position in April 2022-August 2023. Continued TTF price volatility may have attracted more investment funds in recent months, particularly as the front-month contract earlier this month hit its highest since December, peaking at €35.88/MWh on 3 June. Russian pipeline gas used to provide the European market with a large degree of flexibility, but the loss of most of this gas, along with higher reliance on LNG, has reduced Europe's supply buffer and has exposed the TTF more to factors well outside Europe. Extended downtime at the Wheatstone LNG plant in Australia, a facility that provides no cargoes to Europe, caused the TTF front-month contract to jump to €36.12/MWh in intra-day trading last week . Similarly, news of shelling in the region of Sudzha , the location of the last still-functioning interconnection point between Ukraine and Russia, caused the TTF front-month contract on Ice to spike by more than €1/MWh in the space of two minutes before falling again. Such sudden jumps and falls have become increasingly common in recent months, with many traders noting the role of algorithmic trading in this phenomenon. A volatile trading environment is more attractive to investment funds than to other types of market participants, as they make most of their money from price volatility whereas utilities make most of their money from the margins on their sales to customers and associated services. The investment funds' move to a large net long position contrasts with a rapid move to a net short position by commercial undertakings, defined as companies with retail portfolios. These two trader categories each held net long positions of roughly 77TWh at the start of November. But investment funds had unwound this into a small net short position by March, while commercial undertakings continued to go longer, reaching a peak of 159TWh in mid-December. Mid-February appears to have been a turning point, with investment funds beginning to climb to a net long and commercial undertakings quickly unwinding to small net short. This was mostly driven by commercial undertakings' increasingly large net short position for "risk reduction contracts", topping 161TWh, as a hedge for similarly sized net long positions on the physical side in storage ( see commercial graph ). This is only the third time since 2018 that commercial undertakings' aggregate position has been net short, with the only other notable time being for a prolonged period in January-August 2021, as well as one brief week in June 2020. This likely reflects historically high EU stocks at the end of the 2023-24 winter, which have to be counterbalanced by risk-reduction hedging contracts. By Brendan A'Hearn and Matt Drinkwater ICE TTF net positions TWh ICE TTF commercial undertakings positions TWh Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Find out more
News

EU warns of 2030 climate ambition gap


19/06/24
News
19/06/24

EU warns of 2030 climate ambition gap

Brussels, 19 June (Argus) — The European Commission has warned of an ambition gap on the way to member states achieving the bloc's 2030 renewables and energy efficiency goals, although it noted "some" progress. And European industry still faces comparatively high energy prices, the commission said in its twice-yearly report on countries' economies and finances. Increasing energy efficiency and switching to less costly renewable energy is "essential" to improve the competitiveness of European industry, but most EU states lack solid and sufficiently detailed investment estimations, as well as concrete measures to attract private clean energy finance, the commission said. And countries need to strengthen their carbon sinks from the land use, land-use change and forestry sectors. For Germany, the commission noted that the transport sector has failed to reach annual sector-specific emission targets, including in 2023 , when the sector increased final energy consumption by 6.3pc compared with 2022. EU states also need to strengthen policies to phase out fossil fuel subsidies so as to align with the EU goal of becoming a climate neutral economy, the commission said. For France, the commission estimated a net budgetary cost of emergency energy support measures at 0.9pc of GDP in 2023 and a projected 0.2pc in 2024, falling to 0pc in 2025. And for Italy the commission forecast a net budgetary cost of emergency energy support measures of 1pc of GDP in 2023, reaching 0pc in 2024. For Germany, the estimations are 1.2pc of GDP going to energy support measures in 2023, 0.1pc in 2024, and 0pc in 2025. Another of the commission's key recommendations is to cut the share of Russian imports in total EU gas imports beyond the 15pc seen in 2023, even if the share historically stood at around 40pc. Further efforts are needed from "certain" countries to phase out imports of LNG from Russia, the commission said. EU states have struggled to agree a further round of sanctions against Russia, which would include restricting the reloading of Russian LNG for export outside the EU at terminals in Europe. EU foreign ministers are expected to discuss the matter at a meeting on 24 June. By Dafydd ab Iago Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Gas necessary for Asia, unwise not to invest: Summit


19/06/24
News
19/06/24

Gas necessary for Asia, unwise not to invest: Summit

Singapore, 19 June (Argus) — Asia's LNG market faces many uncertainties, but not continuing to invest in it would be unwise as it is necessary for economic growth, said speakers at the Association of Energy Negotiators' International Energy Summit in Bangkok, Thailand last week. Many countries are increasingly focusing on batteries and renewables as part of their energy transition plans to move away from fossil fuels, but batteries are still far from being commercially attractive from a cost perspective, said Andrew Kirk, vice-president of origination, LNG at conglomerate B Grimm. Batteries may be able to provide a stable solution to the intermittency challenges posed by renewables in some regions, but wealthier countries are failing to acknowledge that developing countries cannot accept the higher costs involved, as well as the massively daunting task of building and installing the required capacity, he said. "We have to separate the aspirational from the unachievable," said Kirk. There is already instability resulting from gas shortages even in more developed economies such as Australia, where the Australian Energy Market Operator has projected a shortage in southern states. The federal government has confirmed the need for a pro-upstream approach in its future gas strategy , and intends to bring on line new gas supplies and make them affordable during the transition. "The timeline we have given ourselves is starting to look disorderly," said Kirk, with reference to net zero targets. Advancements and breakthroughs in battery technology will be made, but the timeframe for this cannot be defined. If policymakers do not consider reversing declining gas production, the next 10-15 years will create more geopolitical uncertainty, he said. Billions of dollars have been spent on current energy systems, said Steve Morrell, senior vice-president of ExxonMobil PNG LNG, adding that it would make more sense to put more gas into the system considering the higher cost of moving to renewables, he added. "Just by replacing coal [with gas], we'll see a 60pc decrease in emissions without any need for breakthrough technologies." said Morrell. If too much emphasis is placed on renewable energy, this will also lead to declining investment in finding new oil and gas resources, said the executive director of the Petroleum Institute of Thailand, Kurujit Nakornthap, which could lead to energy shortages and more volatile energy prices. "The stone age [ended] not because we ran out of stone, so the oil age is not going to [end] because we're running out of oil," said Nakornthap, paraphrasing a famous quote by ex-Saudi oil minister Sheikh Zaki Yamani. Challenges faced by buyers, sellers Gas projects are already at risk of not receiving funding because the current LNG market outlook is unclear, with short-term price volatility, rolling blackouts, power reduction, and uncertainty in supply affecting buyers and sellers, said Morrell. The whole system is very tight at the moment, added Morrell, and alleviating this is dependent on customers, suppliers and governments as LNG is fundamental to global prosperity. But as a buyer, it is difficult to commit to multi-billion dollar long-term sales and purchase agreements (SPAs) when it is uncertain what the regulatory framework is going to be for the next 5-15 years. The tightness in supply indicates a need for more LNG, which in turn implies there is a need for more projects requiring multi-million dollar investments and that are looking for 20-year offtakes. Gas projects need 4-5 years of construction time and can produce for about 20 years. With an uncertain demand outlook and no buyers to take the product, investment decisions cannot be made and projects cannot get off the ground, said Morrell. "Customers are searching for price signals and trying to plan ahead," said Morrell. But he questioned "if they can't plan six months ahead, how are they going to know 15-20 years ahead?" The changing LNG model Buyers also cannot commit to long-term projects if they cannot predict what the energy transition entails, if certain fuels or greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity reductions get mandated, and how that will change the LNG business model. "The [LNG] market is always changing," said Morrell, with the introduction of carbon pricing to encourage GHG reductions creating further uncertainty for buyers and sellers. There are three areas within the current LNG model that will evolve, said Kirk. There are going to be many new buyers in emerging markets as they turn to LNG as a transition fuel. Secondly, the affordability of low-emission LNG may be an issue because some markets are unable to afford the extra costs when they are struggling to even move from a coal to gas-based market. Thirdly, SPAs will evolve and contracts must change to become more flexible. So buyers and sellers need to "act in good faith", said Kirk. But governments and regulators can slow down developments, which can be frustrating for suppliers, said Morrell. There needs to be a realisation that the consumer is paying for incentives and subsidies that the government provides, he said, adding that discussions should move away from 3–5-year political cycles and look at 20 years in the future. By Prethika Nair Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Phillips 66 targets high Rodeo runs


18/06/24
News
18/06/24

Phillips 66 targets high Rodeo runs

Houston, 18 June (Argus) — Low-carbon feedstock and sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) opportunities will support strong run rates from Phillips 66's converted renewables plant in Rodeo, California, this year, chief executive Mark Lashier said today. The outlook heralded a high output from the converted Rodeo refinery ramping up toward 50,000 b/d of renewable diesel capacity by the end of this month, despite historic lows in state and federal incentives for the fuel. "Where we are today, economically, yes, the credits are kind of compressed, but feedstocks are lower than we anticipated as well," Lashier told the JP Morgan Energy, Power & Renewables conference. "We still see good economic incentives to run and run full." The US independent refiner had started up pre-treatment units at the plant to begin processing lower-carbon feedstocks for renewable diesel in July and August, he said, consistent with previous guidance. "That's how you really make money in these assets — you get the lowest-carbon intensity feedstocks at the best value and process them through the hydrocrackers," Lashier said. " The facility would also bring online 10,000 b/d of renewable jet fuel blendstock production supporting 20,000 b/d of blended sustainable aviation fuel, a product Phillips 66 had not targeted in the initial concept for the site, he said. Both state and federal incentives to supply renewable diesel along the west coast have fallen as the fuel inundates those markets. Renewable diesel alone made up roughly 57pc of California's liquid diesel pool and generated 40pc of the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) credits in the state's market-based transportation fuel carbon reduction program by the end of last year. The supply of lower-carbon fuels, led by renewable diesel, to the west coast LCFS markets have outstripped demand for deficit-generating petroleum fuels and led to growing reserves of available credits for compliance. California amassed more than 23mn metric tonnes of credits by the end of last year — more than enough left over after satisfying all of the new deficits generated last year to offset them a second time. The volume of unused credits has sent their price tumbling to nine-year lows. Oregon and Washington credits, which are needed for similar but distinct programs in those states, have similarly dropped as renewable diesel supplies spread out along the west coast. Gasoline consumption generates almost all new deficits in California. Year-over-year demand for the fuel nationwide has fallen below expectations this spring, Lashier said. "We are not really seeing things pick up like a lot of us expected to," he said. Lower-income customers struggling with higher costs on everything they buy may have forgone vacations, he said. The drop in broader buying power meanwhile had rippled through diesel consumption, he said. "As we move towards more expensive energy sources, that's the part of the economy that gets squeezed as well," Lashier said. "Hopefully we move through that and reverse and that part of the economy can pick up as well as the higher end of the economy." By Elliott Blackburn Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Amtrak used 1.2mn USG renewable diesel in 2023


18/06/24
News
18/06/24

Amtrak used 1.2mn USG renewable diesel in 2023

New York, 18 June (Argus) — US passenger rail service Amtrak used 1.2mn USG of renewable diesel in fiscal year 2023, up from zero the prior year, as the company balances near-term climate targets with goals to increase ridership. Amtrak started using renewable diesel on its Capitol Corridor, San Joaquin, and Pacific Surfliner intercity passenger lines in California during the fiscal year that ended September 2023. Renewable diesel accounted for about 2pc of the company's diesel use over that period, according to a sustainability report Amtrak released this week. The rail service's petroleum diesel use rose by about 6pc year-over-year, reflecting increases in ridership as travel recovers from the coronavirus pandemic. Scope 1 emissions, which come from Amtrak's direct operations and which mostly include burning diesel fuel, were up by more than 3pc from fiscal year 2022. While Amtrak's highly traveled Northeast Corridor is electrified, most of its lines rely on diesel-fueled locomotives. The company plans to replace diesel-powered engines over the long term but says it expects to use renewable diesel as a stopgap solution in the short term and is aiming for the biofuel to become its "main fuel source" for its diesel-powered engines. While the 2022 sustainability report made passing reference to biodiesel — a separate biofuel that can be blended at smaller volumes with petroleum diesel than renewable diesel — the 2023 report only mentions efforts to scale up use of renewable diesel. Amtrak has a goal of curbing greenhouse gas emissions by 40pc from a 2010 baseline by 2030 and achieving net-zero emissions by 2045. Most renewable diesel in the US is consumed in California, which has a low-carbon fuel standard that incentivizes the use of lower-carbon fuels. By Cole Martin Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more