Ukraine crisis highlights Russia fertilizer supply risk
The crisis in Ukraine and potential responses from western governments targeting Russia could have wide-ranging effects on supply of fertilizer to global markets.
Russia is one of the world's most significant suppliers of fertilizer and related raw materials such as sulphur. It was the largest exporter of urea, NPKs, ammonia, UAN and ammonium nitrate last year, and the third-largest potash exporter (see table below). In phosphates, traditionally dominated by China and Morocco, Russia is a major exporter with a combined 4mn t/yr of DAP/MAP shipments last year. It is the fourth-largest sulphur exporter. At today's prices, typical Russian spring export volumes would account for over $2bn/month in revenue.
The major markets for Russian fertilizers and related raw materials include Brazil and, ironically, the EU and US. Russian nitrogen products are of particular significance to European buyers at present as the continent remains lightly supplied for spring fertilizer applications after several nitrogen plants were forced off line for extended periods by high natural gas prices. European natural gas feedstock costs remain elevated, with prices at the TTF hub rising yesterday by around 10pc to €83/MWh ($28/mn Btu).
As of 23 February, no sanctions imposed by the US, UK or EU governments have targeted Russian commodity exports or had significant impact on the fertilizer industry.
Price response in fertilizers has so far been muted, with the exception of the ever-volatile Nola urea market, which leapt by around $40/st yesterday as traders reacted to the possibility of US sanctions affecting Russian urea exports.
Exports from Russia of some fertilizers have already been somewhat curtailed by the export controls imposed by the government late last year, with a two-month ban on ammonium nitrate shipments in place since the start of February.
Russian fertilizer exports and market share in 2021 | |||
Product | Tonnage | Export market share | Export market rank |
MOP | 11,832,717 | 27% | 3rd |
Ammonium nitrate | 4,313,229 | 49% | 1st |
Urea | 6,999,814 | 18% | 1st |
NPKs | 5,928,142 | 38% | 1st |
Ammonia | 4,424,342 | 30% | 1st |
DAP/MAP | 4,048,081 | 14% | 4th |
Sulphur | 1,805,567 | 9% | 3rd |
— Customs data |
Related news posts
Jera delays Hekinan NH3-coal co-firing test: Correction
Jera delays Hekinan NH3-coal co-firing test: Correction
Corrects trial period in first paragraph Osaka, 26 March (Argus) — Japan's largest power producer by capacity Jera has pushed back a trial to co-fire 20pc of fuel ammonia with coal at its Hekinan power plant to after the end of March. Jera previously said the co-firing demonstration at the 1GW Hekinan No.4 unit will start on 26 March at the earliest . But the company has decided to push this back. The trial will begin sometime after the end of this month, Jera said on 25 March. It took more time to test run equipment ahead of the demonstration, with safety the main priority, it added. It is unclear when exactly the company will start the trial to co-fire 20pc of ammonia with coal. Jera aims to demonstrate 20pc co-firing of ammonia with coal ahead of planned commercial operations in the April 2027-March 2028 fiscal year. It also hopes to achieve a 50pc mixture on a commercial basis in the first half of the 2030s. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Yara curtails 2023 European ammonia production by 19pc
Yara curtails 2023 European ammonia production by 19pc
London, 25 March (Argus) — Europe's largest fertiliser producer Yara operated its European ammonia plants at nearly a fifth below their capacity last year, despite its weighted-average gas costs more than halving compared with 2022. Yara curtailed 19pc — or 890,000t — of its ammonia production capacity last year, while it curbed its finished fertiliser production capacity by 15pc, it said in its annual report released last week. This was distinctly below ammonia curtailments of 35pc in 2022 , when the firm insisted it "will not produce or sell at negative margins". Yara's European plants have an average efficiency rate of roughly 36mn Btu per tonne of ammonia produced, according to Argus Consulting estimates, which implies that 890,000t of lost ammonia production is equivalent to about 786mn m³ of gas demand. That said, the firm prioritised production at its most efficient plants such as Sluiskil in the Netherlands and Brunsbuttel in Germany, from which it exported to its less efficient sites where production ran at lower rates. Yara curtailed nearly a fifth of its ammonia capacity, despite its European weighted-average gas cost more than halving to $14.90/mn Btu from $31.80/mn Btu in 2022. Prices were still much higher than in previous years — they were lowest at just $3.60/mn Btu in 2020 ( see prices graph ). Yara's global ammonia production edged down to 6.39mn t in 2023, from 6.51mn t in 2022. And it stayed well below a 2019 peak of 8.48mn t in 2019, suggesting the firm has moved more towards imports to bolster its own production, rather than prioritising strong run rates at its facilities. Yara operates in a "world of volatility" because of military conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East, which affect global supply chains, the firm said. "Strengthened operational flexibility" remains a priority in this context, it said. The firm has warned repeatedly of geopolitical risks associated with an influx of Russian fertiliser output fed by gas that is much cheaper than in Europe. "Vladimir Putin is using fertilisers as a weapon of war," Yara said. "We're sleepwalking into repeating the same mistake with fertilisers as we did with Russian energy imports," Yara's chief executive Svein Tore Holsether told Argus in February . But Yara expects higher European production in 2024, as gas prices have continued to come down while fertilisers prices have held firm. Assuming stable gas purchases, gas costs in the first and second quarters could be $320mn and $100mn lower, respectively, than in the same period last year, Yara said in February . The firm suggested its European ammonia assets could run at or above 90pc of capacity. In regions with "efficient gas markets", Yara seeks exposure to spot market prices "unless exceptional market circumstances clearly give reason for deviation", it said. But in regions without such "efficient" gas markets, the firm prefers entering longer-term contracts "if favourable gas prices are obtainable". Yara has a "high" risk appetite for exposure to gas prices because securing access to, and stable supply of, favourably-priced gas is "imperative to our operations and competitiveness", the firm said. "All of our European gas contracts are hub-based, and we are well positioned to cover the risk of spot exposure," Yara said. At the same time, up to 70pc of its European plants can operate on imported ammonia. Yara's largest gas suppliers are Engie, Shell, Equinor, India's Gail, and Trinidad and Tobago's national gas company, it said. The firm consumed just under 6bn m³ globally in 2023, down from a peak of 6.87bn m³ in 2019 ( see gas consumption graph ). By Brendan A'Hearn Yara weighted-average gas costs $/mn Btu Yara global gas consumption bn m³ Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Fertilizer affordability weakens in 1Q24 on higher N, P
Fertilizer affordability weakens in 1Q24 on higher N, P
London, 25 March (Argus) — Global fertilizer product affordability trended lower through most of the first quarter of 2024, as crop prices slid on higher expected global supplies, while nitrogen and phosphate fertilizers remained at high levels before coming under pressure in the second half of March. The decline in nutrient affordability this quarter comes at a time when farmers start preparing for the spring fertilizer application season in the northern hemisphere. The Argus fertilizer affordability index — a global assessment calculated using the ratio between the fertilizer and crop price index — fell to the lowest quarterly average since the fourth quarter of 2022. Nutrient affordability weakened by 10 percentage points since the start of the year, to 1.03 points in March from 1.13 points in January. An affordability index above 1 indicates that fertilizers are more affordable compared with the base year, which was set in 2004, while below 1 indicates lower nutrient affordability. High urea, phosphate prices weigh on affordability The fertilizer index — which includes international prices for urea, DAP and potash adjusted by global usage — has reached the highest quarter average since 1Q23, owing to high urea and phosphate prices. Urea prices surged through the second half of January, following a bearish end to 2023, initially spurred by short-covering and fresh demand from European markets in the wake of an Indian purchase tender. Levels out of Egypt jumped by around $70/t through the month to over $400/t fob for European markets. Prices remained firm through the first half of February, supported by strong demand from Australia and Thailand, as importers warily eyed rising prices. The supply-demand balance east of Suez was also tightened by plant closures in Iran and Malaysia, as well as restrictions on Indonesian shipments prior to the elections on 14 February. But a return of urea supply east of Suez, a slowdown in buying and weaker gas prices pressured urea levels through the second half of February and into March across most markets, apart from the US, resulting in prices to weaken on the month. For phosphates, DAP/MAP prices remained high on tight supply through the first quarter, while China refrained from exporting product. Also strong demand in Australia and the US diverted cargoes away from other markets. Limited MAP supply and emerging demand encouraged suppliers to raise their offers in March in the west. Meanwhile, in the east, the imminent reopening of China is adding to expected supply, and has turned DAP markets bearish. Traders have started to short Chinese DAP with India's RCF awarding its latest buy tender at $575/t cfr — $20/t lower than the last reported cfr sale into India. But for now, prices remain far above the breakeven price of around $509/t cfr, given the reduced Indian DAP subsidy of 21,676 rupees/t for the April-September kharif season. Crop prices under pressure High fertilizer prices so far in the quarter coincided with a decline in grain prices for wheat, corn and soybeans owing to expectations of higher global supplies in the coming season. This has led to the crop price index — the key element of the affordability index — falling to its lowest point since the fourth quarter of 2020. Global wheat output is forecast to reach 799mn t in the 2024-25 season (July-June), according to the International Grains Council (IGC), up by 10mn t from the IGC's 2023-24 projection, but consumption is expected to be flat on the previous season. Global corn production is also expected to rise in 2024-25, up by 6mn t on the year to 1.233bn t in 2024-25. And global corn consumption is forecast to increase, up by 18mn t to 1.23bn t in 2024-25. Carryover corn stocks for major exporters are set to increase by 7mn t on the year to 78mn t, according to the IGC. As for soybeans, the IGC forecasts global production to rise by 23mn t to 413mn t in 2024-25 because of larger acreages and improved yields. Global consumption is projected to rise by 21mn t on the year to 404mn t, according to the IGC. The council also expects higher carryover stocks at 75mn t in 2024-25, up by 9mn t on the year. By Lili Minton, Harry Minihan and Tom Hampson Global Fertilizer Affordability Index (points) Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Jera considers joining ExxonMobil’s H2 project in US
Jera considers joining ExxonMobil’s H2 project in US
Osaka, 25 March (Argus) — Japan's largest power producer by capacity Jera is considering joining an ExxonMobil-led hydrogen and ammonia production project in the US, aiming to boost its ammonia import portfolio in its efforts to reduce coal use. Jera has signed a framework agreement with ExxonMobil to jointly explore the development of blue hydrogen and its derivative of ammonia at ExxonMobil's Baytown complex east of Houston, Texas, the Japanese firm said on 25 March. Jera will explore the possibility of importing around 500,000 t/yr of ammonia and securing a stake in the project through the deal. ExxonMobil is developing a hydrogen production plant and a carbon capture and storage (CCS) facility at its Baytown complex, aiming to begin operations in 2028. The plant would produce around 900,000 t/yr of hydrogen, part of which will be used to produce around 1mn t/yr of ammonia, Jera said. Jera is separately working with Norway-based fertilizer producer Yara and US ammonia producer CF Industries to develop blue ammonia production on the US Gulf coast, targeting production of more than 1mn t/yr under each partnership. Jera has not decided yet whether it wants to invest in the upstream projects. Jera said it can proceed with projects to invest in low-carbon ammonia production and marketing only with financial and other support from the government . The private sector cannot make upstream or downstream decisions on fuel ammonia "based on just pure business judgment," Jera chief executive Yukio Kani said at CERAWeek by S&P Global in Houston on 20 March. Beyond funding, the government will have to help set safety and other standards for the new type of fuel, Kani said. Jera aims to import around 2mn t/yr of fuel ammonia in 2030 , which is nearly 70pc of Japan's current 2030 ammonia demand target of 3mn t/yr. The company is planning to start testing the use of ammonia at its 1GW Hekinan No.4 coal-fired unit by the end of this month. Tokyo and Washington have also geared up efforts to strengthen their ties in clean energy technology development, alongside private-sector partnerships. Japan's trade and industry ministry and the US Department of Energy held a second US-Japan clean energy and energy security initiative plenary meeting on 19 March, ahead of a US-Japan leaders' summit in April. This is aimed at accelerating cooperation in developing and deploying clean energy technology such as nuclear energy, floating offshore wind, perovskite solar cell, geothermal, hydrogen and its derivatives, including ammonia and synthetic fuels, as well as carbon management. By Motoko Hasegawa Send comments and request more information at feedback@argusmedia.com Copyright © 2024. Argus Media group . All rights reserved.
Business intelligence reports
Get concise, trustworthy and unbiased analysis of the latest trends and developments in oil and energy markets. These reports are specially created for decision makers who don’t have time to track markets day-by-day, minute-by-minute.
Learn more