Giulia: Hello, everyone, and welcome to another Argus "Biofuels" podcast. My name is Giulia Squadrin, and I'm a business development manager for European Biofuels. And joining me today is Philip Goughary, business development manager for renewables and biofuels for North America. Hi, Philip. Thank you for joining me today.
Philip: Hey, Giulia. Thanks for having me.
Giulia: Yeah, great to have you. So today we'll talk about HVO, hydrotreated vegetable oil, or renewable diesel, RD. And we'll focus on the U.S. market and U.S.-EU trade flows. And for anyone listening, in case of interest, we do cover these products extensively as part of "Argus Biofuels" and "Argus Americas Biofuels" publications. So, starting from the European angle, which is what I'm closest to, HVO is growing rapidly in Europe. So, European consumption is estimated at just over 7 million tonnes this year and is expected to grow to around 9 million tonnes next year and over 14 million tonnes in 2028 on the back of rising mandates as member states work towards their 2030 Red Three targets.
If we look at the production, European hydrotreated biofuels capacity, including both HVO and HFASAF, is estimated at 4.5 million tonnes this year and expected to grow to around 7 million tonnes next year, with several plants coming online. But despite this expected growth in production, Europe will remain reliant on imports to meet the targets. So, if we look at recent trends, flows of HVO into Europe have been coming from Singapore, the U.S., Canada, Malaysia, and China. And this despite duties in place on HVO imports from some of these locations. For example, China, the U.S., and Canada. Philip, would you mind reminding us, please, what is the current duty status between the EU and U.S.-Canada when it comes to HVO trade?
Philip: Yeah, sure. So, the EU first imposed anti-dumping and countervailing duties on U.S. HVO and biodiesels all the way back in 2009. But more recently, the Commission confirmed that duties also apply to SAF, to sustainable aviation fuel. Interestingly, those measures expired in 2026. But the European Commission is allowing them to remain in place while they're running an expiry review. So, that's undergoing review right now. And nothing will change until that review is finalized. But the combined countervailing and anti-dumping duties for most major producers are still set at about 400 euros per tonne. And let's see, back in 2011, these were extended to consignments from Canada. The EU concluded that U.S. producers were using Canada to potentially circumvent the restrictions. So, that's why they extended it.
But there's been an interesting development this year. Back in June, the Commission initiated a review on a Canadian HVO producer named Braya. And Braya is seeking exemption from the anti-circumvention measures because it says it only began commercial production as late as 2024, therefore was not involved in the practices that led to the extension of the previous measures. But, you know, despite all of that, the U.S. and Canada have been two of the largest exporters of HVO to Europe continuously over the past year. And that continues today.
Giulia: Thanks, Philip. Yeah, of course, in addition to the EU, the UK has also been importing U.S.-origin HVO. A bit of backstory here, the UK removed transposed EU duties on U.S.-origin HVO in 2022. But then in March '25, a new anti-subsidy and anti-dumping investigation on U.S. HVO was launched by the UK Trade Remedies Authority. And after various interim communications, then a final decision was reached just this September. And while the TRA had recommended imposing countervailing duties on U.S.-origin HVO, the secretary of state rejected the recommendations, and no duties will be imposed at this stage. So, while the UK will continue to be duty-free when it comes to U.S. HVO imports, and the arbitrage, as you mentioned, Philip, now with the EU has often been open in the past, things have actually been changing recently after the U.S. announced record HVO targets. So, Philip, could you please talk us through those targets and the impact they're having or they're expected to have on the U.S. renewable diesel market and U.S. renewable diesel exports, please?
Philp: Yeah, absolutely. I think we might need a two-hour podcast instead of the time that we have allotted to us for that one, but I'll definitely try to sum it up. So, effectively, the new Renewable Fuel Standard, the RFS requirements for 2026 and 2027 were issued in March of this year. And they were widely viewed as the most bullish RFS mandate ever for biomass-based diesel, which would include renewable diesel and biodiesel here in the U.S. So, materially, the requirements...I guess the best way to put it is the requirements increased the required domestic renewable fuel consumption while also incorporating the previously waived refinery obligations. So, the new base volume requirements for 2026 total, I think it's 25.82 billion RINs and 25.98 billion RINs for 2027. But perhaps the more important part of the story is that, in addition to that, the EPA also added a 70% reallocation of small refinery exemptions, which we call SREs, for volumes in the prior years.
So, if you break that down specifically for the biomass-based diesel category, and that's satisfied by biodiesel and renewable diesel production primarily, the effective compliance requirement is 9.07 billion D4 equivalent RINs in 2026 and 9.2 billion in 2027. That's an increase year-on-year of between 15% and 18%. If you go across all RIN categories, it's more like 7.5% for 2026 and 6% for 2027, if you compare it to the EPA's original proposal from 2025. But if you're just looking at the biodiesel and the renewable diesel, I mean, it's a massive seismic change in requirements. So, really the mandates signal to the market that we need substantially more renewable diesel, biodiesel, and advanced biofuels than the U.S. industry is currently producing. That makes exports significantly less attractive.
And if you go back to July, we really got our first big flag, the first big signal about how transformative these mandates really are. The D4 RIN attached to a gallon of renewable diesel became more valuable than the diesel it actually displaced, than the petroleum product it displaced. And perhaps for the first time in the market's history, that made the compliance credit more valuable than fuel itself. So, that makes the RIN the largest component in the value stack, which historically had been diesel. So, if you imagine that from a producer's perspective, I mean, suddenly you're comparing the value of exporting a gallon of renewable diesel to Europe against keeping it in the U.S. and capturing record compliance value through the D4 RIN. And that's a really, really difficult arbitrage to open.
Giulia: It is, yeah. So, have we already seen significant changes in trade flows since this happened and the measures and the targets came into effect?
Philip: Absolutely. In fact, Argus reported a 47% decline in U.S. renewable diesel exports in June. And that's exactly the kind of market response we'd expect when domestic compliance values begin competing directly with export economics.
Giulia: Thanks, Philip. If we change focus slightly and look at the bigger global picture, of course, we've had an eventful few years. And between the Russia-Ukraine conflict and the conflict in the Middle East, we've seen global distillate supply disruptions that have created really remarkable price actions across every region in the world. And that has created some very interesting dynamics between biodiesel, biofuels, and fossil fuel prices. So, looking at Europe, for example, we've seen in some occasions biodiesel prices fall below diesel, ethanol fall below gasoline, the spread between the Argus for Bay Area HVO benchmarks and diesel narrow shortly after the conflict, and HVO 100 in German pricing below diesel recently.
And I mean, for anyone interested in more details than this, we've actually talked about some of these trends in a recent webinar on HVO and we have another webinar that looks specifically at the German HVO and tickets markets that's coming up in November. So, they're free to listen. So, please just tune in and register if you are interested in this. Sorry for the side note, just going back to our focus. We have also had similar trends in the U.S., if I'm not mistaken, Philip, and off the back of that, the government has been floating the idea of a partial or even a complete temporary ban on diesel exports. Can you tell us, what could be the implications of such a ban on renewable diesel or HVO?
Philip: Oh, wow. Yeah. That is really the billion-dollar question right now, so to speak. And, you know, just like what you were mentioning, what you're seeing in the European markets, in the U.S. markets, we have seen renewable diesels really getting close to values of the conventional fuels, as the conventional fuels have been very, very salty on the back of the military conflicts throughout the world. In terms of the idea that the U.S. government and the administration has been floating about a ban on diesel exports, whether it be partial or complete, it's really complicated. There are quite a few different outcomes that we're monitoring and predicting on the back of this.
So, Argus, obviously, has been watching this very, very closely, and we've released regular and comprehensive commentary on this ban for our subscribers. And in fact, Denise Cathey, who is our associate editor for Americas Biofuels in the Houston office, she really summed it up perfectly in a recent article. And I can read you a quote from that article. Well, Denise said, "Conversations remain focused on conventional diesel, but renewable diesel shares the same classification as conventional diesel under U.S. export schedule numbers, known as Schedule B." That means that unless specified, renewable diesel could fall under the same rules as conventional if there is an export ban.
So, the implication for this, for trade flow between the U.S. and Europe or U.S. and AURA is pretty clear. If renewable diesel is included in the ban, then however many barrels are banned, we could pretty easily calculate dropping out of the market. But if the U.S. Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security, which I think is called the BIS, it's like an acronym after an acronym, if they find a way to exclude renewable diesel from such a ban, then we have a very interesting domestic market situation that could drastically change the export picture. So, you know, if renewable diesel was excluded, you'd have, at least in the short term, increased availability of conventional diesel. So, that could supply domestic consumption. And then that could drive prices low enough to, you know, reopen or at least widen the ARB for renewable diesel for HVO to be exported.
But it's not quite black and white. So, what Denise also cited in her analysis was that any ban would also affect the U.S. Renewable Fuel Standard, the RFS. So, while an exporter of renewable diesel, you know, loses corresponding RIN credits, if that fuel is blended into domestic supply, those credits would remain viable for compliance. So, that could potentially lower compliance costs in the short term. But yet any cut in fuel runs, because we don't have any way to store all of the diesel that we would suddenly have shoring up here domestically, would affect both the available supply of diesel to produce renewable diesel and future RIN credit generation. So, that would leave obligated participants reliant on buying any remaining D4 RINs. So, I guess the short of it is, it's messy, it's clear as mud, and we are watching it unfold in real time and reporting very closely.
Giulia: It's clear as mud. Perfect. So, I'm sure we'll come back with more questions on this. Just to continue on the switch in the focus a bit more on the domestic market in the U.S., of course, it's an interesting market for renewables, and each state government has the power to create their own incentive programs for energy transition. So, taking into account both the federal EPA mandates we've discussed, as well as the disruptions to distillate supply that we are feeling worldwide, how has the overall picture for renewable diesel changed in the U.S. this year?
Philip: Yeah. This is definitely my wheelhouse, being that my overview is North America. So, the short of it is that state-level programs have driven particularly strong adoption of renewable diesel, especially on the U.S. West Coast. So, California, in the United States, remains by far the largest renewable diesel market in the country. And, you know, depending on what period you're looking at specifically, California has consumed the overwhelming majority of domestic renewable diesel. This is basically...So, again, I say the short of it, it's like making a long story longer, but California really has the most aggressive fuel standards in the U.S. They're set by the California Air Resources Board, which is known as CARB, and it's the most robust incentive program in the country for consuming renewable fuels as well.
So, it's a combination of three deficits and credit programs. Argus refers to those programs as the attribute stack for assessing renewable diesel indexes in the State of California. And renewable diesel, which is mainly R99, most often trades in California as a differential to the ultra-low-sulfur diesel CARB complex, plus that attribute stack. So, this year, with conventional diesel prices so high on the back of these global supply disruptions, renewable diesel, the R99, has often been significantly discounted to CARB diesel in California, you know, as you take into account their program.
So, for years, the conversation was whether renewable diesel could compete economically with petroleum diesel. But in parts of the U.S. this year, RD has become attractive enough that it was directly displacing petroleum diesel, rather than just competing with, let's say, biodiesel blending requirements. And that's really remarkable. I think that really highlights how important renewable diesel is to the U.S. domestic security in terms of the overall fuel picture. I mean, we're already seeing multiple states indicate, at least, you know, I'd say renewed interest in looking at renewable diesel as they're feeling the pinch, and recognize that perhaps something that is domestically produced is not reliant on fossil diesel is the way to go.
Giulia: Thank you, Philip. This complexity around California is quite interesting. I'm not an expert by any means on the U.S. markets, but it's my understanding that there are significant market differences regionally within the state as well, right? Could you explain to me, but also to anyone listening, how we're assessing RD prices in that market compared to other states in the U.S.?
Philip: Yeah. Yeah, sure. I'm glad you asked. So, California is an interesting and very unique market. So, beginning in 2023, Argus launched market-surveyed bulk assessments for the California R99. And those assessments captured spot values priced as CARB, ULSD, like we talked about earlier, plus that attribute stack for head-of-pipeline transactions at really two key terminals. It was at Kinder Morgan's Watson Terminal near Los Angeles, and then Kinder Morgan's Concord Terminal near San Francisco. And really, the California market is split into those two regions. It's Northern California pricing around San Francisco, and Southern California pricing around Los Angeles.
So, a year later, Argus expanded that coverage. We launched four additional bulk assessments for renewable diesel. We did an FOB barge in the Gulf Coast. We did a delivered barge in New York Harbor. And then we did delivered rail in both Southern and Northern California. So, you already get the idea of how complicated the California picture is. In that state, we're monitoring and reporting renewable diesel, R99, traded as a differential to 9MX ULSD, traded as CARB ULSD plus attribute stacks. And we're doing so across both head-of-pipe and rail delivery modalities in both Northern and Southern California. So, it's a market that is complicated. It's niche. But it's also dynamic. And it's sort of the perfect place to really try to drive some transparency and some clear understanding of these assessments for our customers.
And because of that, in May of this year, in 2026, we launched one of our Argus Open Markets platforms for California R99. So, Argus Open Markets, or AOM for short, are trade initiation platforms that enable transparent price discovery for various markets. In the case of California, our AOM enables that transparent price discovery for renewable diesel in both Northern and Southern California. And it's across both the head-of-pipe and rail delivery modalities for both pricing options.
Giulia: Thanks a lot, Philip. I think that's all we have time for today, but I'm sure we'll need to pick this conversation up soon, given everything that's going on. Thank you very much for your time.
Giulia: No, thank you. Thank you for your time. I appreciate it. I hope I answered some of your questions.
Giulia: You did. And thank you everyone for listening. For any outstanding questions that we didn't manage to address today, please do not hesitate to reach out to us at oil-products@argusmedia.com. Thank you, and speak soon.