Generic Hero BannerGeneric Hero Banner
Latest market news

Japan’s flexible energy plan poses unpredictable risk

  • Market: Coal, Electricity, Emissions, Hydrogen, Natural gas
  • 20/12/24

An uncertain energy transition demands a range of policy options, but makes investment planning harder,

The Japanese government has addressed the uncertainty facing its new energy mix goal for the April 2040-March 2041 fiscal year by drafting multiple plans to tackle concerns over the future development of clean energy technologies. But the wide range of targets could also reduce predictability and complicate the country's energy strategy toward its 2050 net zero emissions goal.

The new power mix goal will be the centrepiece of Japan's Strategic Energy Plan (SEP), which is due to be updated before the end of March 2025. The SEP must be reviewed every three years, and the previous one was formulated in 2021, before Russia's invasion of Ukraine refocused Tokyo's discussion on how to prioritise energy security, decarbonisation and economic growth.

The latest review of the SEP has totally changed from the previous one, said Yoshifumi Murase, a commissioner of Japanese trade and industry ministry Meti's natural resources and energy agency, noting that Tokyo will take a flexible approach to its power mix goal while facing uncertainties that include a risk scenario for innovation failures. Meti has not disclosed details of these scenarios.

The draft 2040-41 power mix entails renewable energy making up 40-50pc of the country's power generation, up from 22.9pc in 2023-24 (see table). By contrast, Tokyo plans to curb the thermal share to around 30-40pc from 68.6pc over the period. Meti has refrained from disclosing a breakdown for thermal fuels for now, as the ratio of each will vary depending on technological developments in hydrogen, ammonia and carbon capture, utilisation and storage.

But the absence of a breakdown for thermal power targets could weigh on private-sector investment plans, warns one committee member. "[Technological] uncertainty does exist, but the industry can hardly invest without predictability," said Tatsuya Terazawa, chairman of the government-affiliated think-tank the Institute of Energy Economics Japan. Tokyo is supposed to increase predictability for investors with specific measures for each thermal fuel on the table, he added.

Long-term uncertainty

The ambiguous target also makes it difficult to map out Japan's long-term fuel procurement, especially for LNG, which would play a role in ensuring power generation flexibility alongside the growing share of solar and wind. Japan has faced falling long-term LNG supplies as previous SEPs that promoted renewables and the liberalisation of the retail power market disincentivised the industry to extend contracts. Japanese gas demand is expected to fall in the base scenario, but increase in the risk scenario, Teiko Kudo, deputy president of Sumitomo Mitsui Banking, said. It would be important to show the maximum volume of gas Japan may need within a specific period in the next SEP, she said.

The issue of fuel security may be further exacerbated if Japan's planned return of nuclear reactors is delayed. Under the draft power mix for 2040-41, nuclear accounts for around 20pc, up from 8.5pc in 2023-24. But it is still uncertain how many reactors will be operational by then because of safety concerns over Japan's nuclear power sector since the 2011 Fukushima meltdown. The new SEP has made some progress, allowing nuclear power operators who had decommissioned reactors to build next generation reactors at their nuclear sites, not limited to the same site. The previous SEP did not mention building new reactors or replacements.

The 2040-41 power mix aligns with a 73pc greenhouse gas emission reduction goal by 2040-41 based on 2013-14 levels. The new emissions target is currently under discussion, ahead of Japan's submission of its updated nationally determined contribution (NDC) to the UN Climate Change secretariat by February 2025. Power mix goals could be revised depending on the final NDC, Meti said.

Japan's power mix goal%
FY23FY30FY40
Power generation TWh9859341,100-1,200
Renewable22.936-3840-50
Solar9.814-1622-29
Wind1.15.04-8
Hydroelectric7.611.08-10
Geothermal0.31.01-2
Biomass4.15.05-6
Nuclear8.520-2220
Thermal68.641.030-40
LNGNA20NA
CoalNA19NA
OilNA2NA
Hydrogen/ammoniaNA1.0NA
FY23: actual ratio (preliminary), FY30: confirmed goal, FY40: draft goal

Sharelinkedin-sharetwitter-sharefacebook-shareemail-share

Related news posts

Argus illuminates the markets by putting a lens on the areas that matter most to you. The market news and commentary we publish reveals vital insights that enable you to make stronger, well-informed decisions. Explore a selection of news stories related to this one.

News

Trump announces plan for 'reciprocal' tariffs: Update


13/02/25
News
13/02/25

Trump announces plan for 'reciprocal' tariffs: Update

Updates with more details, additional quotes from Trump. Washington, 13 February (Argus) — President Donald Trump said today he would impose "reciprocal tariffs" on imports from an undisclosed number of countries sometime in the future, a move that could affect imports of ethanol and likely many other energy commodities. The idea behind the next major wave of tariffs Trump plans to unveil is to raise the US import tariffs to the same level foreign countries charge on exports from the US. A fact sheet circulated by the White House singled out Brazil's tariffs on US-sourced ethanol and EU's higher tariffs on imported cars as examples of the allegedly discriminatory treatment that Trump would attempt to address. "They charge us a tax or tariff, and we charge them the exact same tax, very simple," Trump told reporters at the White House. As with his first tariffs against Canada and Mexico — paused until 4 March — and against China, which went into effect on 4 February, there is a great deal of regulatory uncertainty on how or when the tariffs will be implemented. "Nobody knows what that number is, unless you go by the individual country, and you can see what it is," Trump said. So far, the pending actions do not yet appear to be as severe or hastily implemented as Trump's recent comments led many to believe. His directive does not set a specific deadline for when the reciprocal tariffs will be imposed. It merely directs US government agencies to review if US exporters face higher taxes and other trade barriers compared with their foreign competitors, and to propose countermeasures. The review preceding the potential imposition of 'reciprocal tariffs' will be complete by 1 April, Trump's commerce secretary nominee, Howard Lutnick, said. "We'll be ready to go on 1 April and and we'll hand it to the president, and he'll make a decision," Lutnick said. The intent of the directive is to force foreign countries to lower their tariffs against the US. But that outcome is not guaranteed. Trump's 10pc tariff on imports from China, and Beijing's more limited counter-tariffs, went into effect this month despite his claim that he would quickly negotiate with Beijing to avert a trade war. In what is becoming a norm with the tariff announcements, Trump is alternatively downplaying inflationary effects of such tariffs, or casting any negative effects as justified. The tariffs are going to result in "tremendous amounts of jobs, and ultimately prices will stay the same, or go down, but we're going to have a very dynamic country," Trump said. Prompted by the reporters to say if voters would hold him responsible for any resulting spike in inflation, Trump said, "prices could go up somewhat short-term, but prices will also go down." The White House, at least, no longer rejects descriptions of tariffs as a tax, even though it continues to insist that only foreign exporters — not US consumers — will be paying it. Trump has imposed a 25pc tariff on imported steel and aluminum that will become effective on 12 March. The 1 April date referenced in today's announcement is also a deadline set in an earlier Trump executive order for all US government agencies to investigate the causes of "our country's large and persistent annual trade deficits in goods". That review is the first step in planned imposition of tariffs on national security and other grounds against imports from the EU, UK, India, Vietnam and other major economies. The large deficit the US runs in trade in goods with India will be a subject of Trump's meeting later today with Indian prime minister Narendra Modi. The US expects India to step up purchases of crude and other energy commodities to better balance bilateral trade. Trump likewise told Japan's prime minister Shigeru Ishiba last week that Tokyo should ensure that Japanese energy companies source more US oil, LNG and ethanol to "get rid of" the US' trade deficit with Japan. By Haik Gugarats Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

ACBL sets release dates for Illinois River lock


13/02/25
News
13/02/25

ACBL sets release dates for Illinois River lock

Houston, 13 February (Argus) — Major barge carrier American Commercial Barge Line (ACBL) has issued its earliest release dates for Illinois River barges planning to transit the Lockport Lock, which closed for maintenance last month. Release dates will be from 23 February through 19 March for barges expecting to pass through the Lockport Lock over the spring season, ACBL said Wednesday. The US Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) expects to reopen the Lockport Lock on 25 March, the Corps said when it announced the closure . The Corps closed the lock on 28 January to install new vertical lift gates and make repairs. The closure has cut off major trade hubs such as Chicago, Illinois, and Burns Harbor, Indiana, from Illinois River barge transportation. Lock 27 and the Mel Price Lock above St Louis will remain partially closed through 1 April, as they are also undergoing maintenance by the Corps, ACBL said. The barge line acknowledged higher demurrage rates were likely for those who loaded barges prior to the released dates. Initial transit on the Illinois River is also anticipated to have a significant backlog in the spring months. By Meghan Yoyotte ACBL's Illinois River release dates Origin Port Barges destined above Lockport Lock, on IL River Mobile, AL 25 Feb Houston, TX 23 Feb Weeks Island, LA 26 Feb New Orleans, LA 3 Mar Pittsburgh, PA 2 Mar Cincinnati, OH 5 Mar Decatur, AL 10 Mar Memphis, TN 10 Mar Evanscille, IN 12 Mar Cairo, IL 16 Mar St Louis, MO 19 Mar — ACBL Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

Trump announces plan for 'reciprocal' tariffs


13/02/25
News
13/02/25

Trump announces plan for 'reciprocal' tariffs

Washington, 13 February (Argus) — President Donald Trump said today he would impose "reciprocal tariffs" on imports from an undisclosed number of countries sometime in the future, a move that could affect imports of ethanol and likely many other energy commodities. The idea behind the next major wave of tariffs Trump plans to unveil is to raise the US import tariffs to the same level foreign countries charge on exports from the US. Trump's trade advisers previously cited Brazil's tariff on US-sourced ethanol, which is higher than the US customs duty on ethanol, as an example of the disparity they would attempt to address. "They charge us a tax or tariff, and we charge them the exact same tax, very simple," Trump told reporters at the White House. As with his first tariffs against Canada and Mexico — paused until 4 March — and against China, which went into effect on 4 February, there is a great deal of regulatory uncertainty on how the tariffs will be implemented. "Nobody knows what that number is, unless you go by the individual country, and you can see what it is," Trump said. Trump's directive does not set a specific deadline for when the reciprocal tariffs will be imposed. The intent of the order is to force foreign countries to lower their tariffs against the US. But that outcome is not guaranteed. Trump's 10pc tariff on imports from China, and Beijing's more limited counter-tariffs, went into effect this month despite his claim that he would quickly negotiate with Beijing to avert a trade war. In what is becoming a norm with the tariff announcements, the Trump administration is alternatively downplaying inflationary effects of such tariffs, or casting any negative effects as justified. "Last year, US-based companies paid foreign governments $370bn in taxes," White House National Economic Council director Kevin Hassett said today. "Meanwhile, foreign companies paid the US $57bn in taxes. Are we supposed to keep doing that because of some economic model that doesn't have the whole real world in it?" The White House, at least, no longer rejects descriptions of tariffs as a tax, even though it continues to insist that only foreign exporters — not US consumers — will be paying it. Trump has imposed a 25pc tariff on imported steel and aluminum that will become effective on 12 March. He set a deadline of 1 April for all US government agencies to investigate the causes of "our country's large and persistent annual trade deficits in goods" — a review that likely will result in additional tariffs later this year against imports from the EU, UK, India, Vietnam and other major economies. The large deficit the US runs in trade in goods with India will be a subject of Trump's meeting later today with Indian prime minister Narendra Modi. The US expects India to step up purchases of crude and other energy commodities to better balance bilateral trade. Trump likewise told Japan's prime minister Shigeru Ishiba last week that Tokyo should ensure that Japanese energy companies source more US oil, LNG and ethanol to "get rid of" the US' trade deficit with Japan. By Haik Gugarats Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

News

US wholesale inflation holds near 2-year high in Jan


13/02/25
News
13/02/25

US wholesale inflation holds near 2-year high in Jan

Houston, 13 February (Argus) — Prices paid to US producers in January held at nearly a two-year high, another sign of mounting inflation pressures that may keep the Federal Reserve from lowering rates for longer. Prices paid to producers (PPI) rose by 3.5pc in January from a year earlier, matching the prior month's gain, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said today. Analysts surveyed by Trading Economics had forecast a gain of 3.2pc. The PPI number follows a higher-than-expected consumer price reading Wednesday which together reinforce the message that the Federal Reserve may hold off longer on rate cuts, especially in the face of potentially inflationary trade conflicts and migrant roundups under the new US administration. PPI excluding food, energy and trade services rose by 3.4pc in January following a 3.5pc gain in December. PPI for services rose by 4.1pc in January following a 4pc gain in December. Wholesale prices for energy were flat following a 2pc annual decline the prior month. PPI for goods rose by 2.3pc in January following a 1.8pc gain in December On a monthly basis, headline PPI rose by a seasonally adjusted 0.4pc, compared with a 0.5pc gain in December and a 0.2pc increase in November. Services PPI rose by 0.3pc in December, following a monthly gain of 0.5pc in December and a 0.1pc gain in November. By Bob Willis Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2025. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.

Generic Hero Banner

Business intelligence reports

Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.

Learn more