Citgo share fight continues in appellate court: Update
Updates from hearing.
Federal appellate court judges in Pennsylvania today questioned arguments that a lack of injury from Venezuelan-controlled Citgo was enough to separate the refiner from the country's billions of dollars in debt.
The US Third Circuit Court of Appeals could block one path to restitution for companies with assets expropriated by Venezuelan governments or make vulnerable the US refining and terminal infrastructure those governments have repeatedly mortgaged for cash.
The court heard arguments this afternoon over whether a US district court erred in deciding last fall that debtors can attach Venezuela's state-owned oil company PdV, and by extension its US refining subsidiary Citgo, to satisfy the expropriation of Crystallex mining assets by the Venezuelan government.
Appellate judges Thomas Ambro and Joseph Greenaway Jr asked PdV attorneys to name a single case in which a party needed to show that a country caused injury through an entity it fully controlled to make that entity liable, as a district judge found last August.
Arguments continued this afternoon.
The district court determined last fall that Citgo assets were effectively the possessions of Venezuela, not indirectly held through subsidiaries. The finding allowed Crystallex to pursue an auction of shares of Citgo's controlling US holding company. PdV insisted the court erred by associating PdV with the expropriation and by ignoring its sovereign immunity. Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido's attorneys filed separately last month and argued that the decision could imperil US foreign policy.
Venezuela took over Crystallex's Las Cristinas gold mining assets almost a decade ago. The World Bank's International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (Icsid) awarded the company $1.2bn and interest for the expropriation in 2016. PdV was not a party to the arbitration.
Crystallex, now controlled by New York-based investment firm Tenor, laid the groundwork to pursue Citgo in 2017. The company sought to force payment of the debt through access to Venezuelan assets in the US. PdV said the court improperly set aside its sovereign immunity and its status as a separate entity from the Venezuelan government. Crystallex argued that PdV, directly controlled by and essential to the funding of President Nicolas Maduro's government, could not be separated from Venezuela's leadership.
Venezuela losing US leverage
Citgo, a subsidiary of Venezuelan national oil company PdV, has tried to exude steady profitability as lenders, jilted investors and rival political factions wrestle for shares of the company. US sanctions cut off Citgo payments to Venezuela in 2017, and in January halted shipments of diluent essential to the country's crude exports. But Citgo's 750,000 b/d of US refining capacity and associated pipelines and terminals remain vital to Venezuela's current and future governments.
The US assets support billions of dollars of commercial and Russian lending. Those lenders do not want other creditors to seize that collateral. PdV must pay $72mn in interest on 29 April on a 2020 bond secured with 50.1pc of the shares of Citgo's holding company. The company must pay more than $800mn in principal and interest in October. The remaining 49.9pc of shares were pledged to back a $1.5bn loan from state-controlled Rosneft.
PdV and Crystallex have reached settlements twice. The most recent agreement, reached last fall, stalled auction proceedings and involved a roughly $400mn payment to Crystallex before falling apart in December.
Appellate judges decided last month to allow arguments from bondholders and Guaido's opposition government.
The US and most western governments recognize Guaido, head of Venezuela's national assembly, as an interim president leading a transition to new elections. Guaido appointed new Citgo directors in February, and the US refinery is the only Venezuelan institution so far over which the opposition leader has exerted any control over. His administration still has no access to Citgo revenue.
"This proceeding has thus endangered US foreign policy, threatening a judicial auction of highly visible strategic assets of the republic — albeit assets indirectly held," Guaido's attorneys wrote. "Such an auction would not just be unseemly; it would be dangerous, undermining US foreign policy by impeding President Guaidó's ability to complete the transition of the republic to democracy."
But no matter who will run the country, Venezuela owes substantial debts, Crystallex responded last week. The appellate court's charge was only to consider the district court's decision — not how plans might change for the executive branch. Guaido appointments have shown no more independence of Citgo from a Venezuelan government than Maduro's, Crystallex said.
"As the Assads and Castros of the world will attest, our nation's record of pressuring dictators into retirement through economic pressure is not one of unalloyed success," Crystallex wrote. "Even if it were appropriate for this court to consider new facts in these appeals (and it is not), mere speculation about PdV's future under the Guaido regime — if it ever fully comes to power — cannot erase two decades of Venezuela's disregard for corporate formalities."
Related news posts
Indonesia's Pertamina to complete gasoline unit in Aug
Indonesia's Pertamina to complete gasoline unit in Aug
Singapore, 25 April (Argus) — Indonesian state-controlled refiner Pertamina aims to finish building its new 90,000 b/d residual fluid catalytic cracker (RFCC) in the Balikpapan refinery in August, the firm said. The RFCC is a gasoline production unit, which typically uses residual fuel as a feedstock. The unit will be able to produce propylene, LPG and 92R gasoline that will meet the Euro V specifications, said Pertamina last week, without disclosing further details such as the start-up date. The newly built RFCC unit will be the largest in Indonesia, with the second-largest being the 83,000 b/d RFCC in Balongan and the third-largest the 54,000 b/d RFCC in Cilacap. The new RFCC will also help reduce Indonesia's reliance on gasoline imports. Indonesia currently imports around 9mn-11mn bl/month of gasoline, making it the largest gasoline buyer in the Asia-Pacific. The new RFCC will increase Pertamina's gasoline production by a conservative estimate of 45,000 b/d or 1.3mn bl, or around 10pc of Pertamina's current import demand, according to estimates from an oil analyst. The installation of the new RFCC is part of Pertamina's Refinery Development Master Plan (RDMP), which will take place in two phases. The first phase includes revamping existing units at the Balikpapan refinery, such as the crude distillation unit, vacuum distillation unit, and hydrocracking unit. It also involves building new units, such as the aforementioned RFCC, a gasoline hydrotreater, diesel hydrotreater, and naphtha hydrotreater. The second phase includes building a new residue desulphurisation unit. The RDMP also includes expanding the capacity of the Balikpapan refinery from 260,000 b/d to 350,000 b/d, said Pertamina's chief executive officer Nicke Widyawati. The Balikpapan expansion is expected to be completed in May. By Aldric Chew Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Barge delays at Algiers lock near New Orleans
Barge delays at Algiers lock near New Orleans
Houston, 24 April (Argus) — Barges are facing lengthy delays at the Algiers lock near New Orleans as vessels reroute around closures at the Port Allen lock and the Algiers Canal. Delays at the Algiers Lock —at the interconnection of the Mississippi River and the Gulf Intracoastal Waterway— have reached around 37 hours in the past day, according to the US Army Corps of Engineers' lock report. Around 50 vessels are waiting to cross the Algiers lock. Another 70 vessels were waiting at the nearby Harvey lock with a six-hour wait in the past day. The closure at Port Allen lock has spurred the delays, causing vessels to reroute through the Algiers lock. The Port Allen lock is expected to reopen on 28 April, which should relieve pressure on the Algiers lock. Some traffic has been rerouted through the nearby Harvey lock since the Algiers Canal was closed by a collapsed powerline, the US Coast Guard said. The powerline fell on two barges, but no injuries or damages were reported. The wire is being removed by energy company Entergy. The canal is anticipated to reopen at midnight on 25 April. By Meghan Yoyotte Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Cepsa supplies HVO bunker fuel in Algeciras
Cepsa supplies HVO bunker fuel in Algeciras
London, 24 April (Argus) — Spanish refiner and bunker fuel supplier Cepsa has recently delivered 150t of 100pc hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) by truck to the Ramform Hyperion at the port of Algeciras. The supply follows market participants reporting firmer buying interest for HVO as a marine fuel from ferry lines in the Mediterranean in recent sessions. The supplied HVO is said to be of class II, with used cooking oil (UCO) as the feedstock. Cepsa added that the supply was completed in cooperation with Bunker Holding subsidiary Glander International Bunkering, and could bring about a greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction of up to 90pc compared with conventional fuel oil. Cepsa will also look to obtain capability to supply marine biodiesel blends exceeding 25pc biodiesel content by the end of the year, delegates heard at the International Bunker Conference (IBC) 2024 in Norway. This also follows plans by Cepsa to build a 500,000 t/yr HVO plant in Huelva , set to start production in the first half of 2026. Argus assessed the price of class II HVO on a fob Amsterdam-Rotterdam-Antwerp (ARA) basis at an average of $1,765.54/t in April so far, a premium of $906.41/t to marine gasoil (MGO) dob Algeciras prices in the same month. By Hussein Al-Khalisy Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Iraq to keep 3.3mn b/d crude export cap until year end
Iraq to keep 3.3mn b/d crude export cap until year end
Dubai, 24 April (Argus) — Iraq will stick to its pledge to cap crude exports at 3.3mn b/d until the end of the year, regardless of what the Opec+ coalition decides at its June meeting, sources with knowledge of the matter told Argus. Baghdad announced the 3.3mn b/d export limit last month , representing a 100,000 b/d cut compared with the first-quarter average. April's exports will be in line with recent months, according to the sources, indicating that Iraq has yet to adhere to the cap. The self-imposed limit on exports is part of Iraq's commitment to compensate for exceeding its 4mn b/d Opec+ production target in the first three months of 2024. It produced 211,000 b/d above target in January, then overshot by 217,000 b/d and 194,000 b/d in February and March, respectively, according to an average of secondary sources including Argus . Prior to that, Iraq exceeded its then 4.22mn b/d output ceiling in each of the last six months of 2023. The persistent overproduction has drawn scrutiny within Opec+, prompting repeated reassurances from Baghdad in recent months that it is committed to its output pledges. Iraq blames it on its inability to oversee production in the semi-autonomous Kurdistan region in the north of the country. Most Iraqi Kurdish crude output is being directed to local refineries or sold on the black market following the closure of the export pipeline that links oil fields in northern Iraq to the Turkish port of Ceyhan just over a year ago. Iraq's federal oil ministry says its Kurdish counterpart has stopped providing production data. Baghdad recently sent the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) an official request to hand over oil produced in the region to federal marketer Somo in order to resume Kurdish exports through Turkey, the sources said. Baghdad also urged the KRG back in January to curb output to help Iraq adhere to its lower Opec+ production quota. Ever-widening gap The Association of the Petroleum Industry of Kurdistan (Apikur) said international oil companies (IOCs) operating in the region were hoping that a long-awaited visit to Baghdad by Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan on 22 April might help pave the way for a restart in exports. "We definitely believe the Iraqi government seems more serious about resolving the issues after prime minister [Mohammed Shia] al-Sudani's visit to the US," an IOC source told Argus. But differences between the KRG and Baghdad, mainly over contracts that the former signed with international oil companies (IOCs) in Kurdistan, continue to delay the restart. And tensions between the two sides show little sign of easing. In a statement on 22 April, the KRG's ministry of natural resources accused Baghdad of misleading statements by seeking to blame the KRG for the export shut-in, adding that there is no provision in Iraq's constitution that gives power to the federal government to approve contracts issued by the KRG. With the help of multiple federal court rulings, Baghdad has been attempting to downgrade the KRG's autonomy over its finances and energy sector. A court ruling in February 2022 overturned a law governing Kurdish oil and gas exports and upheld Baghdad's request that all KRG production-sharing contracts be placed under federal oil ministry oversight. The judgment rendered the KRG's 2007 oil and gas law unconstitutional, raising questions over the future of the KRG's active contracts. The KRG's natural resources ministry has dismissed the February 2022 court order, saying it was delivered by a "committee of political appointees in Baghdad". While the federal Iraqi oil ministry "publicly refers to that committee as the 'Federal Supreme Court', everyone knows that it is no such thing", the ministry said. By Bachar Halabi Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more